KOSYGIN-BREZHNEV THREATEN DISSENTERS IN USSR WITH POLICE CLUB
By George Saunders
As protests by Soviet intellectuals over the recent trials of young rebels and dissenters broaden in scope, the Brezhnev—Kosygin regime has felt called upon to intensify its counterpressures.
This was evident in the major speech by General Secretary Leonid Brezhnev on March 29, warning that protesters "cannot go unpunished." The April 9-10 meeting of the Central Committee of the Communist party of the Soviet Union [CPSU] also reflected the regime's concern over growing rank-and-file defiance at a time of turmoil in neighboring Poland and Czechoslovakia.
Previous to these events, the main literary paper, Literaturnaya Gazeta, on March 27, ran a big article by its chief editor, Aleksandr Chakovsky, who is also an official of the Soviet Writers Union. Chakovsky polemicized at length against some of the recent protest statements by intellectuals such as Pavel Litvinov. Among authors and signers of these statements have been many leading writers and scientists and other prominent persons. However, the Soviet press has not printed their statements. Ironically, Chakovsky gave considerable space to quotes from letters of a different kind -- written by apologists for the trials, all previously unknown figures.
Among Chakovsky's more benevolent suggestions was that the young people recently jailed might better have been exiled and denied Soviet citizenship.
A similar line was pursued in an article by Sergei Mikhalkov, another bureaucrat of the Writers Union. Writing in the March 30 Komsomolskaya Pravda, the Young Communist League paper, he demanded closer ideological supervision for writers who are party members, and complained that some prominent writers were still defying warnings and agitating against the trials.
The Moscow party organization has held a series of meetings to denounce dissidents. Two well~known writers, Stepan Shchipachev and Aleksei Surkov, gave speeches at such a meeting, blasting “those who sign letters which provide nourishment for imperialist propaganda."
The positions taken by Surkov and Shchipachev are symptomatic of the pressure being applied by the régime now. Neither was ever an outstanding anti- Stalinist or "liberalizer," although in recent years both have gone along with the majority of the writers community in favoring relaxation of literary controls. Both were among the great number criticized during Khrushchev's campaign against "abstract art" in 1964. And in 1966, Surkov was one of the signers of a petition opposing a possible rehabilitation of Stalin at the Twenty-third Congress of the CPSU.
That these two figures have now crumbled before the regime's pressure shows that a drive is on to break away the weaker wills, the more bureaucratic elements. A strong spirit of solidarity among the writers has been a limiting factor on the regime for several years, and the intention seems to be to break up this solidarity.
But pressure, intimidation, and police action will not necessarily work. Such methods have been greatly intensified in the last three years, but have only aroused greater protests. Further intensification may have the same effect.
A good description of the atmosphere of resistance among Soviet intellectuals appeared in an article by Patricia Blake in the March 24, 1968, New York Times Magazine. Written from the point of view of a bourgeois student of Soviet letters, the article shows Miss Blake's close knowledge of and good feel for the Soviet literary scene, but it naturally falls short of a clear un~derstanding of the significance of the intellectuals' struggle.
Miss Blake does not see that this is part of the broader movement toward the regeneration of the Russian socialist revolution and the revival of work~ ers democracy in the spirit of Lenin's State and Revolution. She imagines perhaps that the protesting youth and intellectuals are fighting for "freedom" as enjoyed by American writers and scholars. But they are probablyless naive on that subject than she.
