Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

In Defense of Bertrand Russell

· World Outlook Vol. 5, No. 9, 3 March 1967 · pp 230-234 · 2,582 words

Vietnam and Indochina United States

DEFENSE OF BERTRAND RUSSELL

By Joseph Hansen

In its February 19 issue, The New York Times Magazine, the weekly supplement of the world's biggest, if not always best, bourgeois newspaper, paid its highest possible tribute to Bertrand Russell; i.e., it subjected him to a full-scale personal attack of a most venomous nature.

The New York Times does not claim to speak authoritatively in the field of philosophy in which it rates Bertrand Russell's contributions as among the greatest of all time. But it is an authority on imperialist war and the suppression of colonial struggles for freedom and it is in this field that it levels its heavy guns against the distinguished British pacifist. More particularly, it lowers its aim down to Russell's opposition to the current American role in Vietnam; and to give its condemnation of the 94-year-old battler the greatest possible weight, it utilizes the services of a Bernard Levin whose credentials are that he is "a regular contributor to The Daily Mail of London and New Statesman" and that he recently joined "Kingsley Amis, John Braine and other British writers in publicly affirming support of American action in Vietnan. "This bird, it is clear, does not flock with the doves.

Levin's article is entitled, “Bertrand Russell: Prosecutor, Judge and Jury." Its thesis is simplicity itself: Russell is violating the norms of bourgeois jurisprudence by taking part in a War Crimes Tribunal that is gathering evidence of American war crimes in Vietnam when he himself has already become convinced that the U.S. government is guilty.

Levin does not attempt to establish a countercase by arguing that the Johnson administration is innocent. He does not advance facts or cite witnesses in an effort to defend the acts committed under the policies for which Johnson, McNamara, Rusk and Helms of the CIA bear responsibility. Instead he scores Russell for "actively defending" alleged “atrocities of the Vietcong in Vietnam."And under guise of “explaining” why Russell stands on the side of the Vietnamese freedom fighters and not the imperialist aggressors, Levin seeks to further divert attention from the real issues and facilitate his main job which is to smear the War Crimes Tribunal by attacking Russell personally.

Levin describes Russell at a London press conference as an "it," and his appearance there as "the equivalent of the religious custom of showing to the faithful the

saint's bones, or vestments, or miraculously liquefying blood.” The "it" is "unwrapped" as "the holiest relic the. international left possesses..." Are we to conclude then that Russell at 94 is senile, as all this somewhat more than implies? Not at all! "His grasp of the speech he is reading, its pages held in a thin, blue-veined hand is obviously complete."

This disclaimer does not prevent Levin from then continuing after Russell has read his statement and leaves the room: "The holy relic has been shown, and is laid back

; in its velvet-lined ark till the saint's

day comes round again." How's that for

literary polish, for dexterity in slid-

ing a razor across a throat?

If Russell is senile, then it

must be that he is being used and ma-

nipulated? Levin brings in Russell's

secretary Ralph Schoenman, "a young

man with a round, neat beard, and a

smile of infinite self-satisfaction."

A number of details, including American

flavored words in Russell's statements

indicate that Schoenman does indeed ma-

nipulate the “holy relic." Oh, no, but

not at all! How can you believe that

Levin implies anything of the kind is

being done by this "sidekick" who grew

up "with a deep, and deeply neurotic,

hatred of his native land..."

"For even if Schoenman prepares

singlehanded all the documents, it is

beyond dispute that Russell agrees to

them. Schoenman may be Mephistopheles,

but he is not Svengali; he may have

persuaded Russell to believe in, and

propagate, the most odious rubbish,

but the fact remains that Russell does

believe it, and is not just a mindless

puppet, good for nothing but holding

the pen." ‘

And as if to prove that every-

thing he has brought up about Russell's

age and the American Schoenman's "anti-

American" influence is meaningless =-

except as it may stick in the minds of

BERTRAND RUSSELL careless readers, Levin specifically

; declares: "Russell is not senile. Indeed, it is quite clear that in many ways his faculties are undimmed, and those who have talked with him recently have been impressed by the vigor of his mind...it must be made clear that he is no brain-softened dotard, signing documents he does not understand."

If Russell's mind retains whatever vigor it formerly had, then perhaps he was always easily taken in. Not so, Levin responds. "His mind has in its time been one of the most glorious that ever adorned the human race; he has compelled his recognition as the peer of Leibnitz, Descartes, Newton, Archimedes, Kant..."

