ALEXANDER DEFENCE RALLY IN LONDON
"Tt is not often that I presume to speak for the labour move~ ment as a wnole but on this occasion I have no doubt that the Labour party is with me ," said Sidney Silverman, a Member of Parliament, at a packed meeting in the Caxton Hall tonight.
The meeting was called by the Alexander Defence Committee to launch a nation-wide campaign to raise $2,500 [$7,000] to help pay the cost of the appeal of Dr. Neville Alexander and 10 others (six men and four women) arrested in Cape Town, South Africa in July, 1963, under the infamous 90-Day-No~Triai-Clause and tried for "sabotage’ in November,
“An appeal was granted on certain irregularities; e.g., the instructions of Alexander to his counsel had been opened and read by the police, etc. It is hoped that the: appeal will be heard in. about eight weeks, Bates
Guest speaker was Dr. Wolfgang Mueller, formerly a student friend of Alexander at Ttibingen University, and Acting Secretary of the West German Alexander Defence Committee. The German campaign had raised £4,000 [$11,200] and collected over 5,000 signatures on petitions to the United Nations to intervene, explained Dr. Mueller, He made an impassioned plea for similar action to be taken in Britain,
Barnei Desai, President. of the South African Coloured Peoples Congress, said that Alexander's struggle for justice represents the struggles of thousands of unknown Africans serving heavy jail sentences under Verwoerd's tyrannical regime.
Other speakers included Raymond Kunene, representative in. Britain and Europe of the African National Congress; C. Van Gelderen, Hammersmith Borough Councillor and Ellis Hillman, London County Councillor, The chairman was Chris Arthur, president of the National Association of Labour Student Organizations,
' Among an impressive list of individuals and organizations who sponsored the meeting were Frank Allaun, M.P.; Bob Edwards, M.P., General Secretary of the Chemical Workers Union; Ernie Roberts, Assistant. General Secretary of the Amalgamated Engineering Union and a number of Labour Party and Young Socialist bra anches.
Mrs. Connie Kirkby, the secretary of the Alexander Defence Committee, announced that postal orders and cheques should be made out to Defence and Aid, Alexander Appeal. The mailing address is Mrs, Connie Kirkby, a7” Thurs ley House, Holmewood Gardens, London, S.W.2. .
Tho. meeting closed by passing a resolution endorsing the actions and proposals of the Committee,
oly a
"I HAVE NOT FORGOTTEN. . .
By Pierre Frank
Within a few weeks of each other, the heads of the two biggest Communist parties of western Europe died. While purely accidental, the coincidence of the two events provides a political symbol of the greatest significance. In effect, the death of the two men marks the end of an epoch,
Among the leaders of the world's Communist parties, Togliatti was the oldest, holding seniority even over Mao Tse-tung. Thorez, likewise an elder among the leaders of the Communist movement, was of working-class background; Togliatti was an intellectual. Both of them belonged to the young generation in the.old socialist parties. following World War I who turned toward the October Revolution to re~ new the workers! movement which had been defiled by the betrayal of the Social Democracy in 1914, Both of them, in the enthusiasm of their youth, were attracted by Bolshevism, .
Each of them, of course, underwent different experiences for a long time, The Italian Communist party was driven underground in 1922-25 and did not begin to function openly until after the downfall of Mussolini, The French Communist party did not go through the underground experience until during the second world war, There were likewise significant differences in the character and comportment of the two men, Togliatti was more supple than’ Thorez, although this should not be exaggerated as has been done by many commentators, The suppleness of Thorez was evidenced often. 1. enough and Togliatti dis- ~ played his bureaucratic aptitude.
One essential characteristic brought them together, even united them: Both Thorez and Togliatti utilized their talents and their posi-~ tions they had won, to place the organizations that had been created to prepare and lead the proletarian revolution in the service of the Soviet bureaucracy when, under Stalin's leadership, this bureaucracy usurped power in the Soviet state and in the Communist International. This was not an easy operation, and Thorez and Togliatti came to play their role only after hesitancy and reservations. In 1924, Thorez distributed Trotsky!s New Course in the Pas-de-Calais federation of which he was’ secretary. Even in 1928, in the corridors of the Sixth Gongress of the International he indicated his reservations on tne theory of “socialism in one country." At the same congress, Togliatti supported Bukharin, and it was while the car was going full speed, it could be said, that he jumped out when, a few months later,,. Stalin cut down Bukharin and crushed the Right Opposition in the USSR and the Communist International.
These old leaders of the Communist movement were perfectly aware of Stalin's crimes; they were particularly cognizant of the
policy of the "third period" and how fatal it was in Germany in 1933, But both of them served as willing tools of the Soviet bureaucracy; both of them became Stalinists above. all because they had lost confidence in the revolutionary capacities of the working class,
In the years following the war, differences arose betwoen Thorez and Togliatti, but these remained within the framework of their common loyalty to the Soviet bureaucracy. (It has even been observed that there was something symbolic in the fact that both of them died not in their own country but in the Soviet Union or on the way there, )
More important than the differences which developed with regard to their positions in the Sino-Soviet conflict was the fact that they shared a fundamental point of departure -- in practice they had given up the proletarian revolution and envisaged no road to socialism except the "peaceful" one. With both of them this was not just a concept; they actually assured the bourgeoisie through their deeds that the parties they led constituted no revolutionary threat.
The working masses unfortunately have not yet understood this, That is the explanation in part for the hundreds of thousands of people who turned out for the funerals. Consequently most of the petty-bourgeois intellectuals in the periphery of the workers! move-~ ment are unable to understand the historic role of a Thorez and a Togliatti; hence the many stupidities like those uttered by: Sartre with regard to both men.
But the most clear-sighted elements among the bourgeoisie of France and Italy understood this role quite accurately, They did not forget the situation at the time of the liberation from the German occupation and the immense service that Thorez and Togliatti rendered them, How strongly impressed they were can be judged from the fact that twenty years later they publicly expressed their recognition over the coffins of the two leaders,
Here is the letter which de Gaulle sent to one of the sons of Thorez, authorizing its publication:
"T offer you and your family my sincere condolences in your grief over the death of your father, For my part, I have not forgotten that at a decisive time for France, President Maurice Thorez -whatever may have been his actions before and after that -- in response to my appeal and as a member of my government contributed to maintaining national unity. Please accept, Sir, my deepest regards,"
. IT have not