Fourth International Publications

The International’s English-language periodicals: World Outlook, Inprecor and their companions, 1958–1994

The Need for a Revolutionary International

· International Marxist Review Vol. 1, No. 1 (No. 1), Spring 1982 · pp 27-52 · 13,743 words

Fourth International France Britain and Ireland Soviet Union

The need for a revolutionary International The need for a

revolutionary International Ernest Mandel and John Ross The internationalisation of the productive forces Since its inception capitalism has been oriented towards the world market. International trade in specialised goods, exports of commodities manufactured in the capitalist countries which first became industrialised, imports of commodities from 'underdeveloped' countries, conquest of markets in these countries, accompanied every step forward of the capitalist mode of production. By its very nature as a development of the productive forces capitalism was and is a world system. Any superior mode of production, replacing capitalism will necessarily be even more international in its character than the imperialist system. All concepts of 'socialism in one country' are not merely from a political but even from a directly economic point of view both reactionary and utopian.

The worldwide expansion of capitalism however took on an uneven and combined nature. Modern industrial mass production from the developed capitalist countries destroyed precapitalist production (domestic industry, village industry, initial forms of manufacturing) in those countries under their domination without, leading to a massive growth of modern industry in the dominated countries themselves.

Consequently the world economy becomes more and more a unit structured in favour of the imperialist centres. Over-specialised in the output and export of raw materials, and with even manufacturing structured by the export market, the dominated economies are at the mercy of sudden ups and downs in raw material prices and fluctuations in the world market. Even those economies achieving some industrial development remain subjected to the situation in the imperialist centres, while the weakest neocolonial economies suffer blows which condemn masses of poor peasants and workers to move from misery to sheer starvation. Social inequalities mount with consequent political instabilities and crises.

In late capitalism (a sub-period of the imperialist epoch beginning with the end of World War II), the emergence of the multinational corporations shows even more clearly a new and even higher phase of the internationalisation of the productive forces: no longer does this internationalisation manifest itself only through world trade of commodities and world movement of capital. It manifests itself now in an increasingly internotional organisation of production itself.

----- photo credits and running heads -----

27

The multinational corporations organise an international division of labour inside their own companies, have spare parts manufactured in one continent and assembly lines set up in another, transfer from one country to another, if not one continent to another, the manufacturing of this or

There is no better proof of the fact that not only (capitalist) private property but also the nation state have been outgrown by the level of development attained by the productive forces. In many branches of industry there are today high levels of technology, even single machines, which can only be applied profitably if they cater for half a dozen or a dozen countries at

All the key economic problems which face humanity today — the problem of overcoming hunger and underdevelopment in the third world; the problem of assuring and maintaining full employment; the problem of subordinating the 'spontaneous' developments of science and technology to the needs of humankind - can only be solved on an international scale.

But there still exists a tremendous gap between this objective need and the average level of consciousness needed to achieve it. As always con-

The idea of unfettered 'national sovereignty' which is progressive as long as it is used against remnants of feudalism and against imperialism becomes reactionary when applied to the building of a united socialist world, a World Federation of Socialist Republics. This also explains why all the attempts by the bureaucracies of the deformed and degenerated workers' states to build 'socialism in one country' are not only reactionary but utopian as well. No rational planning of world resources in favour of rapidly overcoming underdevelopment, suppressing starvation and misery, eliminating inequalities between 'rich' and 'poor' nations, is possible, if its 'own' automobile industry, its 'own' electronics industry, regardless of costs, and regardless of the huge advantages of international division of labour. This will be even more the case with revolutions in advanced in-

For sure, the way in which the international division of labour has functioned under capitalism, the way in which the priviliged bureaucracy which usurped power in the USSR has applied the same idea, i.e. upon the basis of inequality, has tremendously increased suspicions and prejudices towards international solidarity among many people (in Eastern Europe as well as in Asia and elsewhere). But this is no reason for revolutionary Marxists to close their eyes to the obvious: world socialism is only possible on a higher level of international organisation and planning of economic and

This is only possible if many restrictions of 'national sovereignty' are freely accepted by the mass of workers, who will be masters of their fate under world socialism, on the basis of strict equality between nations. Such a free acceptance is impossible without a high level of internationalist

By its very nature, i.e. its ties to private property, competition, exploita-

28 that type of product.

the same time.

sciousness lags behind objective reality.

each country wants to 'go it alone' dustrialised countries.