Nevertheless that same mind has reached the conclusion that Johnson, McNamara, Rusk and the rest of them are guilty of war crimes! How is this to be explained?

Did Russell become anti-American because of "the shameful treatment he received as long ago as 1940, when he was prevented, in a trumped-up legal action, from taking up his appointment as professor of philosophy at the College of the City of New York"? No! That case, "which to this day makes sorry reading for admirers of the United States" as a classic example of "prejudice, malice, religious bigotry and judicial boondoggling... never seemed to have left any lasting mark on Russell..."

The mystery deepens even more before Levin clears it up; for this mind, of the caliber of a Leibnitz, Descartes, Newton, Archimedes, Kant, is nevertheless “hovering uncomfortably close" to an “insane paranoia."

For instance, this titanic intellect, which on the surface still appears to re-

BERTRAND RUSSELL

BERTRAND RUSSELL

tain full lucidity, is nevertheless capable of issuing a statement. accusing the CIA of. engaging in plots! Yes, the American CIA!! How monstrous it is to: accuse the CIA of:-en+ gaging in plots could fortunately be judged by everyone the very week >in which Levin's article appeared, for that was the week the CIA won headlines throughout the world in : recognition of its philanthropic disbursement of funds in a whole. series of fields:s: ngs beginning with education.

All “the more pertinent, therefore, is the evidence cited by: hevin to show the. kind of “odious rubbish" to- which Russell attaches his distinguished name. Despite ‘the. nausea it will obviously occasion among some of his readers, Levin dutifully cites the following: ‘proof: of "insane parandia" -- an attack leveled by Bertrand Russell against the CIA: - ods

"The C.I.A....draws up lists of popular leaders to be assassinated. It plots to. start wars. It invades countries....In Argentina, American tanks smashed the civilian government of Arturo Frondizi....Brutal military putsches have been imposed upon Ecuador, Bolivia, Guatemala. and Honduras....The United. Nations has become a tool of. American aggression... -In the Congo, mercenary troops, acting for Belgian and American interests... have shamelessly killed....The dregs of American militarism have been used for this pure pose... .right—wing generals, with United States money, have taken control of Indonesia...."

Even if he stands at the level of Leibnitz, Descartes, Newton, Archimedes and Kant, a man is obviously off his rocker if he can believe such "odious rubbish" ‘about the CIA and the Pentagon. _

What then is the explanation ‘for Russell's. ‘sad decline? Here’ ‘is ‘the vkey to the mystery as worked out by a mind of the level of Levin's: "What I-think has distorted, and finally destroyed, Russell's capacity for critical judgment , is. his unbearable horror at the prospect that mankind may perish in a nuclear: Armageddon. "

Russell is suffering from a strange kind of madness. whe has. lived, privately as well as publicly, fully and richly; and now he sees the possibility that the human race, which he has so long and valiantly labored to show:can be master of its destiny, will vanish utterly in a radioactive wilderness, and make Plato.and Shakespeare and Beethoven and Rembrandt, and the millions of innocent people who only want to live in peace, and the hills and fields, and the goodness of which men and women are capable, and Bertrand Russell, all one with the dust. 5 :

"To. prevent that, he has frenziedly devoted, what must now be. ‘his. comparatively few remaining years. Philosophy he now rejects with ¢ontempt as a wasteful digression; the only thing | that now matters is preventing. man vowing himself and the. earth to pieces. . oe,

From this Russell came to blame "particular men," 1 ‘then those guiding the de inies of the. "most powerful nation." From that he came to “regarding them and theirsysten as evil," then to regarding their opponents as "good and true and always right": and "thence to -- well, the 'War Crimes Tribunal,' which will put President Johnson and the United. States on ‘trial! before judges who have already made up their minds that the defendants are guilty as charged."

This labored argument is of interest for it provides a clue to understanding a person of the Levin type, a species that is apparently human but which experiencés no unbearable horror at the prospect that mankind may perish in a nuclear Armageddon. It enables us to'appreciate how such a: stringer on the payroll of the New York Times can close his mind to the threat of nuclear war and blithely devote himself to such higher interests as defending the immaculateness of the CIA and the purity and innocence of U.S. policy in Vietnan.

It enables us likewise to better grasp why a Levin can seriously argue that Russell, “whose first major public action was his participating in a commission to examine the Congo atrocities of King leopold I of the Belgians" is now doing the utter opposite. by initiating an inquiry into the war crimes being committed by the Johnson administration in Vietnam.

