Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The War Between India and Pakistan

· World Outlook Vol. 3, No. 28, 17 September 1965 · pp 6-9 · 1,682 words

South and Southeast Asia China Britain and Ireland United States

between India and Pakistan has not stopped, although the "big two," the United States and the Soviet Union,are supporting the efforts of U Thant, the secretary~general of the United Nations to at least get a ceasefire. These steps are doubtlessly being accom panied by various pressure moves, The United States and Great Britain have already suspended all shipments of arms. The question of econ-" omic sanctions has been raised.

. Will this pressure prove sufficient to halt the fighting or will the war become extended? It would be hazardous to offer a fore= cast on this; the conflict has deep causes.

It is necessary to go back to 1947 when the British government of that period (the Attlee Labour government) granted independence to the colony that constituted the crown jewel of the British empire, The Labour party glorified this action.

But the Labour government in London favored installing in power a bourgeoisie which for the past eighteen years has let India stagnate in the worst misery. In addition, faithful to the old maxim of "divide and rule,” which British- imperialism has applied throughout the world, the Labour government supported the demands of the Moslem League headed by Jinnah; i.e., one of the most reactionary political factions, in order to divide the Indian subcontinent along religious lines into two countries, India and Pakistan.

Still worse, since the former British colony was made up of a number of states and principalities, it was the maharajahs and other princes, and not the people living there who were called on to decide the fate of their states, choosing either India or Pakistan. The massacres at the time affected millions of persons; and the new war could set off new bloodbaths since 50,000,000 Moslems still live in India and 10,000,000 Hindus still live in Pakistan.

Upon reaching power, the bourgeoisie failed to carry out one of the traditional tasks of the bourgeois revolution; namely, unification of the country. On the contrary, Pakistan was set up as two separate pieces almost 1,000 miles apart. And many disputes remained between India and Pakistan, the most important one concerning Kashmir.

This territory was inhabited in the great majority by Moslems but the maharajah was a Hindu. After some equivocation, he came out for attaching Kashmir to India. This leg to fighting which ended in 1948 with a ceasefire, the division of Kashmir between the occupying forces, and a decision agreed to by both sides for a referendum that would enable the population to choose which country they wished to join.

ae en

There was every reason to believe that in a referendum the big majority of the population of Kashmir would come out for joining Pakistan. In any case, it has been this consideration that has determined the policy of the New Delhi government since 1948. It has con= tinually blocked holding a referendum. The prime minister of the part of Kashmir occupied by India, Sheik Abdullah, who cooperated with the Congress party before independence, was ousted and arrested in August 1953 and not freed, as we will see later, until April 1964 when he was released for a short period. His assistant, who became his successor, Baksi Ghulam Mohamed, was eliminated in turn in 1963. Beginning in 1948, the Indian government took a series of legislative and constitutional measures to convert the part of Kashmir under its occupation into an integral part of the Indian Union. Recently Prime Minister Shastri declared that the territory belonged to the Indian Union like any other territory, without any different status.

.. Pakistan at no time. subscribed to the concept that guided the New Delhi regime,

Pakistan. was created as a reactionary bastion designed to block any advance of the Indian revolution, This was the reason why it was favored from the beginning by British imperialism. In February 1954, American imperialism, which at that time looked with disfavor on : Nehru'ts "neutralisn, a began to send military aid to Pakistan, military aid which in its view was to be aimed against China and not against India, In 1962,-when the first frontier incidents broke out between India and China, the United States likewise sent arms to India to fight China.

But India and Pakistan had not forgotten the Kashmir business and this moved into the forefront. It appears that Nehru, before he died, thought of making a turn on this question, In April 1964 he freed Sheik Abdullah and permitted him to go to Pakistan. Whatever the truth about Nehru's intentions, the Shastri government continued to follow the line practiced by New Delhi since 1948. Sheik Abdullah only had to interview Chou En-lai in Algiers to be arrested again upon his return to India in May 1965. American and British arms were to serve India as well as Pakistan for an attempt to settle the dispute.

