Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The Socialism Antoni Zambrowski Wants for Poland

World Outlook Vol. 6, No. 15, 19 April 1968 · pp 352-354 · 2,109 words

Eastern Europe Stalinism Communist parties Italy

SOCIALISM ANTONI ZAMBROWSKI WANTS FOR POLAND

[Among the young people who have been mentioned as leading figures in the current Polish student rebellion, the name of Antoni Zambrowski, 42, has appeared along with those of Jacek Kuron, Karol Modzelewski, and Adam Michnik. All four have reportedly been arrested since the student demonstrations broke out.

{Kuron and Modzelewski are better known as the former Warsaw University instructors who were first jailed in 1965 for circulating a document calling for a revolution to establish workers democracy based on workers councils. They also called for a revolutionary anti-imperialist foreign policy and spoke favorably of the creative example of revolutionary Cuba. They were released in 1967, only to be rearrested in the present crisis.

{Young Zambrowski was a member of the Warsaw University teaching staff also. In the summer of 1966 his critical communist opinions came to the attention of the bureaucratic party leadership, apparently as a result of a May Day article he had written. He was asked to present his views to the party Control Commission in writing, which he did. Because of this document he was expelled from the party, fired from his job at the university, and given a job in an engineering concern.

{Zambrowski's background is similar to that of Kuron and Modzelewski in another respect. The fathers of all three held important posts in the party regime. The father of Zambrowski, Roman Zambrowski, has long been a prominent government figure, both in the Stalin era and under Gomulka. During the present disturbances, the elder Zambrowski was ousted from his post as a reprisal for his son's indiscretions. The Zambrowskis are also of Jewish origin, which did not help the father's fortunes once Gomulka and company began their virulent campaign against "Zionists, old Stalinists, and revisionists." Roman Zambrowski was one of the first victims of the ugly purge now sweeping the Polish party.

(The text of Antoni Zambrowski's 1966 statement to the Control Commission has become available. We reprint it below, from the version in the March 22 London Times.

{What is most interesting about Zambrowski's statement is the indications it gives of fresh currents of socialist thought stirring among young people in postcapitalist Poland. He mentions several opposition groupings within the Polish party, and seems to represent a distinct point of view himself.

{[Zambrowski declares himself clos-— est to the standpoint of the Italian Communists, so far as the permitting of internal discussion within the party goes, and to the Yugoslavs, in regard to permitting a greater degree of democratiza-— tion in public life. He is not free of certain illusions over the extent of democracy in either the Italian CP or in Yugoslav society, but he is primarily using these as Communist examples that definitely improve on the Polish and Soviet models.

(Quite interesting also is Zambrowski's discussion of the views of Kuron and Modzelewski, who in their enphatic opposition to the bureaucratic government of the Polish workers state, wrongly call it a "new class" that must be overthrown by proletarian revolution.

(Marxists are careful to distinguish between the form of the governing apparatus and the class nature of the state. The governing bureaucracy, corrupt as it is, has no independent roots in property forms of its own; it is a privileged caste only, a parasitic growth upon socialized property forms. It is not rooted in the very economic and social system as classes historically have been.

(Zambrowski is right in regarding "the bureaucratic deformation of revolutionary power as a transitory phase," which arises "from the political superstructure and not from the foundations."

{It is not clear how firmly Kuron and Modzelewski are wedded to their mis-— take in theory, however. If there were freedom of discussion in "People's" Poland perhaps they would correct themselves in the light of criticism from persons like Zambrowski, or perhaps from revolutionary Marxists in the West.

{On one point, however, there is agreement all around. As Zambrowski put it, “depriving them of liberty has brought great political harm to our country as well as to Poland's reputation in the world." And that goes for the bureaucrats' treatment of Zambrowski and all the other young rebels as well.]

* * *

I am a Marxist and communist, and for this reason I am a member of our party. For me, joining the party was a simple consequence of my way of life. As a 13year-old boy I distributed pamphlets for the Polish Workers' (Communist) Party at the 1947 elections. In that same year I joined the Young Communists' League. But I must confess that, while accepting the ideological foundations of our party, I have a mass of reservations with respect

to its current policy. I feel more sympathy with the standpoint of such communist parties as the Italian Communist Party (PCI) or the Union of Communists of Yugo- Slavia (SKJ). In my view, if we applied the policies of the PCI or the SKJ in Poland, we should have less political difficulties and considerably more influence in society.

The most valuable part of the Yugoslav party's programme seems to me to be their different interpretation of the party's role in the exercising of power. At present our party apparatus provides, in the words of Comrade Gomulka, "a specific, centralized authority...steering a direct course and regulating the life of the whole country." This leads to "an identification of the party with the apparatus of people's power" and to "the duplication of the work of the state apparatus." Another important element of the Yugoslav party's policy is the system of Workers' Councils and social self-administration which is extended to all levels of economic and administrative power. Two consequences of this are the autonomy of the trade unions, which do not belong to the state system but are its partner, defending the interest of the working man, and the independent role of parliament towards government, thanks to which parliament genuinely is the highest organ of the the state. The role of the SELPJ, the equivalent of our Front of National Unity, is also. extremely valuable since it serves as a socialist tribunal of discussion. I approve of the Yugoslav party's policy of a consistent and systematic development of democracy inside both party and state.

