Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The Death of Jabra Nicola

· Inprecor no. 18, 31 January 1975 · p 2 · 893 words

This text was corrected by hand against the scan: read from the scan on 7 October 2026 (pp. 2 and 23): the OCR had dropped the second column of p. 2, and the continuation on p. 23 had been run into the France article

Middle East Fourth International The national question

Jabra Nicola, a former leader of the Palestine Communist party (PCP), a long-time member of the International Executive Committee of the Fourth International, and more recently a leading theoretical contributor to the Israeli Socialist Organization, died in London on Saturday, December 28.

For over three decades comrade Nicola, better known to many as Abu Said, held high the banner of revolutionary Marxism in the Middle East. In such a total bastion of reaction as Zionist Israel, this was no mean achievement.

His death comes as a grievous loss to the Arab working class movement and to the Fourth International. An assessment of this loss must take as its point of departure the historical context that produced and was in turn produced by Abu Said.

The PCP was born in 1922 out of a split within the Zionist Workers Party. Following the split it affiliated to the Third International. A significant layer of this early revolutionary leadership was deported to Russia in the late 1920s and 1930s by the British Mandate authorities who then governed the area. With the degeneration of the Third International, they all fell victims to Stalin's purges. A new generation of working class leaders, more firmly in tune with Stalinism, then picked up the reins of the PCP. A similar process unfolded in other parts of the Arab world.

Abu Said was the sort of exception that did more than just prove the rule. For in him was concentrated not only the voice of political opposition to the equivocations of the PCP between Zionism and Arab nationalism, but also the living spirit of what once was a revolutionary International. In the 1940s he was removed from any leadership position within the PCP. His evolution toward Trotskyism and the Fourth International, in which he remained until his death, followed closely after this.

In 1963, Said joined the Israeli Socialist Organization (Matzpen), which had been founded in 1962 by a small nucleus of Jewish revolutionaries expelled from the PCP. Largely as a result of Said's influence, Matzpen completely rejected Zionism and came to the fundamental recognition that objectively the principal political division in Israeli society revolved around acceptance or rejection of Zionism. Furthermore, Said brought into Matzpen the conception of a single Arab nation which had been artificially fragmented by imperialism following the first world war in opposition to the then prevailing Stalinist conception of different Arab nations in Iraq, Syria, Egypt, etc. In so doing, Said drew a direct link with the PCP's revolutionary past, for it was only in 1927 that the degenerating Comintern reversed its stand on the question of the objective unity of the Arab world, despite the opposition of the early revolutionary leadership of the PCP.

Both of these facets of the ISO program were integrated into the perspective of a socialist revolution throughout the Middle East as the only historical solution to the problems of that region, including the national question. On these foundations, an authentically Jewish-Arab organization emerged in Israel that was qualitatively different from the old PCP in that it firmly rejected — while never equating — both Jewish and Arab forms of nationalism. These were tremendous steps forward far surpassing in their importance the limited number of cadres who constituted the ISO.

However, the radicalization that swept the Arab world following the 1967 defeat in the Six Day War, and the radicalization that occurred throughout Europe following the May 1968 uprising, combined to exert their objective pressures on the situation in Israel. A program for the Middle East revolution isolated from a total world perspective was no longer tenable. In 1971 the ISO split into two main groupings, and Abu Said, in accordance with the logic of his whole life's work, joined the ranks of the ISO(Marxist), Israeli section of the Fourth International.

In England, comrade Said was probably best known for an article jointly written with Moshe Machover entitled "Arab Revolution and the National Problems in the Arab East," which appeared in the Summer 1973 issue of International (Vol. 2, No. 2).

We draw attention to this article because it summarizes another of comrade Said's central theoretical contributions to the development of a program for the Arab revolution. Said was literally the first Arab ever to realize that it was in the objective interests of the struggle against Zionism and for a socialist Arab East to recognize programmatically the right of the Israeli nation to self-determination, within the framework of a socialist Middle East. Although much subsequent debate has raged over this question both inside and outside the International, what counts above all is the fact that comrade Said creatively applied the Marxist method to the concrete aspects of the national question in the Middle East. This has resulted in an enrichment of the theoretical heritage of Marxism on the national question.

To appreciate the significance of our loss in the death of Abu Said, it is not necessary to agree or disagree with this or that point. It is enough to realize that Abu Said, like a stubborn, tenacious, and immovable rock, never moved from the side of the working class. It is to this quality in the man that we pay our deepest and humblest respect.

(The preceding article is reprinted from the January 9, 1975, Red Weekly, paper of the International Marxist Group, British section of the Fourth International.)

← The Profits of Famine · Vietnam: Imperialist Positions Disintegrate →

Something wrong on this page?