4 political life.

education and organisation.

2. The class struggle is international

International Marxist Review

, building each its 'own' steel industry,

tion and inequality, the capitalist class and its hangers-on (those parts of the petty bourgeoisie which share its ideology) are organically unable to implement any world solution of humanity's problems. The tremendous gaps between the objective internationalisation of productive forces on the one hand, and the survival of the bourgeois nation state on the other, are being papered over by all kids of international institutions and international mechanisms. But when one looks closer at the way these institutions operate and these mechanisms function, one will always discover that it is in favour of certain groups of capitalists (generally the strongest ones) and at the expense of others, as well as in favour of capital as a whole and at the expense of the exploited, and the oppressed the world over.

Capitalism cannot grow without at the same time developing the growth of wage labour. Capital accumulation has as its source surplus-value which only living wage labour can produce. Therefore, from its inception, a continuous class struggle between capital and labour accompanies the develop-

This class struggle however does not rise continuously and does not become conscious all the time. It experiences ups and downs in its sharpest forms (large-scale mass strikes, large-scale political prerevolutionary situations, revolutionary struggles for power). But even when it subsides temporarily it is pursued daily, at factory level, by the capitalist class. Every new machine introduced in a factory, every attempt to 'rationalise' organisation of production, is an attempt to extort more surplus value from labour by capital. Every firing of a worker is an attempt capitalist class, this daily class struggle by their class enemy, by massive, instead of individual or piecemeal reactions. These massive reactions go from mass strikes to the highest forms of proletarian class struggle: the struggle to overthrow the capitalists' state power and property, the struggle to

The higher the level of internationalisation of capital and of the productive forces, the more the class struggle itself becomes international. To take merely the most elementary development, already in the second half of the

19th century, employers tried to break strikes by either transferring orders for production to foreign countries or by 'importing' foreign labour. Nationalist reactions by the strikers, trying to present the 'foreigners' as their enemies, played into the hands of the employers and quickly showed themselves to be inefficient, even for winning strikes. On a long-term basis, they could only help the employers, the capitalist class, in trying to permanently divide the working class, in trying to introduce into the working class itself the kind of competition and strife between different nationalities, which is normal for capital but against the interests of labour.

Experience quickly taught the workers that their best response against these manoeuvers of the capitalists was to extend strike and trade union organisation on an international level. That was one of the main reasons why Marx and Engels succeeded in organising the First International Work-

Contrary to the capitalist class, the working class has no ties with competition linked to private property. Its' basic interests, tied even to the very

The need for a revolutionary International ment of capitalism.

to weaken the working class.

Periodically the workers achieve a victorious revolution.

ing Men's Association, as early as 1864.

answer these continuous attacks

29 mass actions, by the

30 International Marxist Revieu way in which it works inside the factory and in which it has to defend itself against its class enemies, are tied to cooperation and solidarity. And the way in which capital increasingly operates on an international scale, the way in which capital increasingly internationalises the class struggle, forces the working class to answer by extending cooperation and solidarity on an international scale, lest it is beaten in advance in an uneven game with cards heavily stacked against it.

It is true that proletarian consciousness has again and again lagged behind the objective needs of the proletarian class struggle. Again and again the bourgeoisie, and the labour bureaucracies that serve it, have succeeded in using nationalism, chauvinism, and racism to divide the workers, pitting them against each other instead of uniting them against their common class enemy. But each time this happened, each time the working class failed to understand its internationalist tasks, experience showed that only the capitalists gained from it and the workers were heavy losers.

Thus at the beginning of World War 1 the majority of the European workers initially bowed before the tremendous pressure of bourgeois and chauvinist propaganda transferred into their ranks by those leaders of their mass parties and unions who had capitulated before the imperialist bourgeoisie. This meant the collapse of the Second International. These workers in 1914 accepted going into the war as a war of 'national defence' while in reality it was a war of imperialist robbery. But they rapidly payed a heavy price. Millions of workers were killed, by their own class brothers of other countries. Tens of millions saw their standards of living decline rapidly, as a result of the acceptance of class collaboration with the employers, and the imposition of no strike pledges, made for the sake of 'national unity'. It became possible for the internationalists, a minority in the beginning of the war, to convince growing sectors of the working class that internationalism was neither a utopian pipedream nor an abstract 'ideal' which only a small vanguard could practice, but a reality which corresponded to the immediate common material interest of the workers of all countries.

