In the factional struggle that waged over this question and the more obscure associated issues at stake, it was evident that Mao was in a minority in the Communist party and the Communist Youth League. Without bothering about the procedures of democratic centralism to which he pays lip service, Mao appealed directly to the masses, but not as a whole and not on a clear programmatic basis.
First the school youth were mobilized and organized into Red Guards. The real power behind the Red Guards was the army which opened the way for them and checked actual or potential countermoves by Mao' s factional opponents.
» As the factional struggle. came to a head, appeals went out to the workers. Simultaneously the army intervened openly inthe struggle to one degree or another wherever it was felt necessary; and its intervention appears to have been decisive, although in face of the paucity of hard information, a very. tight censorship and news deliberately distorted by many interested parties, not least of all the Maoists, this conclusion can only be advanced tentatively. In addition, the internal strains in the army, as well as those in the peasantry, remain unknown ; and these are extremely important in reaching an accurate assessment.
In the process of bringing the factional struggle to a head, broad forces were set in motion. These, particularly the working-class sectors, tended to move against the bureaucratic structure as a whole much in the pattern of the Hungarian workers although only in an incipient way up to now. Were this movement to continue, it would tend to develop into a political revolution that would retain and reinforce the big gains of the revolution, above all the new property forms, while instituting some form of proletarian democracy in the example set by the soviets that appeared in the Russian revolutions of 1905 and 1917. :
Mao and the leaders around him are well aware of this as can be gathered from their repeated references to "Petofi clubs" and "“anarchistic" elements who want "ultrademocracy." -
In face of this threat to their "self-interest," the bureaucratic factions had much to gain by closing ranks, if necessary even settling for an arbiter, whether a sector of:the -bureaucracy or an individual, around which.a modus vivendi could be reached.. Both the advance of the army in the factional dispute and the subsequent "rectification campaign" reflect this.
There is considerable speculation in the bourgeois press about a "sag" in Mao's drive, about the army not having succeeded in taking over in some areas, of suffering reverses and even being torn internally. There may be some substance to the speculation; it.is more likely, however, that this is incidental phenomena.
If the weight of the army has proved decisive in the scales, it is in the logic of the situation for immediate moves to be made to show that its aim in its new role is not to bring chaos and disaster but on the’ contrary to serve as a responsible stabiliz-— ing force. Aside from the objective of winning over the opposition (one of the main themes in the "rectification campaign") or at least neutralizing it, the regime is faced with an imperious need to bring order into the situation. Dangers are pressing from all sides, ranging from the threat of an imperialist attack to a dip on the agricultural front that could entail acute scarcities in the near future if not worse.
Besides this, a breathing space is required to consolidate the factional gains
and sift things out. Whether it is Mao or a new combination’ in the leadership, the exact lineaments ‘of which. cannot yet be determined exactly, the immediate need facing the ruling group 'is‘to relax tensions. ~~
To accomplish this,:concessions are required, — particularly to those sectors of» the bureaucracy which have ‘been under -heaviest pressure and upon which the regime after all résts. This is one:of the main purposes of the present "rectification campaign." Other moves, suchas gétting the Réd* Guards back home; opening the schools and dealing’. some educational blows to those elements who had begun to hope for a bit of proletarian’ democracy and. an improvement in diving Standards , fall naturally into the same pattern.
A big ‘question remains. “Can the forces unleashed ‘Dy the appeals. to" the revolutionary-minded youth and vanguard sectors of the workers be bottled up again? The question is fateful for the Chinese Revolution, tHe defense of thé Chinese workers state and the possibility of a truly-giant stride forward; for it will determine whether: a mere shift has: occurred inthe relative positiotis of the various sectors of the bureaucracy or whether a rift-was opened of such proportions as to permit the masses to-surge forward in the political arena with ‘innovations of their own aimed at bringing the® bureaucracy as a whole under democratic control. ‘As yet it is impossible to say how soon an answer will be forthcoming.