Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

Pakistan's Future

· International Marxist Review Vol. 3, No. 2 (No. 7), Autumn 1988 · p 138 · 189 words

This text was corrected by hand against the scan: read from the scan on 21 October 2026 (p. 138); a review of Tariq Ali, Can Pakistan Survive?, split from the reviews section on 4 November 2026. Signed (EM): Ernest Mandel, who signs the first review of the same section in full

South and Southeast Asia

Can Pakistan survive? Tariq Ali (Penguin, London; 1983)

Of the half-dozen books that Tariq Ali has produced in the last few years, this is by far the most important. It is a durable contribution to understanding the destiny of the Indian sub-continent, a real enriching of Marxism applied to a key country of the 'third world'.

This is also the work of a real revolutionary of remarkable political courage. Tariq's central thesis is not only the intransigent defence of the strategy of the permanent revolution (and not in the sectarian caricature propagated by some) but also, above all, that the creation of Pakistan in 1947 was a mistake from the point of view of the toiling masses, that the partition of India imposed by British imperialism with the help of the Muslim League started a process of Balkanisation which continues. This statement from a Pakistani revolutionary does not make him very popular among the Pakistani petty-bourgeoisie, without mentioning the ruling class. It is easier to defend this thesis in India. But it had already been intuitively felt by the Indian Trotskyists in 1948. History has proved them right.

(EM)

← Origins of Oppression · A Marxist Renaissance: Review of The New York Intellectuals by Alan Wald →

Something wrong on this page?