Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The Jewish Question

· International Marxist Review Vol. 3, No. 2 (No. 7), Autumn 1988 · pp 137-138 · 367 words

This text was corrected by hand against the scan: read from the scan on 21 October 2026 (pp. 137-138); a review of Jacob Taut, Judenfrage und Zionismus, and Nathan Weinstock, Le pain de misère, split from the reviews section on 4 November 2026. Signed (EM): Ernest Mandel, who signs the first review of the same section in full

Middle East

Judenfrage und Zionismus. Jacob Taut (ISP Verlag, Frankfurt; 1986). Le pain de misère: histoire du mouvement ouvrier juif en Europe. Nathan Weinstock (La Découverte, Paris; 1986)

This work continues the Marxist analysis of the Jewish question from the point at which the now classic work of our comrade Abraham Leon (The Materialist Interpretation of the Jewish Question) stopped, that is the outbreak of the Second World War and the foundation of the state of Israel. Taut is a citizen of this state but, as a coherent internationalist, he rejects this foundation as contrary to the interests of the toiling masses both Jewish (in Palestine and the diaspora) and Arab.

This position, which is that of our current since 1948, has been confirmed. The state of Israel represents a tragic historical dead end for those who escaped the Holocaust and for those born there. Without a freely accepted common life with the Arab masess, there is no future for the Jewish workers of Israel. And this common life could only be won by taking on the defence of the Arab masses of Palestine, who are today oppressed, deprived of national rights, economically super-exploited. This is shown convincingly by Jacob Taut, without falling into the excess of denying the national reality of the Jewish population in Israel and its rights to autonomy and self-administration. Here as well the discussion continues on the precise relationship with the rights and desires of the Palestinians. But most of Jacob Taut's formulations are acceptable for any internationalist Marxist.

While Taut's book takes Abraham Leon's analysis forward into the future, Weinstock delves into the past. He sketches an impressive fresco of the rise of the Jewish workers' movement, which played a role in creating the workers' movement in Russia and Poland (Lenin learnt more from the Jewish Bund than any other workers' grouping).

Its contribution to the creation of the European workers' movement (particularly in Germany) is not forgotten. After this rise was a slow decline which finished in the tragedy of the Holocaust with the physical destruction of 90% of the Jewish proletariat of Europe by the Nazis. This is a classic work which will be point of reference for future historians.

(EM)

← The Car Revolution · Origins of Oppression →

Something wrong on this page?