Successive Stages

I think that the process of overcoming the consequences of Stalin's autoc-— racy was begun but not concluded by the twentieth and twenty-second Congresses of the Soviet Communist Party. I fully support the view of Comrade Togliatti expressed in his Yalta testament criticiz-— ing the policies of these communist parties which now hold power. It is a question of, in his words, "removing the system introduced by Stalin whereby democrat— ic freedoms and personal liberties were restricted and choked." The problem is that "the return to the Leninist norm, which ensured both inside and outside the party a broad freedom of speech and discussion in culture, art and also politics, is a slow process which is meeting some resistance. This slowness and resistance are incomprehensible to us."

I think the party should embark on a far-reaching programme for democratiz-— ing public life. This would entail successive stages in the controlled development of socialist democracy:

(1) the development of democracy inside the party by bringing back all the Leninist norms of party life, for instance, the right of individual members to organize different platforms at party conferences and congresses, and to put these platforms to the vote.

(2) the granting of independence to social organizations such as trade unions and youth organizations.

(4) a change in the voting regulations, beginning with the lowest organs of the state and leading up by successive stages of power to elections to the Sejm (Parliament). These new regulations would foresee elections to one-seat constituencies with several competing candidates from the Front of National Unity, perhaps representing the same parties now exist-— ing in Poland -- the United Workers' Party, the Peasants' Party and the Democratic Front. This would follow the example of the United Arab Republic and Tanzania.

(4) and only in the more distant future, a change to a political system which allowed a legal opposition, a party based on socialist principles and in accordance with the constitution of the Polish People's Republic.

The adoption of this programme, or one similar to it, which would gradually democratize our public life, would go a long way to relax the political tensions in our country. It would give our party the support of the broad masses of society.

view on the case of Jacek Kuron and Karol Modzelewski is as follows: Kuron and Modzelewski embarked on their activities through their impatience at the halting of the process of destalinization in Poland. Examples of this are the closing of the discussion club at the University of Warsaw, and the repressive measures taken against those who signed the letter of the 34 to the Prime Minister. These obstacles to consistent destalinization were taken by them as an expression of the class interest of a "power. elite," which is supposed to be building a new class to exploit the proletariat. Taking this view of the situation, they decided upon the historical inevitability of a social revolution of the proletariat. The victory of this revolution would open the way to the true building of socialism. The programme and tactics of this revolution were to be an exact copy of those of the Communist International, of which before the war the Communist Party of Poland formed part.

Transitory Phase

I do not support their point of view since I consider the changes begun by the October revolution of 1917 to be

socialist changes. I review the bureaucratic deformation of revolutionary power as a transitory phase, peculiar to the period of construction of socialism -- a disease which can be diagnosed and effectively cured by applying Marxist theory. It arises from the political superstructure and not from the foundations. This is why social revolution is not now inevitable. The problem is to repair socialism,-not to bring it about by a violent agitation of the present state. The fight against the bureaucratic distortions of revolutionary power must be carried on so as not to endanger the achievements of socialism and, above all, socialist power.

While I reject the opinions of Kuron and Modzelewski, I still think that depriving them of liberty has brought great political harm to our country as well as to Poland's reputation in the world. The worst aspect of the affair has been the use of the Shorter Criminal Code against this communist opposition, a Code which was introduced just after the war during a period of national reconstruc-— tion, and was aimed against such reactionary underground organizations as the "Freedom and Independence" and "National Armed Forces" movements. I can see no justification in treating opposition groups within our party -- such as the groups of Kuron and Modzelewski, of Badowski and Hass, or of Kazimierz Mijal -in the same way that the "National Armed Forces" bandits were treated. One is reminded of the type of behaviour that was outlined to us by Comrade Gomulka in his criticism of the methods used by Stalin to fight opposition within the Bolshevik movement.

My view on the conflict with the Church hierarchy is as follows: We cannot consolidate the achievements of socialism without the firm support of the whole of the working class. But unfortunately the vast majority of the members of our working class are believers. Our dialogue with Roman Catholics is designed to ensure for our party the support of the working masses. We cannot allow the quarrel with Cardinal Wyszynski to be treated by the Catholic masses as a "Kulturkampf" against the Church, since this would isolate us for an important part of the society. Unfortunately the events of past years have combined with the present confrontation with the episcopate to give rise to such suspicions. Catholics have taken great exception to the difficulties they encounter in building new churches and religious schools, to the refusal to allow the Pope to come to Poland, as well as to “sacrilegious" acts of the People's Militia against a vehicle carrying an image of the Virgin Mary. All this is grist to the mill of reactionary clerics.

In reference to my May 1 article,.. I can only say that the most questioned part of my article does contain ideas which are widespread among modern Marxists. What is more, these ideas are a simple continuation of the ideas of Marx, Engels, and Lenin, which were silenced during the Stalinist period and brought into the daylight after the twentieth congress of the Soviet Communist Party -- or earlier by the Yugoslav conmunists.

← Zengakuren Leads New Demonstrations at Army Hospital and Airport · Widespread Sympathy in Brazil for Student Demonstrators →

Something wrong on this page?