In the same way, at the beginning of reactionary counter-revolutionary wars of colonial reconquest, like the one conducted by French imperialism against the Algerian revolution starting in November 1954, the mass of the workers were influenced by chauvinistic and racialist prejudices, especially as these were not counteracted vigorously from the start by the leaderships of the mass organisations of the working class. They remained aloof from their evident duty of solidarity with the freedom fight of those oppressed by their own exploiters. Again, they payed a heavy price for this: thousands of deaths and, in the case of France, a growing threat against their own elementary democratic freedoms, leading to the downfall of the Fourth Republic and the establishment of a Bonapartist strong state under General de Gaulle in 1958. That experience helped the small internationalist minorities in convincing sectors of the working class that it had to fight against that dirty war, that it had to oppose the 'war effort' by all means necessary.

The need to take up the class struggle at the international level was made clear by more recent struggles also. Today when multinational corporations organise production on a worldwide basis and when politics is

above all world politics, the attempt to solve even economic defensive issues of the working class on a strictly national basis becomes progressively more difficult. For example, while a deep structural crisis swept over all of Western Europe's steel industry in the last three years, leading to the sacking of more than 100,000 steel workers in twelve countries, the West

German steel workers were left alone in their first exemplary strike for the

35 hours week, which, if conquered internationally, would have saved all these jobs. Likewise, the striking power of the British steel workers in spite of their determination, was eroded because no serious attempts at international solidarity were organised. No boycotting of the transport of steel from European mills by European lorries and railways, through European ports, was seriously established. Even a limited number of determined unionists, coordinating their actions in all European countries, could have achieved partial suceess there, and could have exercised such growing pressure upon their union structures that in the end, international solidari-

These examples show how the international reality of the class struggle imposes itself on objective social processes. It therefore shows the duties and possibilities for the working class and revolutionaries. The objective need of proletarian internationalism is very simple. The class struggle is one in which every defeat for one side is a victory for the other. This is true not

The bourgeoisie fully understands this. Its leading circles have an exrevolutionary organisations (NATO, EEC, 'defence' agreements, ASEAN etc) and operations (Vietnam, the coup in Bolivia, the intervention in the scope. No matter what particular disagreements exist between them they fully cooperate in the most decisive counter-revolutionary operations.

The proletariat in contrast is drastically hampered by its Stalinst,

Eurocommunist and Social Democratic misleaders, and suffers greatly each time it fails to rise to its international duties. The failure of the Second International leadership to fight imperialism resulted in the catastrophic

The failure of the workers movement in Britain to meet the needs of solidarity with Ireland has directly created not only the division of that country but an ultra-reactionary enclave inside the British state. The failure of the leaderships of the workers movement in the imperialist countries to solidarise with the struggles against the Stalinist bureaucracy in

Eastern Europe leaves open the door for ultra-rightist currents in their own countries to assume the cloak of 'defenders of democracy'

Similarly, every time it has exercised international solidarity, even if initially from confused or unclear motives, the workers movement has gain-

Thus it was the growing refusal of Portuguese workers and youth to fight in the colonial wars in Africa, the penetration of this mood into the army, which lead to the crisis and overthrow of the hated fascist dictatorship

Another powerful example, particularly as it started from small beginnings in the world's most powerful imperialism, was the case of the anti-

The need for a revolutionary International ty would have prevailed.

only nationally but also internationally.

tremely developed

Persian Gulf, Salvador) are slaughter of the First World War.

ed.

of Salazar/Caetano in Portugal itself in 1974.

international consciousness.

31

Their counternot only national but fully international in

Vietnam war movement. The beginning of the all-out American military offensive in Vietnam in the mid 1960s was not at once met with mass active opposition in the United States. But the continuing toll of the war in human lives, its consequences for the American economy, the utterly naked face of imperialist aggression it revealed to young people, led to mounting op-

Internationalists, who at the beginning had been a small minority and only able to lead small protests, by the end of the war were capable of leading actions of hundreds of thousands and found themselves swimming with the tide of popular feeling. The outcome of this struggle, spurred on by the unbelievable heroism in struggle of the Vietnamese people imposed the heaviest defeat on the American ruling class it had suffered in its entire

Internationalism is thus no special 'gadget', 'exotic concern', or 'utopia' of the revolutionary Marxists. It directly affects the relation of forces, and therefore the possibilities of working class victories, in every country.

