Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

PlaJ "Cultural Revolution" and Trotskyism

· World Outlook Vol. 5, No. 18, 5 May 1967 · pp 475-478 · 2,480 words

China Fourth International Soviet Union Latin America

TROTSKYISM

By Pierre Frank

[The following article has been translated by World Outlook from the April issue of La_Quatrieme Internationale, published in Paris by the Parti Communiste Internationaliste, French section of the Fourth International. ]

*x* *

The “cultural revolution" has obviously entered a new phase. It seems that the Mao faction, having met with strong resistance in the party and state apparatus, is trying to overcome this resistance. Its current formula is the establishment of a "triple alliance" to direct the movement. This "triple alliance" is constituted in the first place by the army, then by the "revolutionary rebels" (that is to say, by those who have responded to Mao's appeals), and finally by the cadres, including those who have committed errors, on condition that they really want to follow the movement. This apparently means that Mao is seeking to break up his opponents and establish some kind of new leadership. The prime mover in the present phase is Chou En-lai who, even while following Mao's group, did not sever relations with the other factions.

This "triple alliance" is therefore a sort of combination between bureaucratic factions or subfactions and is far from the type of organization represented by the Paris Commune, where diverse working-class and socialist tendencies counterposed their programs and democratically submitted to the votes of the workers. Moreover, the term "commune" is scarcely to be found any more in the Chinese press.

Now the blows are delivered more against the “left opportunists," against those Red Guards who have committed "“excesses" by attacking privileged bureauerats, etc. Despite Mao's “infallibility" he has seen the campaign he launched at the end of 1965 unfold in an unexpected fashion. He went on from there to embark upon a kind of "escalation" of the struggle against his opponents until around mid-January when, following the entry of such masses as the Shanghai workers on the arena, he began to maneuver to curb the menacing outbreaks. While many surprises can still be expected, we can be sure that henceforth China will not revert to the condition that prevailed when the "cultural revolution" began. The bureaucracy has been weakened, the leadership dislocated, and all those carrying it on and participating in it have lost prestige.

Leaving aside for the moment the political analysis of the events, it will be useful to make some theoretical observations about them. Scientific thought advances especially through the definition and concretization of categories: in the domain of the natural sciences, for example, the atom, the electron, etc. In the domain of the social sciences, labor value, surplus value, the class, the dictatorship of the proletariat.

In the specific field of political thought, the Trotskyist movement has enriched Marxism with theories pertaining to the development of Soviet society which were concretized in several categories: the bureaucratically degenerated workers state, Stalinism and the political revolution. Let us see what the Chinese events have contributed to clarify these concepts.

The bureaucratic degeneration of the Soviet Union had only to be mentioned for the Soviet bureaucracy to cry out "Trotskyism." Let us recall that, about three years ago, when the Sino-Soviet conflict was essentially restricted to ideological controversies, Suslov, in the name of the Central Committee of the Communist party of the Soviet Union, denounced the Chinese as guilty of "Trotskyism" when they criticized the degeneration in the Soviet Union. Now we see Mao denounce phenomena of degeneration in the party and state apparatus of China itself. To be sure, Mao's views on this subject (the reestablishment of capitalism, etc.) are, as we have already had occasion to demonstrate, an expression of the bureaucracy's incapacity to understand the real nature of the phenomenon; they belong to false consciousness and "ideology" rather than to scientific thought. Nevertheless, they testify to the necessity of recognizing that the phenomenon of degeneration applies not only to the USSR but also to other workers' states.

The Trotskyist movement analyzed Stalinism as a unique form of bureaucratization of the Soviet Union and an entire wing of the revolutionary workers movement owing to a confluence of exceptional circumstances (the backwardness of the Soviet Union, its isolation and the recession of the world revolution) and deduced from this that all other forms of bureaucratization would be very different from Stalinism. From the beginning of the "cultural revolution," and even from the beginning of the Sino- Soviet conflict, we emphasized this capital difference and each successive event confirms it. In the Soviet Union Stalin

ceaselessly resorted to the police to stifle the opposition and the masses. In the struggle between the bureaucratic factions in China, one of them, and very likely several of them, have appealed to different sections of the masses. Moreover, anyone can ascertain that the pres-— tige of the Chinese revolution has not involved any manifestation of the international scale comparable to the Stalinization of the Communist party. The pro- Chinese groups who follow the "thought of Mao" are extremely weak. While there is no question of a return or an aspiration on the part of the Chinese bureaucracy to proletarian democracy, the differences with the development in the Soviet Union and the rest of the world are so great that the peculiarity of Stalinism has incontestably been established.

