RIGHT FOR ONCE
... Among other things putting him above ordinary men, such as being equipped with “extra glands," President Johnson has.a feeling for art. So far as is known, he has displayed this only once; but the quality of judgment revealed in the instance is sufficient to show that the world lost an art critic of highest caliber when Johnson decided to go into politics. ss:
The great man's hidden talent ‘came to light last -year when the official. Presidéen- _ tial portrait, which he had commissioned, was sent to him at his ranch for approval. When the artist arrived, he found that Johnson had set it up under fluorescent lights and "It looked like death warmed over.
“In a single pithy phrase, Johnson gave artist Peter Hurd the distillation of his Judgment -- "That's the ugliest thing I ever saw.
As Hurd told the story later, "My hair began to bristle. I said, 'What do you like, Mr. President? ' And he said, Aral show you) what I like,' and whisked out Rockwell." ; a
This was a drawing of the President done by the magazine illustrator Norman Rockwell from a. photograph and maybe one sitting by the great. subject for a. few. minutes. Johnson, as a true. connoisseur of. art, kept this beautiful work in his desk drawer for handy reference. . ;
According to .Hurd, _Mrs.. Johnson told him afterwards that she didn't ; expect to endure any meeting so grim again if she "lived to be 1,000." Over the phone she explained to Hurd, "The only thing that didn't go wrong that day was that the government of Viet Nam didn't fall.
No doors were slammed.as the artist left the LBJ Ranch. But, naturally, with the customer dissatisfied, the sale didn't go through. The price tag, incidentally, was only $6,000 -- just half the usual price, seeing who this patron -of the arts was and what it meant in reputation, free advertising and other good and valuable considerations to have a portrait of him accepted.
Hurd said, "I was damn glad to get out of the whole thing." Still, he was bound to feel some disappointment, and considered the President's comment "very damn rude," as he had spent fifty hours on the canvas, twice the usual time, and "I had worked my tail off."
The New York Times took an editorial position on the esthetic values where the artist and critic were at loggerheads, saying, "Mr. Johnson's reaction to Mr. Hurd's painting -- "the ugliest thing I ever saw' -- is. not easy to understand,. since Mr. Hurd _is only a slightly slicker, if less sentimental, practitioner. of the illustrative realism that is Mr. Rockwell' s standard style."
By way of consolation to the President, the Times declared that compared with news and TV photographs, "any painted likeness of Mr. Johnson or any other public figure is likely to take on the quality of a mortuary exercise..."
As for our own position, in this case we think the art critic is, in the main, correct. He is a little off base, of course, in putting such strong stress on nuances_ of style. Nonetheless, in view of the subject matter -- which must also concern the critic as well as the artist -- he is undoubtedly dead right in coming to the conclu- . Sion, "That's the ugliest thing I ever saw."
HOOLIGANISM AT LIEGE -- DESERTION AT THE AVENUE KLEBER
By Pierre Frank
A demonstration in behalf of Hugo Blanco was held December 14 in ‘front of the Peruvian embassy in Paris at the Avenue Kleber. [See World Outlook January 6.] All the organizations claiming adherence to Trotskyism were there save one, the group that recently baptized itself "Organisation Communiste Internationaliste," plus the youth organization it guides, "Révolte." These two organizations had nonetheless been invited to a meeting to discuss undertaking the action in favor of Hugo Blanco and they were represented there by Stephane Just, who began by affirming amid general smiles that they were the only Trotskyists.
They refused, to go along with the action for. two main reasons: (1) We were associated with officeholders of the UNR [de Gaulle's Union pour la Nouvelle République] and priests in the appeal for "A Billion for Vietnam";* (2) the aétion in behalf of Hugo Blanco ought to try to mobilize the unions with the exception of the CFDT [the Catholicdominated Conféderation Frangaise et Démocratique du Travail]. These two reasons warrant some comments. -.
We signed the appeal for a billion and gave our reasons for it publicly. All that is involved in the appeal is a simple demonstration of solidarity, the weight of which we do not overestimate, couched in terms that are unassailable, expressing solidarity without any reservations towards’ the Vietnamese people against American imperialism. The appeal does not concede anything at all to "pacifist," "humanitarian" sentiments masking more or less dubious orientations. If some UNR deputies, some priests, etc., have subscribed to this appeal, is that any reason for saying, as did the spokesman of one of these groups at a meeting: "Not a sou for the billion! "?