The need for an international organisation of the working class vanguard is not only rooted in the economic realities of our contemporary world. It is likewise rooted in the realities of the daily class struggle:

'Proletarian emancipation can only be an international deed' (Engels to

At least since the 20th century (and partially in the 19th century), the growth of the inner contradictions of capitalism leads to periodic violent explosions. The imperialist epoch becomes the epoch of wars, revolutions and counter-revolutions. And like wars, revolutions and counterrevolutions take on more and more the form of international revolutions

In fact, not a single important revolution has occurred in the twentieth century without both being pushed forward by international developments and without spreading to other countries. The Russian revolution quickly spread to Finland, Poland, Germany, Austria, Hungary and partially Italy.

In 1936 the Spanish revolution started to spread towards France. The

Chinese revolution of 1946-49 spread to Korea, Indochina, Indonesia,

Malaya. The Indochinese revolution spread to Algeria. The Algerian revolution spread to Angola, Mozambique and Guinea-Bissau, from where it spread to Portugal. The Cuban revolution spread throughout Latin

America. Before our very eyes the Nicaraguan revolution is spreading to El

Likewise, as we have already seen, counter-revolution organises on an international scale. It is not content with financing and arming the ruling class of each country threatened by revolution in order to stay in power, or, after its overthrow, to recapture power. It organises economic and financial blackmail and commerical blockades against each and every revolution. It organises international groups of mercenaries in order to destabilise and help overthrow any revolutionary regime. When all that is not enough - and the relationship of forces inside the imperialist countries allows it — it organises open military intervention on the side of counter-revolution in the civil war (as it did in Finland 1918, Russia 1918-1920, Poland 1920. Spain

32 position to the war.

history.

Lafargue 27 June 1893).

and international counter-revolutions.

Salvador and other Central American countries.

International Marxist Review

3. The political basis of proletarian internationalism

1936, China 1946-49), or even takes over wholesale military intervention against the revolution itself, as it did in China in the thirties, in Korea

1950-53, in Indochina (first by French, then by American imperialism) for

The internationalisation of revolutions and counter-revolutions, constitutes the political basis for the need of a revolutionary International.

The success of a national revolution does not merely depend on national elements. A revolutionary leadership must therefore take into account not merely the national but also the international situation.

In our epoch, the tasks of an International cannot be reduced simply to opposition to strike breaking by the organisation of international solidarity.

Its tasks are of an increasingly wide scope politically. It must ensure that the international working class and oppressed people rising to conquer national and social liberation do not have to face worldwide imperialist alliances and violence in a completely dispersed manner - in which case their victory becomes more difficult, the price for victory much higher, and

'The crisis of humanity is the crisis of proletarian leadership'.The leadership which is needed is the one which will help the masses overcome this gap between their consciousness and objective reality. A leadership which will face up to its internationalist tasks, which will re-educate the workers movement in internationalism. The only internationalism which is finally decisive is the one which can be verified in practice and this finally is only possible through the building of a real International which functions

4. The historical struggle for a revolutionary International

It is precisely in response to these objective needs of the class struggle to bring its 'organisational' conclusions into line with its political analysis, that the entire political history of the workers movement is in fact bound up with the struggle to create a real revolutionary International. The idea that national revolutionary parties will suffice, or that first strong national revolutionary organisations have to be built before one can start building an international revolutionary organisation is utterly wrong.

It does not answer the question of how one can guarantee a minimum of programmatic and organisational coherence between national organisations built separately from each other. It does not answer the question of how internationalist education is possible without the practical day-to-day experience ot common international activity. It especially does not answer thequestion of how an adequate analysis of an extremely complex international situation and its evolution can guide a revolutionary party's activity, without the test of common practice in most parts of the world, mediated through organisations and militants who are members of the same world party. It fails to understand that grasping the greatest possible international experience through international organisation, formal organisation of an International, intervention and organisation on an international scale, do not cut across or contradict but on the contrary aids the creation of strong national leaderships and strong national parties. This is confirmed by the whole history of the international revolutionary movement and flows from its very nature. In a certain sense the very first 'International' defeat may result.

as such.

