Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The Frankfurt Congress of the Socialist German Student Federation

· World Outlook Vol. 5, No. 32, 6 October 1967 · pp 821-823 · 1,630 words

Germany Fourth International Stalinism Vietnam and Indochina

FEDERATION

By Manfred Ernst

Frankfurt

The twenty-second annual congress of the Sozialistischer Deutsche Studentenbund [SDS -- Socialist German Student Federation] met in Frankfurt, Septenber 6-8. The meeting displayed the action and high theoretical and political debate which have made this student organization, the only legal left opposition in West Germany today, a dynamic arena in which a new generation of youth have boldly challenged their country's ruling class.

They are the horror and scandal of their fathers, as the sensational newspaper coverage here reveals, but a new and promising revolutionary cadre is being assembled within their ranks.

The delegated conference represented all SDS groups in West Germany and there were more than 200 invited guests, ranging from a delegation from the Soviet Union to a delegation from the Fourth International.

The spirit and temper of the conference was symbolized by a large flag of the Vietnamese National Liberation Front dominating the wall behind the presidium. The SDS has sparked and organized a series of impressive actions and demonstrations in solidarity with the NLF in the recent period. [See World Outlook, September 8, p. 767.1]

In fact, during the conference itself, SDSers seized the opportunity to demonstrate their modus operandi: A pro- American, ClA-subsidized institution in Frankfurt, American House, had imprudently sponsored a symposium at this time on "Vietnam -- Is the American Effort Sufficient?" to which they invited West German journalists and representatives of Newsweek magazine to participate.

To the consternation of the organizers, a delegation of the SDS led by Rudi Dutschke of the Berlin SDS took over the platform, raised an NLF flag, and opened the meeting by singing the "Internationale." Dutschke then introduced an American professor who spoke on Vietnan.

With some 100 SDSers in the audience and SDS control of the podium it was clear that the pro-American organizers had lost control of their meeting and they called the cops. One hundred officers took on the SDSers and finally succeeded in driving them out of the hall.

But once out, the students reinforced and reformed their ranks and staged what they call an "antidiscussion." The entire action was admirably and smoothly organized with a thoroughness that has characterized most of the Berlin SDS actions. In this case it served as a laboratory demonstration for the youth leaders from all over Europe who had been invited to the congress -- a demonstration initiated and led by the Berlin section of the SDS to illustrate their thesis that in the present context of West German politics, spirited action is needed in order to break up the image of smug conformity that seems to dominate all of West Germany.

The Berlin section of the SDS is the dominant tendency inside the SDS and succeeded in establishing its leadership of the SDS at this congress.

A major debate on the congress floor on the role of the working class brought the Berlin tendency in confrontation with a loose coalition of tendencies which can roughly be described as spokesmen and sympathizers of the illegal West German Kommunistischen Partei [CP -- Communist party].

The CP is actually a small apparatus kept alive for its possible usefulness ultimately in bargaining between East and West Germany.

The Berlin students, beginning their political lives with wholesale rejection of the West German bourgeois establishment, also tend, like many American students, to overlook the revolutionary potential of a largely conservatized working class.

This has led to the popularity of Herbert Marcuse, whose writings find a ready echo in the students' own present experience. In a sense they are being victimized by Marcuse, who represents an old generation that saw all its hopes destroyed by Stalinism and fascism. Preferring to forget its own responsibilities for that dark period, it takes a lugubrious revenge by denying the class struggle and the historical role of the working class.

But these students have nothing in common with the old, defeated and sour survivors of the past. That Marcuse now sees progress through classless consciousness of a presumed elite brings his views into a temporary accord with a new generation of students who have entered the political stage -- and see that they occupy it almost exclusively.

Formally and to a large extent abstractly, the other tendency in the con-

gress, which the Berlin group calls pro- Stalinist, defended the Marxist view on the role of the working class. This, of course, is the weak side of the Berlin group and it leaves them wide open to attack.

But when it comes down to basic decisions of what to do now and how to do it, the Berlin group shows its superiority. The others gave the very strong inpression of being rather passive elements who would like to put the SDS at the disposal of the trade-union bureaucracies.

