Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

PERSPECTIVE MONDIALE - Hebdomadaire Abonnement, 26 numéros : 37,50 F, à Pierre FRANK, 21, rue d'Aboukir, Paris (2°)

· World Outlook Vol. 3, No. 22, 11 June 1965 · pp 32-35 · 1,169 words

France

PERSPECTIVE

By Pierre Frank

- Faced with a presidential election at the end of the year, the fifty-fifth congress of the SFIO [Section Frangaise Internation«ale Ouvrisre -= the French Social Democratic party], held at Clichy . June 5-6, could only ratify the candidacy of Gaston Defferre, the mayor of Marseilles. ("To give up his candidacy would be a genuine catastrophe," General Secretary Guy Mollet declared.) No one had any alternative to propose. As for the future of the Socialist party and the possible "Democratic Socialist Federation" proposed by Defferre, the problem remains.

With Defferre as their candidate, something worse than a defeat awaits the opponents of de Gaulle. It is quite evident that the PCF [French Comaunist party] cannot play Defferre's game. The PCF leadership is under compulsion to run its own candidate, while trying to hold losses to the minimum. These will be due in particular to the fact that the numerous statements of the Communist leaders on the "yositive aspects" of de Gaulle's foreign policy will serve him the

way similar statements served him in the plebiscite of September 28, 1958. As for Defferre, despite all the-calculations of his "brain trust," not only will he take no votes away from the PCF, he will lose from his own left to the probable candidate of the PSU LParti Socialiste Unifié] and there is no guarantee that he can compensate from the right with votes picked up from the MRP [Mouvement Républicain Populaire].

The presidential election will prove to be at bottom a plebiscite for de Gaulle. Some of Defferre's partisans say that he.is looking aheac, to the succession to de Gaulle. For the most conscious politicians of French capitalism, the problem posed by the succession is maintenance of the "strong state," a presidential-type regime. But these same politicians are too shrewd to envisage carrying this out with men like...Defferre or Pompidou.

Actually a grave crisis in French society is maturing under the fagade of political apathy presented by the Gaullist regime. To the right, much more dangerous than the agitation of the ultras will be the calculations and possible undertakings of the army, an army. that has been more and more trimmed in the direction of a professional army. Along with this is the developing crisis in the Socialist party, the depth of which was shown at the Clichy congress.

The "Democratic Socialist Federation" proposed by Defferre is nothing less than the dissolution of the Socialist party, not even in exchange for a formation the program of which would be like that cf the German Social Democracy, but a formation without any real structure at all. The envisaged Federation would be the "UNR"* of a Defferre! It was quite symptomatic that the main oratorical clash at the Clichy congress occurred between the Marseilles mayor and Augustin Laurent, the mayor of Lille. In Marseilles,Defferre wins his elections without a strong labor following. In Lille, Laurent is backed by the majority of the workers and has to defend this majority against the encroachment of a strong Communist minority. His language reflected this fact:

"T agree with the idea that a federation could go further, aiming at the organic unification of the Socialists, but I hope that the federation will be willing at that time to address all those who accept the grand idea of socialism, including the Communists. It will only be then that the millions of workers, whose power today is paralyzed, will understand that the genuine future of the socialist democracy in France goes along the road of labor unity. Why cover up this aspect of things? You know very well that our difficulties arise from the existence of the Communist party. I am against the Communists because they compelled us to take up responsibilities in

*The Union pour la Nouvelle République organized by Gen. de Gaulle as his personal party.

the defense of the Republic that prevented us from being ourselves. But a Socialist party must never say that it gives up the desire to some day unite the whole world of labor."

One can smile at Laurent's words about what the Communists "compelled" the Socialists to do (break strikes? conduct the war against Algeria? enter de Gaulle's government in 19587), but it is quite clear that the Socialist party in France cannot carry out an operation such as Defferre proposes without repelling what remains of its own worker base, driving them toward the PCF despite the politics of that organization.

Since the Socialist congress was split down the middle and could not go back on Defferre's candidacy, it voted one hundred per cent, or close to it, for a document on which every one had his reservations.

For Defferre, the "movement" around his candidacy, the petty bourgeoisie and bourgeoisie associated with it, will serve to liquidate the old ideas and the old party. It is worth noting the numerous pessimistic statements made about the Socialist party by him and his partisans at the congress. (Defferre stressed the loss of mem-— bers. A senator from Seine-et-Oise said, "We are suffering from leukemia.) On the other hand, his opponents count on the electoral defeat dealing a blow in the SFIO to Defferrets "Federation." The mayor of Lille talked about the "bursting of this soap bubble," Finally, Mollet stressed the changes occurring in the POF.

Thus the Socialist party which was the axis of almost all the governmental combinations during the Fourth Republic and which suffered a split to the left after de Gaulle came to power, is now threatened with a deep division in which its existence as a workers party is at stake. The issue will not fail to flare up again after the election.

In the PCF, the leadership has refrained from publicly expressing the internal differences troubling the party. The continuation of Defferre's candidacy under the conditions approved by the Clichy congress extricates it from a quandary. But this does not end its deep difficulties within the framework of the international crisis of Stalinism due to the absence of policy and authoritative leader~ ship since the death of Thorez.

Even the bureaucratic success chalked up less than three months ago in the Communist Student Union proved ephemeral, the new leadership of that organization having already divided politically.

In the corridors, the PCF leadership (or a part of it) appears to be moving toward. the "Italian" position. But. this will not solve the problem, since the PCF does not have the advantage currently enjoyed by the Italian Communist party; namely, of operating within

35m

the framework of bourgeois democracy. The Gaullist regime does not make things easy for parties that want to live and to act as in the days of the Third and the Fourth Republic,

The die is cast for the next presidential election. An electoral defeat is inevitable. What is important is to draw lessons from this defeat that can serve to renovate the labor movement in order to avoid subsequent defeats of a kind much worse than: those on the electoral level.

← Italian CP Leaders Air Differences · Deutscher Describes "Teach-In" Movement →

Something wrong on this page?