IMR Spring 82 - C

The need for a revolutionary International

33 thirty years, in Algeria 1954-1962 etc.

34 International Marxist Review in the history of Marxism were Marx and Engels themselves - people who never once in their whole lives established first a national organisation but always built simultaneously, whether with mass or tiny forces, an international simultaneously with national parties (Communist League, projected International with the Chartist leader Ernest Jones, First International, Second International). It is a truism, but one whose significance must be fully grasped, that Marxism was not a national product but an international one right from its origins — in that famous phrase 'the product of German philosophy, French politics, and British political economy'. Marx and Engels formed themselves and their ideas right from the beginning on the widest international field - the arena to which they were forced to look for answers by the very needs of the revolutionary struggle in Germany.

Did this 'obsession' with international developments, the refusal to establish simply national organisations but always to build international ones, lead to Marx or Engels being 'out of touch' with 'national realities and peculiarities' as is sometimes claimed? Quite the contrary. Precisely because they were such complete internationalists in their practice and ideas and they could see most clearly the universal decisive elements of the historical process, Marx and Engels had by far the best understanding of anyone in their own country, Germany, of the revolutionary process of 1848. No matter what particular errors occurred they had the best grasp of tactics, understanding of the concrete situation, and intervention. Their international basis led them to the most correct national line while the more parochial forces fell into error after error.

Similarly, did Marx and Engels reveal an 'incapacity of party building' or 'incapacity to understand specific national features' in their later activity? Not in the slightest. It was they who understood best how to build the First International and its sections, to grasp the significance and line of advance for the Paris Commune, and the features of the struggle in Germany. In his agitation for the creation of a mass workers party with no programmatic preconditions, (a 'Labour Party') in Britain, Engels was twenty years ahead in his understanding of the line of development of that and other workers movements, compared to those fixated in the so called 'national realities'

This is a general rule of the development of the international revolutionary movement - one reflecting the basic objective character of the economy, politics and the class struggle. Those currents most correct and revolutionary on the national field are those which not only have advanced revolutionary experience in their own countries but which are most inter nationally formed. We can illustrate this with the most elementary facts of the history of the workers movement.

The most revolutionary, and also most internationalist, wing of the German SPD was that led by Liebknecht and politically by Rosa Luxemburg. Yet Luxemburg herself was one of those who was totally integrated into international experiences and viewpoints. Born in a divided Poland she had the opportunity to be a militant in three parties simultaneously - the Polish, the Russian, and the German.

She simultaneously worked to construct a Polish organisation, lead a wing in the German party, and personally participated in the Russian Revolution of 1905 and the internal struggles of the Russian Party, in addi-

tion to work in the Second International. It was this international current which was the most realistic and revolutionary in Germany compared to all

What was Luxemburg's own conclusion on all this? That she had been excessively internationalist? On the contrary that the whole workers movement had not been internationally organised enough. As she wrote following the catastrophe of August 1914 and the collapse of the Second International: 'The centre of gravity of the organisation of the proletariat as a class is the International'. She did not in any way confine this to an 'exchange of ideas' but understood it as real international organisation

A second great example was that of the Bolsheviks themselves. The tremendous necessity for revolutionary ideas and solutions created by the pressure of the class struggle in Russia from the late nineteenth century onwards, coupled with the forced exile in the rest of the world of literally tens of thousands of political oppositionists in Russia, gave to the Russian party an intelligence network and an international experience totally unmatched by any other party in the world. As Lenin put it the Russian party was the and developments. This was not just an abstract but a real material question. Russian politics was completely determined by world politics. Both the 1905 and 1917 revolutions were precipitated by war. The Russian revolutionaries, due to their exile, had enormous international contacts with members in virtually every country. The translation of revolutionary literature of every variety into Russian was superior to that of almost any other country. The Bolsheviks, demonstrably the party most capable of grasping the 'national peculiarities of Russia', were the most international

