Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

Gus Hall Answers a Question . on Revolutions

World Outlook Vol. 4, No. 14, 6 May 1966 · pp 27-31 · 1,798 words

Cuba Latin America Communist parties National liberation

ANSWERS As QUESTION ON REVOLUTIONS

tin” ‘the April 24 issue of The. Worker, Gus Hall, the main =. spokesman of the American Communist party, attempts.a reply .to the. editorial in the April issue of the Monthly. Review rejecting Fidel Castro:'s -attack.on "Trotskyism". and pointing to the damage done the. Cuban Revolution by the continued = silence over Che Guevara. Hall's reply, in the form of an answer to a question from a reader of The Worker’; is:.entitled "Gus Hall Answers a Question on Revolution." The question was formulated as -follows: "Mr. Hall, Would .you please explain. to.me what is the meaning of the. following sentences in an editorial in ‘the April issue of Monthly Review: '...iIn our opinion, . the only kind of revolution that has any chance of succeeding in .. Latin America today is a socialist revolution. We were, we believe, among the first to say that the Cuban Revolution would be forced to advance rapidly to socialism...in.1963 we stated our opinion in these pages that there.is no such thing as feudalism in Latin America -and-that it..therefore makes no.sense to talk about.-a bourgeois revolution. '"

[We have provided the full text of Mr. Hall's reply below. ]

* KK

THE EDITORIAL that you quote is wrong on. most counts. Among other: things it is an ill-tempered, slanderous, :personal attack on Fidel Castro and the leaders of the Cuban Revolution in general. The editorial slanders Castro as "ignorant" and a "latecomer," and calls his concluding speech to the Tri-Continental Conference "ugly and perhaps ominous , " and states that: Castro's "malice comes from his advisers. Sf _

This ill-tempered slander is in fact a cover for some very fundamental errors in the editorial policies of the Monthly Review. As you can see, there are obvious contradictions even in the lines that you quote. They say, "The only kind of revolution that has any chance in Latin America is a socialist revolution." Then; as seeming proof for this conclusion, they cite the Cuban Revolution. But what | is the meaning of the words, "...Cuban Revolution would be forced to advance rapidly to socialism?" "Advance rapidly to socialism" are the key words. Because if the Cuban Revolution started as a socialist revolution, it would not have had the task of advancing ‘to it.

The first stage of the Cuban Revolution was. anti- imperialist, was for national independence. The fascist Batista regime. was a puppet of U.S. imperialism. It. had to be overthrown. This was corréctly placed by the Cuban revolutionaries as the first task.of.. the revolution. After this was successfully concluded, then it © "rapidly advanced to" a socialist reorganization of society. So, if anything, this sentence disproves the main contention of the editorial.

THE ERROR of MR is in the attempt to ignore the nature of the struggle against imperialism and to replace it with a socialist revolution. In practice such a’ policy would not result ina successful struggle against imperialism, and it would not set.the stage for a socialist revolution. Wherever imperialism is a:factor, amass struggle against: imperialism is a necessary ingredient and a phase in the struggle. for socialism. :

“why are these: ‘concepts so important? Because the locomotive of social revolutions are people. And people will fight for what objective processes have placed on the order of the day. Therefore, if socialism is not on the order. of this day, but in spite of that, the advanced forces present At as if it is, this can only result in isolation for such forces.

The conscious organization and advocacy of advanced ideas, including socialism, are very important. But they can generate power | only if they are related to the level of objective developments of the period.

.&

THE LAST SENTENCE you quote from the editorial does not resolve the contradiction when it states "...there is no such thing as feudalism in Latin America and that it therefore makes no sense to talk about a bourgeois revolution." The realities of Latin America, of course, refute such a blanket assertion. Most Latin: American societies are a mixture of capitalism and feudalism.

‘But what is the ovérriding dominant phenomenon facing most, if not all, of the Latin American countries? It is that they are all victims of imperialist oppression.

Thus, breaking the chains of U. S. imperialist domination is the present overriding historic task. This is on the order of this day. Masses who have had enough of colonial oppression but who have > not yet decided what kind of a society should be built will join those who are convinced of the need for socialism in the struggle against imperialism. This is a necessary and an unavoidable step.

~The period between this hurdle and the struggle for socialism may be very brief, and the two may even overlap. The existence of the socialist world has a direct influence on these struggles. But the two tasks cannot be confused. Those with socialist convictions will be a part of and in fact the organizers of the anti-imperialist front and while doing so, will be working to convince all, about the advantages of the socialist path after the victory over imperialism. But the mass mobilization will be to achieve the first task first:

EDUARDO VALVERDE, member of the Secretariat of the People's Vanguard Party of Costa Rica, discusses these questions:

29.

"Feudal survivals, too, still make themselves felt, or even predominate, in the countryside in most Latin American countries. ... In Peru, Ecuador, Paraguay, Guatemala, El Salvador.and some other.: countries pre-capitalist production relations: are much more pronounced than in Argentina, Uruguay , Chile or | Mexico.