Nevertheless, her description of the Soviet intellectual dissent is an accurate and useful one: "The simple fact is," she writes, "that the Russian intellectual has, by and large, ceased to be afraid. The old, fearful sense of isolation from which writers and readers, teachers and students, scholars, scientists and artists suffered under Stalin has gradually been replaced by a sense of community that now gives them the courage to risk prison for the sake of commonly shared principle. This change seems very nearly miraculous when one considers how intellectually, artistically and morally stupefying was Stalin's terror.... [Emphasis added. ]
"Today intellectuals of all ages are openly calling, not only for greater intellectual and artistic freedom, but, increasingly, for fundamental changes in Soviet society.* They are fighting for their beliefs from the prisoner's dock, on the streets, in underground books and magazines and, indeed, on any tribune they can find -- including the foreign press. They throw flowers on paddy wagons, demonstrate outside courtrooms, and assemble in public squares carrying placards calling for adherence to the Constitution. They hold illegal press conferences for Western newsmen where they accuse Soviet newspapers of slander, and threaten to sue. They draft letters, signed by a who's who of Soviet literature, science, and scholarship, demanding an end to violations of the law, and address them to Brezhnev and Kosygin, the Politburo, the Supreme Court, Pravda and Izvestia, and circulate them all over Mos~ cow. In short, the liberal intelligentsia is confronting the Soviet leadership with its own myths."
One of the recent protest statements that Miss Blake quotes in her article is especially interesting. It was drafted by Pyotr Yakir, son of Maj. Gen. Iona Yakir, one of the top Red Army officers shot on Stalin's orders in 1937. Gen. Yakir was rehabilitated after Stalin's death; Pyotr, the son, spent seven-— teen years in Stalin's prison camps, and now works as a historian.
Pyotr Yakir's statement denounced the January trial of young rebels in Moscow in sharp terms: "Even Andrei Vyshinsky would have envied the organization of this trial," Yakir wrote, adding: "The inhuman punishment of members of the intelligentsia is a logical extension of
* Miss Blake no doubt thinks the Soviet rebels favor restoration of capitalism, but there is no evidence that they advocate anything but greater democracy within the postcapitalist framework. The establishment of democratic workers control over the government and economy would be a "fundamental change" in the present political structure, which is characterized by exclusive bureaucratic command from above. But that change would not alter the basic social and economic foundations -- planned economy and public ownership of all major means of production and distribution. the atmosphere of public life in recent years. The process of the restoration of Stalinism is going on -- slowly but remorselessly."
The "naive hopes" raised by the denunciation of Stalin at the twentieth and twenty-second CPSU congresses, he pointed out, had not been realized. "The name of Stalin is being pronounced from the highest platforms in an entirely positive context."
Yakir pointed to the publication of many works praising Stalin, while those critical of the "great genius" were suppressed. The same point was made by literary historian Lev Kopelev, who together with five others was recently expelled from the CPSU for signing protest statements. (See World Outlook, April 5, pp. 300-302.)
Yakir contrasted the trend toward rehabilitating Stalin with the continued negative evaluation of Trotsky's role in Soviet history.
Yakir's statement closed with an appeal to Soviet citizens to "raise your voices against the impending danger of new Stalins and Yezhovs...We remind you that people who dared to think are now languishing in harsh forced~labor camps. Every time you are silent, another stepping-stone is added, leading to new trials of a Daniel or a Ginzburg. Little by 1little, with your acquiescence, a new 1947 may come upon us."
Yakir's mention of Trotsky was not accidental. A number of Soviet “historical" articles in the past three years have painted Stalin favorably -- precisely in connection with his role in defeating "Trotskyism." In fact, the March 1968 issue of the monthly journal Problems of CPSU History {Voprosy_Istorii KPSS] ran just such an article, entitled "The Par- 1358 Struggle with Trotskyism in 1928- 1930.
Aside from being a rehash of stale old falsifications of history, the article included the following subtle but revealing passage: "The Sixteenth Congress [of the CPSU] summed up the struggle with Trotskyism for the period following the Fifteenth Congress. The reports of J.V. Stalin and G.K.Ordjonokidze, as well as the speeches of I.M.Vareikis,; I.D.Kabakov, P.P.Postyshev, Ya.E.Rudzutak, R.I.Eikhe, E.M.Yaroslavsky, and others, laid out a clear picture of this struggle."
THE