It is known that in recent weeks guerrilla fighters appeared in the part of Kashmir occupied by India. The Indian government, claiming that they were not guerrilla forces but regular troops of the Pakistan army, moved in the Indian army and hostilities flared,

The underlying cause of the war, as we have seen, lies in the way British imperialism, through the Labour government, granted independence to India, building in multiple explosive charges -~ religious, racial, etc. In other words, the struggle led by the Indian bourgeoisie against British imperialism ended in a form that has for many years blocked the development of the Indian revolution into a social-

~Be

ist revolution, which alone would have enabled the enormous difficulties to be overcome through a socialist federation of the peoples of the whole subcontinent, The example of India constitutes one of the most characteristic verifications in a negative way of the theory of permanent revolution. The Indian bourgeoisie have proved incapable of carrying out scarcely a single one of the bourgeois~democratic tasks (unification of the country, agrarian reform, rights of minority peoples),

Among the immediate causes of the outbreak of the conflict the following should be noted in particular:

(1) The bankruptcy of the leadership of the Congress party in India. This is to be seen all the more glaringly in light of the fact that despite the aid constantly received from the United States and the Soviet Union, India has stagnated economically whereas neighbor-= ing China has made impressive progress during the same fifteen-year period. The crisis in bourgeois leadership in India took on wider scope with the passing of Nehru. Reactionary tendencies grew more virulent in India and the idea of a military dictatorship has taken on more substance. It is a plausible contention that the army, in order to refurbish a prestige tarnished by its defeat on the Sino- Indian frontier, initiated hostilities against Pakistan in hope of an easy success, oS

(2) In India, as in Pakistan, in face of the tragic misery of the masses, the war is a diversion aimed at channeling the anger and passion visible in recent months in the hunger revolts,

(3) The development of the war in Vietnam and the American Nescalation" there could not help but strongly affect the neighboring countries, particularly by encouraging tendencies to try to resolve difficult problems by force. A London newspaper, the Daily Telegraph, reported that the CIA was involved in the Indian government's decision to unleash hostilities, The report, of course, has been officially denied as is always the custom in Washington. Nevertheless, one cannot fail to notice that the Indo-Pakistan war has captured interest, that it is getting the major headlines, and that it has diverted attention from Vietnam as American reinforcement of troops there mounts day by day.

The attitude of China and Indonesia in the Indo~Pakistan con-= flict, has been singled out by the press ~= and not only the press -= as a scandalous opposition to the "peace" efforts of the United States, the Soviet Union and the United Nations. However, skepticism may well be expressed over the "pacifism" of the one side and the “belligerency" of the other.

Long before the war broke out, the United States armed both India and Pakistan against China. The Soviet government, it cannot

Qa

be forgotten, likewise furnished planes” to India during the conflict between India and China. The "pacifists" of today played the big power game for years at the expense of China.

It happens that China is now able to turn the tables, to play the same big power game. Those who are caught in their own moves really have nothing to complain about. No revolutionist can blame China, in seeking as a state power to profit from the consequences of a Situation which she not only did not create but which in its origin was directed against her.

Where revolutionists should judge the Chinese policy in the

Indo~Pakistan: conflict, aside from the governmental aspect, is onthe level of revolutionary politics. Unfortunately, from all the inform- -ation at our disposal, it must be concluded that the Chinese leaders are seeking to subordinate the vanguard, including the pro-Chinese Communists to their temporary diplomatic needs in Pakistan,

cya

te oO

Can India and Pakistan continue the war if they are subjected to economic sanctions by the big powers? We must not forget that some 500,000,000 people are involved in the struggle and that it is impossible to foresee what their reactions might be.

In a situation as serious as this one, one of the most somber aspects is the situation facing the revolutionary vanguard, In Pakistan they are extremely weak in number. In India most of the organizations that have been speaking in the name of socialism, including some that have been champions of nonviolence, have voiced outrageous chauvinist sentiments in connection with the war against Pakistan,

The opponents of the war include in particular the left Com munist party and the Trotskyists who have just organized the Socialist Workers party. They face a difficult period. There is no doubt that the repression will be severe,

But the struggle which they have undertaken, aside from the vicissitudes that can be expected, will contribute to accelerating the decomposition of the bourgeois system,

← Bertrand Russell on the Revolt in Los Angeles · Young Japanese Workers Turning to Socialism →

Something wrong on this page?