.But in: all circumstances” ‘in order ‘to pave. the way. ‘to. economic progress, ait is essential to win freedom from imperialist domination.

"Needless to say, our Party as well as the other Latin American Communist parties, unlike some 'ultra-revolutionary' groups...do not consider the winning of power by the working class and the full realization of the program of the socialist revolution to be the immediate task. The immediate prospect in our Countrses , as we see it, is the anti- imperialist. and. democratic revolution.

' "Moreover , worldwide experience - (and for us Latin-Americans the experience of Cuba above all) shows that at the present time the victory of the anti-imperialist and anti-feudal revolution is, as a rule, a precondition and “point of departure’ for the Socialist path of Sevelopment. '

. THE PROGRAM of the Communist Party, U. s. A. , also places this | question in a correct and clear manner: es

"We ‘Live’ ‘ina revolutionary age. ‘that. in scope and depth — eclipses all prior ages of social upheaval: and transformation. . Today the revolutionary tide extends to all continents, penetrates into the most remote jungles of Africa, climbs the most inaccessible mountain peaks of. Asia, stalks the plantationS'and mines of Latin America; sweeping-in its wake the overwhelming majority of mankind. Today's revolutions challenge the réign of. imperialism and monopoly capital everywhere. Those former revolutions ushéred in the age of capitalism: Today's revolutions mark mankind's’ historic transition from capitalism to socialism. oe

"The contemporary revolutions bear two distinctive marks: they are socialist, they are anti-imperialist. More than a billion human:. beings are embarked on socialist revolution. A larger number is in varying stages of anti- colonial revolution.

“The anti-colonial revolutions aim to. destroy imperialist. domination, feudal ‘bondagé and political tyranny. In the struggle for such aims- a’ broad: national ‘unity is. attainable, including «= .:capitalist elements who chafe under the’ oppressive: restrictions of. foreign monopoly. The attainment of such aims, progressive and liberating as they are, is not’ yet socialism. However, there is a close relation between the socialist and colonial. revolutions.

"1. Imperialism is the common’ enemy of both.

"2, The speed and scope of the colonial liberation tide is

made possible by the existence of the socialist world -- by its revolutionary example,::by. its. economic, diplomatic and military assistance, which greatly ‘restricts imperialism' f=) ability to suppress or strangle colonial revolutions... . .

"Thus, the two kinds of revolution typical of the age -- socialist and anti-colonial -- are distinct and yet interconnected parts of one vast revolutionary process. Each reinforces the other."

= By Joseph Hansen

In the April issue of the Monthly Review, Leo “Huberman and. Paul M. Sweezy, the editors of this internationally circulated independent socialist magazine, took shart issue with the way Fidel Castro criticized a wing of the Guatemalan guerrilla movement. In a speech January 15,.Castro. said that "Trotskyites" had infiltrated the movement and that Trotskyism was "a vulgar instrument of imperialism and reaction." The charge, said the editors of ‘the Monthly , Review, was "ugly and perhaps ominous." It was "precisely this accu-~ sation," they pointed out, "which provided the rationalization for the Soviet purge trials of the 1930's."

"Te anything has been proved -- and. not least. by the Soviet government itself," they continued, "--it is that the trials were a shameless frame-up; and no evidence has ever been produced to restore credibility to the accusation. Mo, oo,

They ascribed Castro! s “use. ‘of “Bpotskyism" in this. way £0 either ignorance or malice. "For our. part," they said, "we prefer to believe that in this matter Fidel himself is ignorant and that the matice comes from advisers who never abandoned the attitudes and methods which underlay the trials." They suggested that Fidel Castro as a-"latecomer" to the history of. the movement ("for reasons which do him no discredit") should take time out for some serious study and that "he could do worse than begin with Isaac Deutscher's brilliant three-volume study of Trotsky . which is much more than a personal biography." ;

In addition, the editors of the Monthly _ Review called Fidel | Castro's attention to the damage that was being done the Cuban Revolution by the continued silence on Che Guevara. Does Castro realize, they asked, "that every.day's delay in clearing up the mystery brings anxiety. and doubt to honest. revolutionaries: everywhere and joy to their enemies? *

They also pointed to the. ‘positive achievements. of the Tri- | continental Conference, disagreeing with Adolfo Gilly, who:in the... same issue of the Monthly Review declared that it was "a conference without glory and without program.”

To strengthen Cuba's independent position, they: called for diversification of the economy instead of relying mainly;on sugar.

Finally, they reiterated their position favoring the perspective of socialist” as opposed to "bourgeois" revolutions: in.. Latin America.: | A Reader Wonders Why

~The forthright stand taken by. the Monthly Review on these. issu@€s appears to have dismayed the leaders of the Communist Party, U.S.A. In the April 24 issue of The Worker, Gus Hall, the leading spokesman of the pro-Moscow, anti-Peking party, tried his hand at. replying in an article entitled "Gus Hall Answers a | Question on

← One-Day General Strike in Aden · Gus Hall's Formula for Dooming Revolutions →

Something wrong on this page?