But the Bolsheviks, as with Luxemburg, did not draw the conclusion from their experience that they had been 'too international'. This conclusion was not the one drawn by the revolutionaries but by the reformists of the Social Democracy who after the qualitative turning point of 1914 never again created an organisation with even the minimum international cohesion and commitment of the Second International. The Bolsheviks on the contrary drew the balance sheet that they had been insufficiently international - in particular by not formalising international organisation. This error, which was undoubtedly one of the reasons why Lenin failed to grasp the reality of the SPD's bureaucratisation early enough, was what they went out of their way to correct after the tremendous shock and lesson of

From the very beginning of the war, concretised in their goals in Zimmerwald, Kienthal, and the creation of the Communist International the

Bolsheviks set out to create a new international revolutionary organisation. The Russian revolution gave them the opportunity to create a revolutionary International on a truly mass scale. But they had already decided to

When Trotsky after 1933 oriented himself not to building simply one, or several, national parties but instead right from the beginning built an International, he was not retreating into romanticism, 'ignoring national realities' etc. He was following in the footsteps already carved out and followed by Marx, Engels, Luxemburg, Lenin and the other leaders of the

The need for a revolutionary International the preachers of 'national peculiarities' best acquainted with the 'last word' in international revolutionary ideas party in the whole Second International.

1914.

create such an international organisation before 1917.

35

represented, drew the conclusion of the need for international organisation - to orientate themselves to construct simultaneously an International and national parties. This itself reflected the conclusions forced on them by the objective reality of the international revolutionary process itself. Any revolutionary today who does not build a revolutionary International simultaneously with national parties bases her/himself not on the most advanced conclusions and practice of the international revolutionary movement and its leaders but instead on the false 'logic' of the reformists

Finally the necessity and correctness of this task of fighting to build a revolutionary International is shown even when success is not total. The

First International spread Marxism and initial working class organisation to almost every advanced capitalist country. The Second International created the mass ôrganisation of workers parties for the first time in a whole series of the most important countries of the world

Equally clear, despite its final degeneration, is the case of the Communist International. This, and the process that created it, achieved not only programmatic but great material gains for the world revolution and the

When Soviet Russia was forced to conclude peace under disastrous conditions with German and Austro-Hungarian imperialism at Brest-Litovsk, sacrificing large tracts of territory in order to maintain the workers state during a necessary breathing spell, the Bolsheviks simultaneously did everything in their power to assist by agitation, propaganda,and financial support, the German revolutionists. As a result of the tremendous echo which their (especially Trotsky's) revolutionary agitation had among German and Austrian workers and soldiers, as a result of the organisational help they provided to revolutionaries (and also, as a result of revolutionary education and organisation of Austrian and Hungarian prisoners of war in revolutionary Russia), the German, Austrian and Hungarian revolution were decisively speeded up, and actually broke out in the beginning of

November 1918, hardly six months after the conclusion of the Brest-

When in 1920 British imperialism prepared to intervene militarily in the war between Poland and Russia, thereby threatening to topple the Soviet regime which was exhausted after many years of war and civil war, the appeals of the Communist International to the British labour movement to actively oppose these war preparations were crowned by great success. An action committee uniting the Labour Party and the TUC called for a nationwide unlimited general strike in case of military intervention by Britain, issued a call for the setting up of local action committees to prepare that general strike - a call answered in more than 400 towns throughout the country. As a result of this internationalist stand British imperialism drew back from direct intervention in the Russian-Polish war. A war between

Britain and Soviet Russia was avoided, and Soviet Russia was saved, as a result of coordinated action by the European working class.

The Chinese revolution entered a new stage in the early twenties, through massive confrontations between Chinese intellectuals, students,

36 revolutionary movement.

and the centrists.

working class.

Litovsk treaty.

All these great revolutionary leaders,

International Marxist Review and the vanguard they

workers and parts of the Chinese bourgeoisie on the one hand, and imperialism on the other hand. Soviet Russia sent massive military help to

China and helped organise anti-imperialist resistance and struggle on a broad scale. It is true that as a result of wrong policies of tail-ending the bourgeois Kuomintang, that help led in the first stage to a bloody defeat of the Chinese working class in April 1927 and assisted Chiang Kai-chek in establishing his reactionary dictatorship which he maintained for two decades. But one cannot deny that Soviet assistance in the twenties prevented in a decisive way China from becoming a direct colony of imperialism, and through giving a powerful impulse to the creation of the