The real problem is not to understand Russell but to understand a creature like Levin. Albert Einstein, the great physicist and mathematician, had a word to say on the subject. In an article in which he came out strongly against capitalism and in favor of socialism in 1995” Einstein stressed the peril faced by mankind should a nuclear war

* aby Socialism?" written for the first issue (May 1949) of the Honthiy Review, and subsequently . issued by MR as a pamphlet.

~2435-

oceur. “Innumerable voices," said Einstein, "have been asserting for some time now that human society is passing through a crisis, that its stability has been gravely shattered. It is characteristic of such a situation that individuals feel indifferent or even hostile toward the group, small or large, to which they belong. In order to illustrate my meaning, let me record here a personal experience. I recently discussed with an intelligent and well-disposed man the threat of another war, which in my opinion would seriously endanger the existence of mankind, and I remarked that only a supra-national organization would offer protection’ from that danger. Thereupon my visitor, very ‘calmly and coolly, said to me: "Why 3 are you so deeply opposed to the disappearance of the human race?" :

. “I am sure “that as little as a century ago no one would have so lightly made a statement of this kind. It is the statement of a man who has striven in vain to attain an equilibrium within himself and has more or less lost hope of succeeding. It is the expression of a painful solitude and isolation from which so many people are suffering in these days."

. Einstein does not indicate the identity of his visitor. In all likelihood it was not Levin; but it was quite clearly one of his sisters under the skin.

It is striking that in the list of great men with whom Levin chooses to compare Russell, he selects the names of scientists and philosophers who lived long before’ the day of nuclear weapons. He does not include a single contemporary. Above all, he does not mention Albert Einstein. Why? Was it: just because he was familiar with Einstein' s opinion of the Levins of the late forties? Or is it more likely that something else is involved? Something more destructive of his assessment of Russell?

The truth is that Einstein shared Russell's concern over the danger of a nuclear war. In fact it is possible that it was Einstein or someone of his stature who convinced Russell of the danger, for at one point immediately after World War II Russell apparently favored a preventive war against the USSR if the Soviet governnent rejected international inspection concerning atomic weapons.

. Einstein and Russell corresponded about the danger of atomic annihilation in another war and their last letters, exchanged on the eve of Einstein's death in 1955, show how close their views-were. (See Einstein on Peace, Simon Schuster, New York, 1960.) Einstein's last two signatures were appended, one to a letter to Bertrand Russell, the other to a public. statement drawn up by Russell appealing to scientists. to set. aside all their feelings about even such issues as "the titanic struggle between Communism and . anti-Communism" and to "consider yourselves only as members of a biological. species’ which has had a remarkable history, and those disappearance none of us can desire." -

If Levin haa compared Russell with Einstein, he would, in all consistency, have been compelled to mention their common viewpoint on the danger of any war in the world today becoming escalated into a nuclear war that could signify the end of mankind as a biological species. And if Levin did that, what would happen to his carefully constructed _ attack on the personality of Bertrand Russell? Everything would have become reversed. He would have had to recognize Russell as continuing logically in the pattern set by Einstein. Still more, he would’ have had to recognize that, wholly to his credit, Russell was carrying on despite his age and the handicaps that go with it such as lowered energy.

The truth is that anyone the least’ fair-minded must recognize that Russell at the age of 94 is at the height.of his moral stature. He is carrying on in complete -consistency with his participation in an inquiry into the atrocities: committed by the Belgian imperialists in the Congo and in complete consistency with the broad humane view that has always characterized mankind" s greatest figures.

But if Levin had been fair-minded how could he have carried out his ‘task of picturing Bertrand Russell as having "fallen into a state of such gullibility, lack of discrimination, twisted logic and rancorous hatred of the United States that he has turned into a full-time purveyor of political garbage indistinguishable from the routine _Products of the Soviet machine "?:

Two final points should be noted.

First, the chagrin and anger of the New York- Times over the fact that one of the best-known luminaries of the academic world should have come to put the interests of humanity above the interests of the bourgeois class in which he was born.

Secondly, the dismay felt by this mighty shaper of public opinion that the War Crimes Tribunal sponsored by Bertrand Russell will indeed be recognized by the majority of mankind and that its verdict will stand throughout the world as a definitive moral condemnation of. the dirty. colonial war being waged by: the Johnson administration in Vietnam.

234

THE MAO

← What Would You Tell the Vietnamese Targets? · The Mao Regime and the Paris Commune →

Something wrong on this page?