Isaac Deutscher counterposed the perspective of a quasigradual restoration of Soviet democracy to the necessity for a political revolution in the Soviet Union which is inscribed in our program. This difference became especially pronounced after Stalin's death. Though we both believed that Stalin's totalitarian and bloody methods had to be replaced by other methods of government, we did not attribute the same weight to the phenomenon of "de- Stalinization." In our opinion this process signified that the bureaucracy was making a defensive retreat. He reposed greater hopes in it and saw in it the justification for his perspective.
But Deutscher's thought was not static. He had already begun to place a question mark over this perspective in the third volume of Trotsky's biography. Without wishing to misinterpret his thought in any respect, we got the inression from all of his latest writings some of those pieces republished in Ironies of History and The Unfinished Revolution) that, in the light of the development of the Soviet Union over the past ten years and of the domestic and international policies of Khrushchev and his successors, our differences on this point were being reduced.
On the other hand, up to the very end he displayed an intractable obstinacy on the matter of the Fourth International. For years we had not been able to carry on any discussion, that is to say, a genuine dialogue on this question. This is not the place to dwell on this controversy in which we could not see any right on his side. Having said this, it is also necessary to add that his personality could not have easily unfolded its talents within the framework of an organization and very likely he was best able to serve the cause of the socialist revolution as a free-lance writer.
While deploring Deutscher's attitude, the Fourth International has to be faithful to its function which is to encourage and publicize every production of value for revolutionary Marxists, and Deutscher's activity occupies an eminent place in this domain. In particular, we cannot forget that it often served to introduce numerous young people to Trotskyist ideas which led to their political activity within the Trotskyist movement itself.
By continuing to popularize his writings in the future, we will not only: remain true to ourselves but we will help the memory of Isaac Deutscher continue to participate in the world struggle for the socialist revolution. :
We send the expression of our solidarity to his wife, Tamara, and his son, Mark, in the grievous ordeal they have experienced.
August 22, 1967