Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

Israel: Statement of Three Anti-Zionist Organizations

· Inprecor no. 42, 22 January 1976 · pp 31-32 · 1,333 words

This text was corrected by hand against the scan: read from the scan on 17 October 2026 (pp. 31-32) after a reader's report on the byline: the editors' introduction names the three signatory organizations, credited here. The heading and introduction had been run into the end of the article before it, and the last third (p. 32) into the Sahara declaration. Words lost at a blurred fold or the trimmed edge of the scan are in square brackets

Middle East

[When the General Assembly of the United Nations adopted the resolution condemning Zionism as a form of racism, the Zionist authorities in Israel and their spokesmen in the imperialist world protested. They hurried to utilize their old mystifying weapon, which consists of identifying anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism. It is an old maneuver aimed at keeping the Jews in Israel united around the leadership of Zionist adventurers, united in support of the worst crimes against the Arab people of Palestine. Doing this requires maintaining the besieged-ghetto atmosphere in Israel itself. Against this propaganda, revolutionary anti-Zionists in Israel united around the position expressed in the following statement, which was issued in Jerusalem on November 23, 1975. It was signed by three organizations: the Israeli Socialist Organization (Matzpen), the Revolutionary Communist Alliance (Ma'avak), and the Revolutionary Communist League (Fourth International).]

* * *

Long before the UN General Assembly resolution condemning Zionism, to be exact, eighty years before, Theodore Herzl, the author of The Jewish State, wrote: "We will constitute a bastion against Asia and a forward post in defense of civilization against barbarism. As a sovereign state, we will ceaselessly constitute a link and will be related to the peoples of Europe; for their part, they will guarantee our existence." And thus it is. Of all the predictions and judgments pronounced by the founder of Zionism, this is perhaps one of the few that retains its full validity and significance today. It concisely describes, in bourgeois language, the situation of Israel today. The Zionist state stands against the Arab masses (Asia, barbarism) because it is linked life and death to imperialism.

As revolutionary socialists, our rejection of Zionism is profound and basic. We have adhered to this rejection ever since we began to organize ourselves into political formations in order to advance the struggle for the socialist revolution in our region. Through their anti-Zionist position, the Jews among us represent the best of the revolutionary and democratic traditions of the Jewish masses throughout the world. Through their anti-Zionist position, the Arabs among us represent not only the aspirations of the Arab masses for national and social liberation, but also the best of the spirit and traditions of tolerance that were enjoyed by the Jews who lived among the Arab peoples in the past. Together, Jews and Arabs, we constitute a single bloc, which we put forward as an example and which we point to as the only alternative to the present situation in which Jews and Arabs pay in blood for occupation and oppression, discrimination and expulsion.

In proclaiming this, we say in fact that the resolution of the General Assembly does not concern us. For what would have happened if the General Assembly had ruled otherwise on the question of Zionism? Would we have changed our views on Zionism? Absolutely not. Especially since among both the adversaries and defenders of Zionism in the General Assembly we find representatives of governments that make exploitation and oppression, discrimination and even racism, the basis of their policies. At the same time, there is no doubt that the General Assembly resolution expresses the fact that Zionism is increasingly being laid bare and exposed and that its good old days are at an end. And it is the Zionists themselves more than anyone else who have contributed to this. Through their words and through their deeds.

We base our opposition to Zionism on the fact, among others, that Zionism implies the establishment of a Jewish state in violation of the human and national rights of the Arab people of Palestine. And it is a fact that every step taken by Zionism in this country implied the expropriation of the Palestinians' land and their expulsion from their homeland. The Zionists themselves proclaimed their intentions when they arrived in this country: "the conquest of Hebrew labor, the conquest of the land, the constitution of an entirely Jewish society." It so happened that they purely and simply denied the facts and spoke of a "land without people for a people without land."

Zionism implies discrimination by one national group against another. Zionism implies a privileged situation for Jews in Israel and throughout the whole world and simultaneously transforms the Palestinians under its power into second-class citizens. Look, for example, at the famous "law of return," which accords automatic Israeli citizenship to any Jew in the world, while the Palestinian masses are still denied the right to return to their homeland. Look, for example, at the statutes of the of the Jewish Agency, drafted in 1929 and still in effect today: "The land has been acquired as Jewish property and shall remain the inalienable property of the Jewish people and shall not be transmittable. The Agency shall encourage agricultural colonization based on Jewish labor, and in all enterprises that it carries out or encourages, it shall be a principle to employ Jewish labor." Look, for example, at the policy of confiscation of Arab lands and their transfer into Jewish hands — a policy common to all governments of Israel from the establishment of the Jewish state to today. It was [not us], nor was it any other anti-Zionist, who coined the [one word illegible on the scan] term "Judaization of Galilee." It was the leaders and spokesmen of Israel that did so.

Zionism implies the acceptance of imperialist patronage and labor in the service of imperialism; in this sense, Zionism is an instrument against the Arab national movement and a policeman against the struggles of the Arab people to break the yoke of local and foreign exploitation. Let us simply recall the support and guardianship extended to the Hashemite monarchy for several decades and the war waged against Egypt in the service of Britain and France in 1956.

Zionism implies resignation to anti-Semitism, which is considered as a universal phenomenon, natural and eternal.

That is only a little, but it is enough. The more courageous and frank a Zionist is, the more he recognizes these facts openly. The more a Zionist tries to disguise himself as a liberal, a democrat, or even a socialist, the more he tries to hide and camouflage, muddle or deny these truths.

Zionism, which claimed to offer a solution to the evils plaguing the Jews, itself constitutes a genuine evil for the Jews. Capitalism, not content with striking mortal blows against the Jews, also provided them with a "solution" to the evils plaguing them that was no less tragic than their sufferings themselves. In a certain sense, one can say that the Jews, oppressed under the boots of the lord, have themselves become a new lord oppressing another people: the Arab people of Palestine.

That is why it is not enough simply to say that Zionism created the Palestinian problem. Zionism also created a Jewish problem, a concrete danger for the Jews of Israel and for those Jews elsewhere in the world who tie their own fate to the fate of Zionism.

Our struggle against Zionism is a struggle to win the human and national rights of the Palestinian Arab people, but it is also a contribution to saving the Jews of Israel.

The Zionists, who claim to represent the Jews of the whole world, tell them: "The whole world is against us[."] We, on the other hand, say that the Jews, like all othe[r] peoples, are an integral part of humanity. The Zionists say that the Jews exist in spite of history, and we say that they exist through history. The Zionists sanction and perpetuate enmity between the Jews and other peoples, while we work to eliminate enmity among peoples in general and to eliminate enmity toward the Jews in particular. We are struggling against Zionism, for the integration of the Israeli-Jewish people into the Arab East. Our struggle for socialism includes the struggle for the respect of the human and national rights of both the Arabs of Palestine and the Jews of Israel. For socialism is the liberation of humanity. Of Arab humanity and of Jewish humanity.

← France: The PCF and the Crisis of Capitalism · Sahara: Against the Imperialist Repression of the Saharan People — Declaration of the United Secretariat of the Fourth International →

Something wrong on this page?