Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The Territorial Issues in the Sino-Soviet Dispute

World Outlook Vol. 2, No. 32, 25 September 1964 · pp 5-7 · 933 words

Soviet Union Fourth International China

THE TERRITORIAL ISSUES IN THE SINO-SOVIET DISPUTE

[An inquiry about the stand of the Trotskyists on two important questions in the Sino-Soviet dispute was recently received by the Fourth International, These were:

[(1) The claims raised by the People's Republic of China to territory that has been held by the Soviet Union since the overthrow of the Czarist government .

[(2) Chinats support | of Japants claim to the Kurile. Islands, which were taken by the Soviet: Union after its victory in World War’ ; II,

[Pierre Frank, one of the main figures of the Fourth International, gave the following reply.]

(ve J.

“” SOK

I should like to thank you for providing me with the opportunity to deal with questions on which the Fourth International itself has not yet taken a formal stand, We have been preoccupied with the fundamental international issues at stake among the workers parties and have placed priority on these questions rather than the relations among workers states. But it goes without saying that the Fourth International, Tike all other working-class organizations, must likewise take a position on issues involving relations among: the workers states, e

We took up the question:in a broad way at the time of the break between the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia in 1948, When the Soviet technicians were withdrawn from China, we again considered. the problem, What we said then still holds; namely, that differences... among the parties in power, even if they lead to a split, should in no case be permitted to provoke serious repercussions between states having the same social character.

-This is the broad principle we hold to in determining our position with regard to the territorial problems that have been raised.

In the question of the Kurile Islands, Khrushchev was reported to have said to some visitors from Japan: "As for the Kurile Islands they have no-economic importance for:the USSR. They are only of military importance, If the United States should some day withdraw from Japan and give up Okinawa, well we would reciprocate one hundred per cent." (Le Monde , September 17.

If this is ‘an accurate report, Khrushchev. himself recognizes that the Kuriles are Japanese territory. ms

To justify the occupation of foreign territory by a workers!

ore!

state, the Fourth International would in no case argue its “economic importance," The bargaining aspect, in which Khrushchev involves the United States, is likewise inadmissible. On the other hand, in cer~ tain circumstances, we would not deny that the Soviet government has the right to take into account military considerations involving the defense of the Soviet Union, But such considerations must be advanced with a good deal of caution. Above all, it is necessary to prove whether present militant needs are of such nature that they must take priority over everything else -- especially the negative repercussions that can occur among the masses of the occupied country. As a general rule, it appears to us that the military benefits are minor compared to the accompanying political disadvantages, a

With regard to territories in dispute between two workers states ~~ in this case the Soviet Union and the People's Republic of China «~- we cannot take as the criterion either the shifts in bound-~ ary lines of long ago or the fact that the Soviet Union is the oldest workers! state. The criterion should only be the wishes of the peoples now living in these areas, The right of a people to determine their own fate is the-only fundamental criterion, This was the traditional. position of the Bolsheviks as it is today of the Fourth International, a

In October 1917 the young Soviet power recognized: the right of Poland, Finland and other countries ‘to decide for ‘themselves, even if this signified bourgeois rule, If it is now objected that since then the Soviet Union was constituted, it should be recalled that in 1922 . when this occurred, the issue was discussed and Lenin took a strong position in favor of the right of every Soviet republic to separate from the Union (see his letters of December 30 and Sl, 1922, on the nationality question, which were violently. aimed against Stalin and . the Great Russian bureaucracy). ‘The platform of the Left Opposition (Trotsky+Zinoviev) in 1927 likewise vigorously defended national rights within the Soviet Union. Trotsky was even in favor of the right of the Ukraine to constitute an independent Soviet Republic.

What the wishes of the populations are in the areas referred to by the Chinese leadership and by Khrushchev are not known to us. But the only fundamental criterion, I emphasize once more, is the right of peoples to determine their own fate, The problem of boundary lines. and similar issues are heritages of the past or arise in the process of constructing the socialist society, The workers states should work out. some kind of international law and institutions: independent of the state structures to which such questions could be submitted and resolved acoording to the criteria of socialist democracy.

Unfortunately, these contradictions are now being exacerbated by the ruling bureaucracies. However, it seems improbable to us that the current tensions involving territorial questions between the Soviet Union and China could degenerate into an armed conflict, al+ though the dispute has been embittered in a dangerous way.

we Tne

We are confident that the current crisis of the Communist movement will, after sharp struggles,:end with the removal of Stalinism and all the gross bureaucratic deformations, One of the consequences will be a great improvement in relations among the workers states, But this outcome is still not something immediate,

← Attempt to Crush Political Opposition in Bolivia · Negro Struggle Shakes Party Alignments in U.S. →

Something wrong on this page?