VYACHESLAV CHORNOVIL
By Dick Fidler
New evidence of the persecution of prosocialist critics of the bureaucracy in the Soviet Union has come to light in a couple of articles just published in the January 6 and 8 issues of the Toronto Telegran. :
The copyrighted articles are based on an eighty-page petition and a book smuggled out of the USSR. The author of both is a young Ukrainian, Vyacheslav Chornovil. The manuscript of the book has been termed by a leading North American "Sovietologist," Prof. B.R.Bociurkiw of the University of Alberta's Department of Political Science, "a remarkable document .-.of the stature of the Sinyavsky-Daniel trial transcript."
Two months ago, on November 15, the 29-year-old Chornovil was sentenced to three years in a labor camp, at a secret trial in Lvov in the western Ukraine, near the Polish border. He was convicted under the all-inclusive Article 62 of the Soviet Criminal Code, which provides for imprisonment for anywhere up to seven years for “anti-Soviet activities." In Chornovil's case, these "activities" consisted, among other things, of circulating an eighty-page document of charges against the "illegalities" being perpetrated by the courts, the KGB [secret police], and other authorities.
It all began in 1965, in the days of the Sinyavsky-Daniel affair. According to the Telegram's Peter Worthington, who was in Moscow at the time, their arrests and trial "were part of a wide 'purge' at the time." Among other victims were twenty Ukrainian writers, artists, teachers and scientists.
Worthington and the Telegram tell us little as to their specific views, except the following: "None of them are anti-Soviet so much as they are pro- Ukrainian. They base their defence on the dictums of V.I.Lenin and the pronouncements of Karl Marx. They are in no way agents of Imperialism, CIA informers, or enemies of the Soviet state. Mostly they don't attack Communism -- even Chornovil makes a point of emphasizing his belief in the teachings of Lenin."
They were tried -- six months after their arrest -- under the infamous Article 62. The trials were secret. They were found guilty of "anti-Soviet activity" and sentenced to terms of up to six years.
Vyacheslav Chornovil, a secret of the Komsomol (Communist Youth League], was assigned to cover the trials in Lvov for Kiev television. So shocked was he at how "socialist legality" was distorted, however, that when he was called upon to give evidence he refused on the grounds that a closed trial was illegal. He was subsequently charged under Article 172 (refusal to give evidence) but when he protested that it was illegal to charge someone for refusing to partake in an illegal trial, he was charged once again under Article 62 (anti-Soviet activities). He was sentenced to three years.
In his Telegram articles, Worthington cites extensively from Chornovil's manuscript and petition, more than enough to show that the young Ukrainian critic is completely pro-Soviet and anticapitalist. In his petition, Chornovil "meticulously details his complaints and gives reasons for his behaviour.
"*Not to disclose my own attitude towards that which is taking place would mean to become a taciturn participant in the wanton disregard of Socialist Legality,' he writes...
"He feels that the closed trials were held to ‘intimidate' the general public and notes: ‘After spending six or seven months in the hands of the KGB they will tell all...and will be given in due count five or six "rightful" years of hard labor.'
"He notes wryly: ‘Prosecution for telling anecdotes...will be of assistance in a radical solution to the housing crisis in larger cities. In its devout application, Article 62 of the Criminal Code makes it possible to raise the population of camps to Stalin's levels, or even to exceed them.'
"The prevailing attitude of the Soviet hierarchy, says Chornovil, is that ‘All oppositional tendencies and acts within our country are considered to be exclusively the results of the influence of bourgeois propaganda and intelligence services. If by a wave of a magic wand the bourgeois world would suddenly cease to exist, prosperity would rule supreme. The fate of village folk without passports [required for domestic travel], who are condemned to life on a collective farm, would suddenly be eternal happiness.'
“He continues: 'For five years I studied faithfully Marxism-Leninism at the university -- just recently I passed my Master's examination in Marxist- Leninist philosophy. Then, all of a sudden and quite by accident I lay my hands
-66-
on a Ukrainisn book published abroad and I'm accused of being a bourgeois nationalist..-or I read a leaflet from Peking and I become a follower of Mao Tse-tung -.-.or I listen to a speech by the Pope on the radio and I become a Jesuit...
"'Without doubt Marxism-Leninism is stronger than bourgeois ideology. Yet in our country the reading of a book published in the West makes one subject to prosecution.....'"
Chornovil points to the fact that one can purchase Soviet bocks and news~ papers in Western countries, and asks, ironically, "Is it possible that non- Marxists have absorbed the Marxist- Leninist thesis better than our leaders .--that to disallow the spreading of ideas means to increase their strength and attractiveness?"
Worthington continues his summary of Chornovil's account:
“Chornovil quotes the Constitution which stresses the inviolability of a citizen's home, his right tc privacy and to receive mail unopened by anyone. He quotes Article 130 of the Criminal Code which states that : 'Illegal searches, illegal evictions or other acts which violate the citizen's dwellings by a state official are punishable by imprisonment.'
"Then he tells of medical student M. Plakhotniuk finding his room bugged... of another discovering KGB recording devices in his attic...of 'informers' being planted in communal apartments...of an electronically equipped ‘birthday present' being given to bedridden writer Yevhen Kontsevich...of secret searches, secret arrests, secret trials -- all of which Chornovil says are contrary to the Criminal Code as well as to the Soviet Constitution.
"In short," Worthington continues, "he does not object so much to the arrest and trial of the 20 cases he documents and on whose behalf he is petitioning the highest authorities, as he does to the manner in which it was all conducted, in violation of the law."
Chornovil explains how "confessions" are occasionally extracted from the innocent victims of these frameup procedures.