When this tendency introduced a debate on a motion to fight for the legalization of the West German CP, which to them was the major question for the congress, they met defeat because they refused to agree that all revolutionary groups be legalized. This would include the Fourth Internationalists in Germany. The tendency's sectarianism tripped it up.

A further debate took place on a resolution hailing the fiftieth anniversary of the October revolution. Here the division between Stalinist-influenced and left-wing students became quite clear. The left wing wanted to differentiate between the program and ideas of October in Lenin's time and the myths and parody of the Kremlin usurpers at present. One of the Berlin delegates spoke of the disastrous heritage of Stalinism and its consequences. Pointing to the East German regime, he denied that it should be called a truly socialist state and said it must be characterized as a transitional state that could lead to socialisn.

A delegate from Heidelberg called attention to the festivities being organized in West Germany by the Soviet enbassy to celebrate the fiftieth anniversary. He said that Kiesinger, Strauss, Beitz and 1,696 leaders of big business, finance and the church were invited to a special party to be given by the Russian ambassador.

A high point was the announcement that a representative of the Fourth International would address the convention. The audience, which had generally kept up a buzz of conversation and moving around during all addresses, came immediately to attention and an uncommon quiet descended as Thomas Clement, the young representative of the United Secretariat of the Fourth International, began to speak. He took up some of the issues in dispute, relating them to the worldwide revolutionary struggle of today, from Vietnam to Latin America. [See text of speech elsewhere in this issue. ]

Following his remarks, the Soviet delegation -- all middle aged -- left the congress, to the amusement of the majority of delegates present. They sent a letter to the congress which was read the next day.

It protested the appearance of the Fourth International spokesman and what they called the "anti-Soviet spirit" of the congress. The contrast between the reception given their spokesman and that given to the spokesman of the Fourth International was too humiliating to be ignored. In this small but significant episode, one can read the harsh judgment being drawn up by a new generation of German revolutionists on Stalinism -straight or sugar-coated.

It is too early to predict the final evolution of this student movement. But obviously at the present time it is of considerable importance in a regroup~ ing and reorienting process that is taking place in West Germany.

It would be superficial and nistaken to take the formal ideology of the present dominant leadership which is heavily burdened with Marcusian conceptions and read into it an inevitable evolution to the right and other dire consequences. To be sure, this ideology carries with it an inevitable collision with the fundamental historical tide of the European working class.

If one accepts the basic premise of this thinking, which posits the complete passivity of the working class as a_ class, then all prospects of a revolutionary socialist transformation including that attempted by an elite of socalled conscious people fall to the ground.

Then the work and sacrifices of the SDS cadres themselves will turn out to have had only a nuisance value. Much more must be said about the basic propositions of Marcuse insofar as they influence the program and thinking of these students, but this requires another article. Nevertheless, we will see how Marcuse's basically antihistorical construction stands up at the first serious test of strength between the German bourgeoisie and the many-millioned German proletariat.

And we are safe, I think, in concluding that there is a world of difference between the Marcusian speculations of a defeated professor in his study, and the exhilarating self-consciousness of students who take on the cops in Berlin and Frankfurt.

An entire generation of German revolutionists was destroyed by Hitler after being betrayed by German Social Democracy and Stalinism. The revolutionary socialist continuity was snapped and its human agents were pulverized. Now the threads of that continuity are slowly being spliced together in the hands of a

new generation. As many times before, students are the first to take up that task and so it is in West Germany today.

Two strongly positive orientations were manifested by the leadership and cadre of the SDS which gives it big promise for the future. The first was its wholehearted identification with the worldwide struggle against imperialism and the second was its realization that it must orient to the organization of young high-school students who are, after all, the proletarians of tomorrow.

And one should mention also the avid interest these students have in ideas and program. At the very least, they will help swell a demand for revolutionary literature in Germany which will bear its own fruit. This was clearly manifested at the Frankfurt

← Irade Unions in Japan Set Vietnam War Protest for October 21 · Fourth International Greets SDS Congress →

Something wrong on this page?