PUZZLING DEFEAT IN SOUTH VIETNAM
By Joseph Hansen
Why isn't the U.S. winning in South Vietnam? The White House, the State Department, the Central Intelligence Agency and the Pentagon have no answer. They avoid admitting this, however, by forecasting, if not victory, at least ultimate attainment of a position of strength from which to negotiate,
The mystery of Americats incapacity to win was pointed up again by the uprising of the Montagnards, the. primitives in the hills whom American Special Forces teams have been training for the past two years in the modern techniques of fighting Communism,
On September 20, these tribes suddenly revolted. Armed | with bows and arrows, according to a Saigon report, they arrested their American advisers and seized the Ban Me Thuot radio station,
To appreciate the effect of this news in Washington, you need to know something about the training received by the Speoial Forces teams, An inside story on this recently appeared in the weekly London Observer [August 2], Written by Andrew Wilson, the account begins as follows:
Politics and Psychology
"tThis is survival training,! said the colonel, offering me a snack of fox and racoon meat cut into small dry cubes. Out side the grass shelter. the sun shone on a pine wood where there were frequent explosions and gunfire,
"We were visiting. the United States Army Special Warfare Centre at Fort Bragg, North Carolina, which trains specialists in counter~subversion and guerrilla tactics for the war in Vietnam."
Fort Bragg, continues Wilson, is concerned primarily with Vietnam, "though it could as readily provide counter~subversion teams for the Arctic." Among other things, Fort Bragg contains "a replica of a Vietnamese village for demonstrating Vietcong tactics and a classroom where pretty Asian girls from the Berlitz language school teach basic Vietnamese in six weeks."
The Special Forces trainees, who "wear commando~style berets," learn every trick in the trade. First comes basic training in "unarmed combat and underwater demolition." Then specialization in “political and psychological warfare." ss
How thorough Washington is in schooling its men in this kind
of warfare can be gathered from the following:
‘Since political warfare must be waged in the field, students are trained to feel at home at an 'tunderdeveloped! level. They learn how to kill a man with one's bare hands, how to bite off the head of a snake, and how to manufacture propaganda leaflets with kits made from boot polish and jungle berries."
With such training in political and psychological warfare, the Americans should be sure winners in Vietnam. Yet no one seems to be betting on them,
"at Fort Bragg," reports Wilson, "one cannot help asking why, with all this diligence and tough training, the war in Viet~ nam is going so badly? Officers reply wryly that it's not the fault of the Special Forces but the unwillingness of the South Vietnamese to follow good advice,"
The Special Forces in Action
. Let us now turn to what happens in the field, We are indebted to three American officers for the latest facts, In Saigon, on September 29, Col. John Freund, an artillery officer, Brig. Gen, William EZ. Denny, assistant chief of staff, and Col, Irving Wendt, who was daily ferried with messages in and out of the camp of the mountain tribesmen, granted a. press conference, The three officers made no criticisms, either "implied or direct," of the Special Forces teams.
"But under questioning," reports Peter Grose, special cor- ~— respondent of the New York Times, “facts about the rebellion emerged showing how little control or even knowledge the Americans living at the camps can have over crucial political developments around them,"
As extraordinary as this may appear, in view of the training they received at Fort Bragg, the full story is even more astoundinge
"Tt also seemed that the Special Forces troops were powerless to prevent being used for pro-Communist purposes by the Montagnards.
Here are the facts as. put together by Grose:
"Tt was disclosed that an American Special Forces captain had been disarmed and made to accompany three jeeploads of Montagnard agitators into the Darlac province capital of Ban Met Huot to distribute mimeographed pamphlets denouncing ‘American imperialists! and using Communist terminology in putting Montagnard demands for autonony.
216
"Presumably, with an American along, Montagnard jeeps would not be stopped,
"Similarly, it was stated that no warnings or hints of rebellion had been reported from any of the five camps that participated in the uprising.
Namericans were living at each of the camps but were apparently unable to detect strangers moving in and out of the camps to coordinate planning in the days or even hours before the revolt,"
What Went Wrong?
If there were any extenuating circumstances, these were not revealed, For instance, the Special Forces teams may have run out of boot polish, a necessary ingredient in putting-out propaganda leaflets with jungle berries, This could explain much about the unfortunate breakdown in the situation.
On the other hand, they may have produced an abundance of such propaganda leaflets, the effect of which nevertheless turned out to.be limited due to an unforeseen advance in technology in the area, If the New York Times account is accurate, these bow-andarrow primitives seem to prefer material produced on a mimeograph. In fact, some way or other, they have discovered how to operate a mimeocgraph themselves, thus outmoding the role of boot polish and jungle berries in their politics and psychology. Seemingly they have also learned how to drive American jeeps, using them to transport their mimeographed pamphlets, On the other hand, the fact that display of a Fort Bragg alumnus is held by them to make a journey safer shows that they have not completely transcended the fetish level,
It could also be that in carrying out political and psycholog-= ical warfare in accordance with what they learned at Fort Bragg, the Special Forces teams failed in the snake decapitation ritual. This might not necessarily be due to any sag in morale. It could be due to a sag in the supply of snakes. The low supply of snakes, in turn, could be due to natural causes, or it could be an unexpected side effect from chemicals used in defoliating the jungle, This obviously deserves investigation,
Nowever, it could be that the source of the trouble does not Lie in the Pleld at all, It could be that some of the theories at Fort Bragg are at fault. Perhaps certain parts of the training should be re-examined, In feeding trainees, for instance, is it meally | good practice to supply fox and racoon meat in "small dry cubes" iixactly why should a dehydrated product be put in their Sishes? ‘The literature offered by manufacturers of other lines of
dog food might be referred to for valuable suggestions, including savings: to the American taxpayers, -
One item in particular in the Fort Bragg curriculum might be made the subject of inquiry -- by a responsible body, of course, like the House Un-American Activities Committee, This is the six weeks basic Vietnamese taught by "pretty Asian girls,"
Just what does the "basic Vietnamese" taught by these "pretty Asian girls" include? It is understandable, naturally, that young men on their way to the swamps and jungles of Southeast Asia, should be "trained to feel at home at. an 'underdeveloped! level"; but in what area are the wily Communists more likely to practice infiltrathan where "pretty Asian girls" are used? Shouldn't Congress make it mandatory that basic Vietnamese be taught to unsophisticated trainees solely through phonograph records officially checked and supervised by the FBI?
Another alternative, of course, is just to get the hell out of South Vietnam and let the Vietnamese run their own affairs. However, the strategists who conceived the Fort Bragg program appear unwilling to draw such a conclusion. Perhaps they are right. To become a modern nation, every people at one point or another must learn how to throw out intruders, The American Special Forces teams appear to be teaching the Vietnamese in the South useful lessons in this just as the French troops before them hetped teach the Vietnamese in the North,
FREEDOM NOW