Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

Mrs. Lyudmila I. Ginsburg Protests Slander of Her Son

· World Outlook Vol. 6, No. 6, 16 February 1968 · pp 126-128 · 1,275 words

Stalinism Vietnam and Indochina

LYUDMILA I. GINSBURG PROTESTS SLANDER OF HER SON

By Gerry Foley

Bold counterattacks in the Soviet Union against the official campaign of slander of the four dissident intellectuals sentenced on January 12 for circulating a record of the Sinyavsky-Daniel trial seem to mark a new stage in the escalating rebellion of the intellectuals against heavy-handed bureaucratic thoughtcontrol and intimidation.

The trial of these four, Aleksandr Ginsburg, Yuri Galanskov, Aleksei Dobrovolsky and Vera Lashkova, was preceded by a wave of exceptionally sharp protests which brought new repressions against the protesters. However, if the slander canpaign which was unleashed against these four in the Soviet press after they received their harsh sentences was intended to intimidate further protest, it has not achieved its purpose.

Along with new and outspoken protests by prominent writers and intellec-— tuals, Aleksandr Ginsburg's mother, Mrs. Lyudmila I. Ginsburg, has announced her intention to sue Komsomolskaya Pravda, the organ of the Young Communist League, for false allegations against her son.

In its article on the trial of the four appearing on January 18, Komsomolskaya Pravda published what purported to be extracts from the court record and stated, among other things, that Ginsburg was unmasked at the trial as an agent of NTS [Natsional Trudovoi Soyuz -- National Workers Alliance, an ultrareactionary emigré organization].

Mrs. Ginsburg's intention and her denunciations of the distorted accounts of her son's trial were learned from copies of a letter by her to Komsomolskaya Pravda circulating in Moscow. This letter has not been published by Komsomolskaya Pravda and no reporters without clearance from the Soviet authorities were allowed to attend a news conference given by Mrs. Ginsburg on January 19.

In her letter, Mrs. Ginsburg specifically denied reports that espionage equipment and NTS literature had been found in her son's apartment or that such accusations had even seriously been made at the trial.

An excerpt from her letter, cited in the New York Times of February 4, seems illustrative of the method used by the Stalinist inquisitors and their journalistic henchmen in fabricating this slander.

"The prosecutor, having called him an agent of the N.T.S., admitted in court that he had used the wrong word inadvertently. Evidently, also by inadvertence, this verbal mistake got into the text of the accusation. However, none of the evidence in the case, none of the depositions of the witnesses, not one question from the prosecutor even touched on this point."

Mrs. Ginsburg's protests were seconded in a letter to Komsomolskaya Pravda by Yevgeny I. Kushev, a codefendant of Ginsburg's who was given a one-year suspended sentence. Kushev stated in his letter, which is quoted in the New York Times of February 7, that Komsomolskaya Pravda had distorted his testimony to make it appear that he had accused Ginsburg and the other defendants of distributing NTIS leaflets. He demanded an editorial retraction.

According to the 1960 criminal code of the Russian Republic of the Soviet Union, unfounded accusations of crimes against the state are punishable by five years deprivation of liberty, a sentence equal to that received by Aleksandr Ginsburg. This provision in the Russian code may represent a concession to the revulsion against the political slanders of the Stalin period. However, Mrs.

Ginsburg's courage in threatening to take Soviet law at its word is evident in view of the savage sentences which her son and his companions received for their protests against violations of Soviet law in the Sinyavsky-Daniel case.

Her spirited defense of her son marks a sharp contrast to the Stalin period when fear was so great that no one dared protest the disappearance of victims, and even close friends and relatives were afraid to shelter their children.

At the same time, renewed protests py Soviet intellectuals are being heard. The New York Times of February 7 reports two particularly emphatic statements.

A letter of protest against the Ginsburg trial by two sons of the very well-known Soviet writer Vera Panova has been sent to the Soviet Supreme Court, the party politburo and the Supreme Soviet. The two, Boris B. Vakhtin, a member of the Writers Union, and Yuri B. Vakhtin, a biologist, denounced "an abnormal atmosphere" surrounding the trial, and violations of legality by the authorities. A personal note in their protest made a poignant counterpoint to Mrs. Ginsburg's statements:

"We lost our father during the Stalinist mass purges. He was posthumously rehabilitated. We cannot accept the thought that there could be a repetition of the horrors endured by our country and people, a repetition of the terrible time of lawlessness and bestiality."

Also, a letter signed by fifty-two writers, scientists, university teachers, and others is being circulated. It condemns the secrecy of this and other such trials; it declares that "a legally conducted and organized trial need not fear the glare of publicity." The letter charges that impartial observers having been barred from the Ginsburg trial, newspapers were able to print accounts "distorting the trial and deceiving readers."

The official attempt to slander Ginsburg and his codefendants and the response to it by Soviet intellectuals is the latest development in a series of ever harder blows and counterblows exchanged between the bureaucratic authorities and Soviet intellectuals seeking freedom of expression.

Ginsburg and the other three were sentenced for protesting the Daniel- Sinyavsky trial. Vladimir Bukovsky, a young student who led a demonstration of support for Ginsburg and the others when they were first arrested, was railroaded to prison. An attempt by Pavel Litvinov, the grandson of Stalin's foreign minister Maxim Litvinov, to circulate a record of the proceedings of Bukovsky's trial and to protest its arbitrary character brought reprisals against hin. .

CAO KY READY TO ARM THE PEOPLE?

Probably the rashest promise to be made by anyone in either Washington or Saigon in the aftermath of the victory rolled up by the National Liberation Front, was the one ventured by Vice- President Nguyen Cao Ky.

The swashbuckling puppet, who has avowed that his greatest hero is Hitler, told newsmen after taping a statement for television that arms would be distributed to loyal citizens in South Vietnam "by next week."

"The former Premier, who was wearing a green combat uniform and had a flak jacket folded on the desk beside him, appeared calm. Not a hair was out of place. He spoke slowly, both in English and Vietnamese, puffing Salems as he considered the answer to each question."

He announced that he.was chairman of a task force assigned to restore security to Saigon and the countryside.

The rural areas would be armed first, he said, since the threat from "the Communists" was greatest there. Next to be armed will be places where "we are sure the people are anti- Communist nationalists."

It might be suggested that Ky would do well to speed up arming the people, otherwise the U.S. forces and the puppet government troops might face an unduly high rate of loss of arms from sectors burning to move into action. Or the National Liberation Front might beat him in distributing guns to the populace, and how would he feel about that? It is also questionable whether Ky will be altogether pleased with the people's choice of targets once they get their hands on some guns.

But he may have had a completely different objective in mind. He told the press that it had become clear to him that the 600,000 troops under his command, and the 500,000 U.S. troops fighting with them are not sufficient to meet the foe and will have to be expanded.

Could he, by chance, be angling for a few hundred thousand more GI's to be shipped across the Pacific?

EDITOR OF “PRAVDA"

← National Liberation Front Deepens Revolutionary Tie to Masses · Baitor be "Pravda" Denounces Solzhenitsyn Cao Ky Ready to Arm the People? →

Something wrong on this page?