TROTSKYIST POSITION ON CHINESE-SOVIET RIFT
ROME, Feb, 18 -- A statement of the position of the Internationa! Secretariat of the Fourth International on the Chinese-Soviet rift was released today by Livio Maitan. The statement begins by referring to the fact that at the inception of the dispute two ana a hai? years ago. the IS in an "Open Letter" gave critical support te the position: defended by the Chinese Communist party inasmuch as it fels thea tha: on most of the key issues of the international! class struzele. the pesitirons of the Chinese were more to the left en more rrozressive :san those taken by the Khrushchev terdency.
Yiewing the differences as they now stand, the statement hoicn that on the fsllowing points the CCP has shown itseif to be furthe: +o she left and more correct than the Khrushchev tendency:
(1) That imperialism has not changed its nature and that in the struggle agsinst imperialist war preparations, one shou"d not
. a sow illusions about this or. that imperialist group.
(2) That the risk of atiother world war can be ‘ended only by overthrowing imperialism and capitalism.
(3) That the needs of the colonial revolution must not be subordinated to the alleged "needs" of "peaceful coexistence."
(4) That no reliance can be placed on the national bourgeoisie of colonial and semicolonial countries and that a revolution once begun tends to proceed in an "uninterrupted" way, a view which approaches Trotsky's theory of the permanent revolution.
(5) That it is illusory to believe in a "peaceful road towards socialism" in the imperialist countries, not least of the illusions being the so-called "theory" of "structural reforms" advocated by the Italian CP leader Togliatti; this, in fact, being a theory that socialism can achieve victory without overthrowing the bourgeois state machine. .
(6) That the "five. conditions" placed by Fidel Castro during the recent Cuban crisis deserved immediate support, as. was given by the Chinese; that Khrushchev spread an illusion when he held that Kennedy had given a "guarantee" not to invade Cuba again; and that the Cubans were correct in rejecting unilateral inspection by the United Nations of military bases in Cuba.
(7) That a majority and minority can coexist in the world Communist movement and in a Communist party ard that a minority can sometimes be right against the majority.
While holding the view that these positions are generally more progressive than the reformist political line followed by the leader~ ship of the Communist party of the Soviet Union and of most other CP’s, the statement criticizes the Chinese as taking stands alien to Marxism-Leninism on the following issues:
(1) Their underestimation of the results of a nuclear world War.
(2) Their unprincipled bloc with the Enver Hodza clique in Albania and their refusal to support de~Stalinization in the Soviet Union the way Castro did.
(4) Their unprincipled characterization of Yugoslavia as a capitalist state.
(4) Their maintenance of a bureaucratic regime within the Chinese workers state and the Chinese Communist party.
The statement holds that the discussion in the Communist nove ment will inevitably deepen, posing more and more sharply ali the key questions of Communist policy in the world today. It is in the interests of the Communist movement as a whole to make possible a
-l10=clear and public confrontation of positions, including those developed by the Trotskyist movement and other tendencies.
The debate should not be carried on in a dogmatic, byzantine and sterile way] the statement advocates, but on the basis of the extremely rich and variegated experiences undergone by the revolutionary working-class movement, For that reason the International Secretariat of the Fourth International. favors an international conference of the world Communist movement, provided that it is a genuinely democratic forum where each tendency can freely express its views and from which no tendency is excluded. ,
In the last analysis, the statement concludes, the current crisis in the world Communist movement can come to an end only through new orgenizational crystallizations which will free the international working-class movement from the grip of stultifying bureaucratic practices.
"