The political revolution was undoubtedly the most audacious of all the categories of political thought introduced by Trotsky and the one which raised the most problems. For years it remained unverified and seemed to many a flight of fancy or pure hypothesis. Berlin in 1953, Poland and Hungary in 1956, witnessed mass movements which began to give flesh and blood to this category of political revolution. The events in China are not the political revolution. Nonetheless, it can be said that these developments, just like the "de-Stalinization" effected by the Soviet bureaucracy which Mao so fiercely denounces, constitute a preparatory stage of such revolution.

What should be emphasized is the fact that to’justify its campaign, the Mao leadership has been led to explain the "cultural revolution" as “a revolution within the framework of the dictatorship of the proletariat," that is to say, to evoke a notion close to that of political revolution. Moreover, very recently in Cuba, where the problem of bureaucracy and the struggle against it is seriously regarded, they are talking about "a revolution within the revolution."

Thus, on three essential points of Trotskyist theory, the latest events contribute such striking verification that the Chinese leaders on one hand and the Cuban leaders on the other are forced to think about these events in terms which, although certainly not those of our movement, clearly approximate then, even if this is done in a more or less distorted manner.

This is a theoretical victory for Trotskyism. The paths to political victory will still be protracted, tortuous and harsh. But there can be no doubt of the outcome since our movement alone possesses the theoretical arsenal which can facilitate a correct understanding of the gigantic events which are now convulsing the worid.

HUGO BLANCO BEATEN BY GUARDS

[Continued from page 457.]

zilez, sought to help Blanco to his feet.

Several more guards came up and the captain ordered them to beat Creus, too. The two prisoners sought to defend themselves but caught sight of several soldiers lined up with machine guns ready to fire.

Blanco and Creus realized that a provocation was probably involved and tried to calm down the guards.

They eventually succeeded in getting out of their clutches.

It was immediately after this that the authorities announced that Blanco is "eravely i11." But no one is allowed to see him and it is not known whether he is actually receiving medical attention.

In the opinion of the French Conmmittee of Solidarity with the Victims of Repression in Peru, it could well be that the military authorities would now like to get rid of Hugo Blanco. In view of the worldwide publicity in the case, it can be highly embarrassing for them when the hearing opens before the Supreme Council of Military Justice. From their viewpoint it would be very convenient if Blanco were to die before the council sits.

This was what happened to Maximo Velando, who was reported by the authorities to have taken "poison" in his cell when in reality he was beaten to death.

Daniel Mayer, president of the League of Human Rights, at once went to the Peruvian embassy in Paris to protest the beating of Hugo Blanco.

Jean-Paul Sartre and Laurent Schwartz cabled immediately to the Military Council.

Friends of Hugo Blanco in Lima are urging immediate action everywhere as they are in great fear that the military authorities are planning to have the famous prisoner killed.

Protests should be sent to the Consejo Supremo de Justicia, and to President BelaGnde Terry, Lima, Peru.

Copies of the protests should be filed with local consulates and embassies.

ALBANIA COPIES THE CULTURAL REVOLUTION

Albania, Peking's sole steadfast ally in the Communist world, has been somewhat slow and hesitant about giving its customary all-out endorsement of the developments in China. Now it appears that its leaders have decided to venture on a miniature "cultural revolution" of their own.

Following upon preliminary steps taken in March a year ago, the campaign was launched on February 6 by the Conmmunist party's first secretary, Enver Hoxha,in a major speech, entitled "The Further Revolutionizing of the Party and the Government." It was given before a collective meeting of the basic party organization of the city and district of the capital Tirana.

The general directives contained in this address coincided with the publication in the party theoretical journal Rruge e Partise of an article headed ‘Tong Live the Great Chinese Cultural Proletarian Revolution" which hailed the Chinese events as "historic lessons for all true Marxist-Leninists of the world."

