Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

Wide Sympathy in Soviet Union for Trial Victims-- by George Saunders

· World Outlook Vol. 6, No. 3, 26 January 1968 · pp 68-70 · 815 words

Soviet Union

SYMPATHY IN SOVIET UNION FOR TRIAL VICTIMS

By George Saunders

One of the most significant aspects of the case involving Aleksandr Ginzburg, Yuri Galanskov, Aleksei Dobrovolsky and Vera Lashkova is the substantial support the defendants received from other Soviet citizens. Here is one more instance of the shattering of the Stalinist monolith, this time from within.

Two petitions on behalf of Ginzburg and the others were addressed to Soviet judicial authorities and Izvestia in the months preceding the trial. The first was sent in October by more than 100 intellectuals, asking assurances that the trial be public. The second was issued in early December by forty-four persons. It stressed the illegality of holding the accused longer than ten months.

A third appeal, on the eve of the trial, was sent to the court where the case would be tried, with copies to Brezhnev, Kosygin, and Podgorny. Signed by thirty-one personalities, including young novelist Vasily Aksyonov, poetess Bella Akhmadullina, and Lenin Prize winning mathematician Igor Shafarevich, the appeal urged full press coverage and inpartial selection of witnesses.

The third appeal argued that conpilation of material on the Sinyavsky- Daniel case should not be grounds for prosecution. It added that the trial could not "contribute to an improvement of the atmosphere of a society that not long ago was witness to mass rehabilitations of people who were condemned on false charges."

In a perhaps related development there was also news, on the eve of the trial, of a petition signed by some 180 Moscow intellectuals, including novelist Veniamin Kaverin. This petition urged the Supreme Soviet, the highest legal body, to enforce the constitutional guarantee of freedom of the press by abolishing press censorship.

During the trial itself there was a significant turnout of sympathizers of the defendants each day at the courtroom, although few could gain admittance. Several attempted to act as witnesses for the defense, in spite of extreme pressures against them for doing so.

Prominent among sympathizers were historian Pavel Yakir, son of the General Yakir who was shot along with Tukhachevsky and others in Stalin's 1937 purge of the Red Army high command. Also prominent was ex-Major General Pyotr Grigorenko, former professor of cybernetics at the Frunze Military Acadeny.

Grigorenko had reportedly been removed from his post in 1961 because of a dispute with then Premier Khrushchev. In 1964 he had been stripped of his commission and put in a mental institution, a frequently used method of reprisal against dissident elements. Released in 1966, he is said to have allied himself with oppositional writers. One report was that his difficulties began when he sent Khrushchev a letter protesting discrimination against Jews in the Soviet army.

Most prominent in support of the defendants, of course, were Mrs. Larisa Daniel, wife of the imprisoned writer Yuli Daniel, and Pavel Litvinov, grandson of Stalin's foreign minister in the thirties, Maxim Litvinov. Litvinov came to prominence only a few weeks before this trial, in connection with another, earlier attempt to support Ginzburg, Galanskov, and the others.

A surprising document hit the world press in late December. It was an open letter by Litvinov addressed to four Soviet papers and to the main daily papers of the French and Italian Communist parties. (None of those papers printed the letter or indicated any knowledge of it, to the discredit especially of the French and Italian Communist leaderships.)

Litvinov's letter related to the Sinyavsky-Daniel and Ginzburg-Galanskov cases, but it was more directly linked with a third trial of literary dissidents, one held last August and involving particularly a youth named Vladimir Bukovsky. A look at the background of the Bukovsky case is necessary.

The arrest of Galanskov and the others on January 19, 1967, was met with an immediate demonstration of support. Some fifty persons gathered three days later in downtown Moscow and unfurled banners calling for repeal of Article 70. This was the law under which Sinyavsky and Daniel had been convicted and by which Galanskov and the others were clearly threatened.

In standing up for Galanskov and the others, Bukovsky himself became a victim. He and two others, Vadim Delone and Yevgeny Kushchev, were arrested for participating in the demonstration. They too were held without trial for many months. At last, late in August 1967, they were tried.

Bukovsky, who assumed responsibility for having organized the demon-

~70-

from his teaching job in the physics department of the Institute of Precision Chemical Technology. The alleged ground for the dismissal was "breach of work discipline." The dismissal reportedly became effective January 3. Whether the Kosygin~Brezhnev regime will exact fur~ ther reprisals remains to be seen. To be fired from a job in the Soviet Union is a serious matter since control over hiring and firing is in the hands of the government which in turn expresses the will of the privileged ruling caste.

[Reproduced below is the text of the

← The Case of Vyacheslav Chornovil · Text of Pavel Litvinov's and Larisa Daniel's Denunciation of Trial →

Something wrong on this page?