EXCERPTS FROM LITVINOV'S LETTER ON BUKOVSKY CASE
One of those who figured most prominently in support of four dissident Soviet writers, sentenced January 12 to prison terms ranging up to seven years, was Pavel M. Litvinov, the grandson of Maxim M. Litvinov, Stalin's one-time foreign minister. [For text of Litvinov's statement on that trial, issued jointly with Larisa Daniel, wife of the imprisoned Soviet writer Yuli Daniel, see World Outlook, January 26, p. 69.]
Litvinov first came to prominence as a voice supporting dissident, antibureaucratic writers only a few weeks before the January trial, when an open letter issued by him appeared in the world press.
The open letter pertained to an earlier trial of three literary rebels which took place last August. The chief defendant in that trial was Vladimir Bukovsky, who was sentenced to three years imprisonment for leading a demonstration for free speech in January 1967 in Moscow.
Litvinov's letter reported a conversation between himself and a secret police officer named Gostev, in which Litvinov was warned not to make public the transcript of the Bukovsky trial, as they knew he was preparing to do.
The Soviet bureaucracy has not only failed to make public the proceedings of its trials of recent years aimed against political dissidents. It has also carried out reprisals against anyone making that information public. It thereby shows its own guilty conscience and fear of its repressive actions becoming known.
The real "crime," for example, for which the four young defendants were sentenced in January was not that they were "foreign agents" (as the obvious frame-up claimed).It was that they had compiled and published the transcript and other materials relating to the 1965 trial of anti-Stalinist writers Andrei Sinyavsky and Yuli Daniel.
The following excerpts from Litvinov's letter give some flavor of the obstacles Soviet citizens have to contend with in their struggle for realization of the socialist democracy supposedly assured by the Soviet constitution. After the police officer Gostev's initial warning, Litvinov contended he was doing nothing illegal. The conversation continued as follows:
"I: ...What kind of slander could there be in recording the hearing of a case before a Soviet court?
"Gostev: Well, your notes will be a biased distortion of facts and a slander of the court's actions and that would be proved by the agency competent to handle such cases.
"I: How can you possibly know that? Instead of starting a new case, you yourself should publish the record of this criminal trial and in this way kill the rumors circulating in Moscow.
"Gostev: And why do we need to publish it? It is an ordinary criminal case of disturbance of the peace.
"I: If so, it is all the more inportant to give information about it, to let all the people see that it is really an ordinary case.
"Gostev: Vecherniaia Moskva of Sept. 4, 1967, gives all the information about the case. All that has to be known about that trial is in there."
Vecherniaia Moskva, a Moscow evening paper, ran four short paragraphs on the case, stating that all three defendants had pleaded guilty. Litvinov pointed out that Bukovsky had not pleaded guilty at all. Gostev's reply was, "What does it matter whether he pleaded guilty or not? The court found him guilty. Consequently, he is guilty."
Further on, the conversation went as follows:
"Gostev: ...And in general, Pavel Mikhailovich, have in mind: Vecherniaia Moskva has printed all that the Soviet people should know about this case and this information is completely true and we warn you that if not only you, but your friends or anybody makes this record [public], you specifically will be held responsible for it. You understand very well that such a record can be used by our ideological enemies, especially on the eve of the 50th anniversary of Soviet power.
"I: But I do not know of any law that would prohibit the dissemination of a nonsecret document only because it might be misused by somebody. Much critical material in Soviet newspapers might also be misused by somebody."
NEW