"He notes: 'It is not necessary to slam doors on fingers, to stick needles under fingernails, or to beat faces in order to persuade a person to regard his deeds as terrible crimes or to force him to confess everything.
"tall that is needed is to lock a man in a stone shack with bars...to keep him in solitary for six months...to constantly hammer into him feelings of guilt -.-to morally terrorize, threaten and promise...and usually the required testimony will be squeezed out by the time of the trial.' -
"He quotes one of his 20 'criminals,' medical student Yaroslav Havrych, then 29, as apologizing to a woman whom he had born witness against: 'In 105 days one can be taught to lie.'
"For allegedly spreading anti-~ Soviet propaganda Havrych got five years, subsequently reduced to three years which he is now serving.
"Chornovil tells of indignities KGB officers inflict on women 'offenders' by blackmail, obscenities, stripping and insulting them. Says Chornovil: ‘If a prisoner's fate is decided by the KGB, why do we need the comedy of trials at all -- not to mention closed trials?'
"If such extreme measures as illegally long pre-trial custody followed by closed trials are necessary for accused ‘intellectuals' Chornovil asks: ‘What qualifications should then be given to subversion, murderers, embez~ zlers of state property? Is it possible that we are going back to Stalin's times when murderers were called ‘socially congenial' while writers and artists were considered 'people's enemies'?
"'The whole purpose seems to be to break the prisoner's will and to force him to say memorized words at the trial.'"
Chornovil describes what happened when he declared that he would not give evidence at a closed trial because he "did not wish to participate in a flagrant violation of Socialist Legality."
"The prosecutor jumped up and called me an enemy who has no right to speak of Socialist Legality. Soldiers were ordered to remove me from the court and did it so quickly that I was unable to ask the prosecutor why I, who was protesting against the revival of the wantonness of Cult-of-Personality fame, the closed tribunal, am branded an enemy while he, who in his capacity as the regional public prosecutor was sanctioning this gross violation of the letter and spirit of the law claims to be a friend of the Soviet system..."
When the twenty accused were convicted and sentenced, Chornovil relates, two women poets among the carefully chosen witnesses in the packed courtroom threw flowers to the prisoners. They were immediately seized and interrogated. In the streets outside the courtroom, demonstrators throwing more flowers and shout~
ing encouragement, "bravo...glory," were finally dispersed with fire hoses.
Perhaps the most impressive indication of the difficulties under which Soviet oppositionists labor, is contained in a follow-up story by Worthington in the Telegram which describes the case of Svyatoslave Karavansky. Karavansky's experiences are outlined by Chornovil, but part of Worthington's information also comes from one John Kolasky, a Toronto member of the Communist party of Canada.
Apparently, Karavansky, while still in his early twenties in Odessa during the war, joined an underground organization dedicated to Ukrainian nationalism. In 1944, he was sentenced to twenty-five years. The Telegram story continues:
"Today Karavansky explains that he was 'driven' to his 'mistake' of joining the organization by the ‘ugliness... the repugnant personality cult of Stalin... that demoralizing influence upon the hearts and souls of those Soviet citizens who recognized it as inhibiting development.'
"He feels that the official discrediting of Stalin's policies vindicates his earlier ‘errors.'
"After serving 16 years and five months, Karavansky was released in 1960 when the maximum prison sentence in the USSR was reduced from 25 to 15 years.
"He returned to Odessa where he married, went to university and worked as a poet-translator. During his time in the camps he had compiled a massive dictionary of Ukrainian rhymes which Soviet scholars praised as an ‘astonishing achievement' which normally would have required the collective effort of a university.
"Karavansky says the KGB advised him not to talk of the past, and for five years in Odessa he wrote, worked and made up for the years that had been stolen from his life.
"In February, 1965, he made his mistake. He sent a detailed documented petition to the State Prosecutor complaining that the minister of education for the Ukraine was condoning and encouraging discrimination against Ukrainian students in violation of the principles of Lenin, and of the Soviet constitution and of Soviet law." .
When a copy of this petition was found in the possession of Kolasky, a member of the Canadian Communist party, who was studying at the Higher Party School of the Central Committee in Kiev, Karavansky was accused (the Telegram says) of being "eager for the rotten lure of unscrupulous foreigners." Kolasky, a member of the CP for thirty years, who says he was collecting material on how the Soviets were trying to destroy the Ukrainian culture and replace it with Russian, says that "in essence Karavansky's observations are true." Kolasky says that the KGB held him two weeks for questioning, and confiscated all his papers.
In November, 1965, Karavansky was seized and, without trial or explanation, thrown into a labor camp to serve the remaining eight years and seven months of his 25-year sentence. Since then, Karavansky, still unbroken, has been fighting back in the only way open to him -- by petitions to higher authorities, such as the Supreme Court and the Union of Journalists.
In his petitions, he also appeals against injustices which have been committed against others. In a petition to the People's Court of Odessa which Worthington cites, Karavansky urges "that the dictums of Leninism and socialist legality be followed, and that Stalinism not be repeated or resurrected."
That the treatment suffered by these opponents of the privileged layers runs counter to all the fine-sounding phrases about "building Communism," is eloquently stated by Vyacheslav Chornovil himself:
"The highest material saturation without free thought and free will does not constitute Communism. Rather it constitutes a great prison in which the food ration for prisoners has simpl* heen increased...
"It has been declared that in our country today, Communism is becoming a reality; that today's generation of Soviet people will live in Communisn... Perhaps our generation will live during declared Communism, the same as we are presently living in a declared sovereign republic, have declared freedoms and a declared Socialist law.
"But more than once history has refuted the principle that the ends justify the means. The most equitable society cannot be built by means of terror, by the suppression of civic impulses in people...Improper methods only distort the end...
WIDE