Hoxha concentrated on two topics. One concerned the shortcomings in the performance of the party organization and concluded with the demand that "if these Communists have failed to allow themselves to be educated and corrected, then they must be expelled."

The other took up the struggle against bureaucracy in the state apparatus. The party secretary harked back to the "Open Letter" issued on March 4, 1966 which resulted in the reduction of the state apparatus by 15,000 functionaries and the replacement of numerous others; the sending to the countryside of 40 authors, artists and painters; the abolition of military ranks and the introduction of political commissars in the military units.

He called for reinforcement of this "back-to-the-masses movement" and said "it would be a mistake to imagine that the struggle against bureaucracy has come to an end." He emphasized this point as follows: "We may reduce the personnel of an institution from 100 people to 50 people; this, however, does not save us from bureaucracy if those remaining 50 people do not profoundly understand the meaning of bureaucracy and how to fight like real revolutionaries."

Hoxha, who rules over the most monolithic party and regime in Communist East Europe, took "democracy" as the theme of his speech. He attacked the elements that violate democracy by suppress-— ing criticism, by degrading party and government authority, by behaving patronizingly toward the masses, by damaging the economy and by acting subjectively.

He called for the abolition of the "currently highly ridiculous wall newspapers" and the dismissal of their editorial boards as “opportunistic scribblers who preserve the prestige and authority of the director and of thenselves." In imitation of the Chinese example, he urged everyone to write fearlessly and in big letters about anyone who failed to perform their tasks properly.

This speech immediately unloosed a torrent of criticisms directed against officials at all levels (except the very top). These were vented in the press, among the youth and in the production centers. The two main dailies, Zeri i Populitt and Bashkimi, did not hesitate to censure government ministers who had to admit their errors and promise to correct them. Many party and government functionaries have lost their jobs.

Thus on February 12 Zeri i Populitt criticized the first secretary of the district of Tirana, who is also an alternate Central Committee member, for bureaucratic behavior in delaying the dismissal of the manager of a coal mine who had been unwilling to go down into the mine.

In an editorial two days later the same paper said that "the bureaucrats are ignorant people; they beat their breasts about their past merits, about the fact that they have been holding executive positions for many years, or that these jobs have been assigned to them." It asserted that "these bureaucrats must be identified and eliminated above all in the state and economic apparatus, in the key positions of economic enterprises, in farm collectives, and in educationalcultural institutions."

Young “Red Guards" have set about to criticize old customs, office-holders and other negative phenomena through slogans, bulletins, caricatures and wall newspapers. Typical were the actions taken by the students at the Naim Frasheri school in the port of Durres under the guidance of the city's party organization. Their posters criticized parents for calling their friends "Mr." and "Mrs."; the city's Executive Committee was condemned for wasting money to move a church and its cemetery to another location; and posters were placed on the homes of people who allegedly still have bourgeois mentalities.

Students in Davaje decided to change the label of a popular brand of cigarettes from its present format of a camel in front of a mosque to a picture of a yet-to-be-selected industrial project of the Five Year Plan. High-schoolers in Tirana covered the door of the director's office with a poster condemning his "arrogance, his misbehavior, his rude language, in fact for not being a true educator but a bureaucrat." They also censured the faculty for failing to participate in the criticisn.

Wall posters in the machinepbuilding plant "Dinamo" in Tirana reprimanded the plant's chief engineer who also held the post of party secretary of the plant. He was charged with irresponsibility and abuse of party authority for getting rid of the wall posters criticizing hin.

As in China, this officially inspired antibureaucratic campaign has enabled diverse sectors of the population to get back at certain hated officials who mistreated them. It also set into motion forces which, in some cases and places, threaten to act on their own account and pass beyond the limits set by the initiators of the campaign. Thus in an article on February 11 Zeri i Populitt warned against "those people who try to take advantage of the situation in order to create anarchy" and said they "will be fought mercilessly."

Interestingly, Hoxha has not yet invoked Mao Tse-tung as the inspirer of his program. While the Albanian first secretary occupies the same position of eminence as Chairman Mao, he does not confront the same deep divisions in his party leadership and regime and can proceed with greater assurance in implementing his "

← Grants Political Asylum to GI in Japan · Albania Copies the Cultural Revolution Kupferman Asks Cougress to Investigate Kennedy Assassination →

Something wrong on this page?