We repeat: All that is involved is a simple act-of solidarity with human beings who each day are subjected to tons of bombs by American imperialism.
let us consider a less important example. Some workers are involved in a long strike, and a solidarity committee is set up to help the families of the strikers by collecting funds. And let us suppose that the bourgeois deputy (UNR or any other) of the constituency and the parish priest, for their own reasons, subscribe to the appeal. (Don't let anyone tell us that this is an absurd hypothesis; it has been seen. Only a few months ago a bishop marched at the head of a demonstration of strikers in.a city in the south.) Are our "purists" going to tell a striker who asks them to put their names down for something on the list: "Since the deputy and the curé on the corner are contributing, I'm not giving a sou"? With such "Trotskyism," we obviously have nothing in common. :
We are certainly in favor of steps to get the unions to take up the defense of Hugo Blanco. But why exclude the CFDT? When we were trying to save the Rosenbergs from the electric chair, appeals were addressed to the Vatican, which intervened. We wonder what objection could be made to that! ; ;
But for our sectarians, the argument is that the CFDT is a "Trojan horse" in the workers movement; that it is the vehicle of the Catholic hierarchy in the workers movement, etc. The latter point does not appear to us very exact since the split occurred with the CFTC [Confédération Frangaise des Travailleurs Chrétiens -- French Confederation of Christian Workers], because this split had an objective significance and cannot be interpreted as a maneuver.
‘ However, let:us grant the argument -~ that the CFDT represents interests alien to the workers movement. By the same logic, it could be said just as accurately that the FO [Force Ouvriére] is the "Trojan horse" of American imperialism, this conféderation having been supported since its foundation with American funds (the unions of that country serving in this instance as a transmission belt for the State Department). Why exclude one "Trojan horse" and not the other?
Stephane Just and his comrades aré against the CGT-CFDT [CGT -- Confédération Générale du Travail] accord not because of its reformist content, but in -principle,since they are against an accord on the trade-union level with the CFDT. On this point, moreover, they support the thoroughly reformist leaders of the Fédération de 1'Education _ Nationale. We will return to this later. °
*The current campaign in France to collect one billion old francs (US$2,000,000) to help the Vietnamese people in their struggle against U.S. imperialist aggression.
As for us, we are not only for agreements (their content is something else again), we are for even more; we are for the unity of the CGT, FO and CFDT. This, of course, must not be unity at any price. But in principle, communists are against splits on the trade-union level; and there was a time when they fought in favor of trade-union unity not only against the traditional reformists but also against the CFIC concept of "union plurality."
That's not all. If these "Trotskyists," horrified at the Catholic hierarchy, did not belong to a phony International Committee, if they were members of a genuine international organization, they would know, for example, that in Germany before 1933 there were Social Democratic and Christian unions, and that in 1945 trade-union unity was achieved. What is their slogan for Germany? To kick out the spokesman of the Catholic hierarchy ~- because there is one -- and split the unions?
This is still not all, because the workers movement, unfortunately, does not lack in "Trojan horses." The members of the organization who don't want the CFDT to defend Hugo Blanco are in the FO where they are in alliance among others with Hébert of Nantes. In the latter city, this anarcho-syndicalist supports the reactionary Morice, celebrated at least for having belonged to the Comité de Vincennes pour l1'Algérie Frangaise and. constructing a line bearing his name that sought to isolate Algeria from Tunisia. What does this indicate about the ties between Morice and Hébert?
Let's take a look, if you don't mind, in the direction of the Masonic lodges. We also see there the leaders of the Fédération de 1'Education Nationale. Aren't the lodges a "Trojan horse" in the workers movement? Do Stephane Just, Lambert and the others prefer the apron, hammer and Masonic rigamarole to the chasuble, stole and rituals of the Holy Roman Church?
The "arguments" that were trotted out didn't mean much to anyone except Stephane Just, for whom not much is really needed. They were only a pretext, after all, not to get involved in an action with "Pabloites," "Frankites," etc., in which it would not be possible to operate. the way these organizations did at Liége. There, in October, a demonstration was organized by the Jeune Garde Socialiste [Socialist Young Guard] of Belgium against NATO and for Vietnam. The organizations for whom Just spoke sent a delegation of some 300 youth, their main objective being to "unmask" the Fourth International. In this operation they conducted themselves in hooligan fashion.*
At Avenue Kleber they could not put us "on trial" in front of the Peruvian embassy. They would have had to march shoulder to shoulder with "traitors," "petty bourgeois," etc. This is not really possible for sectarians who do not know where the class line really runs and for whom the main enemy is not the bourgeoisie but those who belong at least as much as they do to the Trotskyist school. This sectarianism ran the whole gamut in less than two months -- from