Chinese Communist Party and its transformation into a mass party, it indirectly contributed to the victory of the third Chinese revolution in 1949, i.e. to the final overthrow of capitalism in China, whatever were the counter-revolutionary policies towards China later practiced by the Soviet

From an economic, social and political point of view revolutionaries are faced with an increasingly international reality. The tasks flowing from the objective needs of the class struggle tend to be more and more on an inter-

It is key for the workers movement today to reconquer its origins - the traditions of internationalism which were at the root of the very first revolutionary workers organisation, that of Marx, Engels, and the Communist International in its revolutionary period. The task that they set out to achieve: to coordinate, on a world scale, the struggle of the working class for the overthrow of capitalism, to coordinate on a world scale the effort to paralyse international counter-revolution is a burning necessity of the class struggle. Failing to take up these internationalist tasks, as history has already shown, will lead the labour movement to enormous setbacks,

But particularly on this field, the consciousness of the masses lags far behind the objective reality. They have been miseducated for years by their reformist leaderships who, instead of raising their consciousness towards internationalism, taught them to defend their 'own' country and therefore their 'own' capitalists against all workers and oppressed of the rest of the

With the degeneration of the Communist International into a simple tool of the Soviet bureaucracy's foreign policy, the absence of a guiding and coordinating force of international revolutionary struggles made itself cruelly felt - especially because these struggles didn't subside. Instead of helping to support the Spanish revolution, the Stalinised Comintern strangled it, thereby making Hitler's conquest of Europe (and his aggression against the Soviet Union from an extremely favourable starting basis)

Instead of helping to support the revolutionary upsurges of the Greek,

Italian and French workers in 1944-48, Stalin delivered them to Western imperialism (only in Yugoslavia was a similar attempt thwarted by the

Yugoslav communists themselves). Instead of organising from the start international support for the Indochinese revolution, Stalin, Krushchev and bureaucracy.

losses, and bloody defeats.

world.

5. The need for a new leadership much easier.

37

The need for a revolutionary International national level and require international coordination.

38 International Marxist Review Brezhnev only gave it piecemeal support, preventing its collapse in face of imperialist aggression but postponing for decades a victory which could have been achieved much earlier. The economic consequences of three decades of aggression and war go a long way to explain the ensuing tragedies.

The need for a new revolutionary International made itself therefore felt from the moment that the end of the Comintern as a tool for world revolution became confirmed through decisive international events, i.e. from Hilters conquest of power in 1933. That is the political basis for the fight for the Fourth International ever since. a) Permanent revolution vs 'socialism in one country'

The failure of the Russian revolution to spread victoriously to key industrialised countries in the 1917-1923 period left it isolated in a relatively backward country. Thereby, a process of growing bureaucratisation of the Soviet state, and of the Communist Party itself set in, which led to the decline of the Communist International, and then to its destruction as a tool of world revolution. This process, whose political and ideological expression is Stalinism, reflects the fact that a new privileged layer, the Soviet bureaucracy - which however is not a new ruling class - has taken away the exercise of political power from the Soviet working class. It concentrates the control over the social surplus product in its own hands, thereby monopolises political power in all spheres of society, and uses this power to defend its own material privileges, which are considerable compared to the average standard of life of the Russian worker and peasant.

The first key revision of Marxism which expressed this usurpation of power by the Soviet bureaucracy from the working class, was the elabortion of the theory according to which a fully developed socialist society could be built in Russia, in isolation from the rest of the world, i.e. the so-called theory of 'socialism in one country'. This theory expressed the basic conservatism of the Soviet bureaucracy, its turning away from world revolution towards maintenance of the international 'status quo', i.e. peaceful coexistence with imperialism, or the division of the world into spheres of influence between the Soviet bureaucracy and international capitalism.

While revolutionary Marxists never called upon the Soviet Union, its workers government, to artificially 'provoke' revolutions elsewhere to 'further' them through military adventures abroad, or to 'sit and wait' before developing the Soviet economy and society towards socialism till international revolution would finally triumph, they fully understood that the fate of the Soviet Union (including the evolution and variants of its inner structure) remained intimately and finally tied to the outcome of class struggles on a world scale. In the same way as the international working class has the duty to defend the Soviet Union against attempts of imperialism to restore capitalism there, the Soviet Union had the duty to help and further world revolution in all those cases where revolutionary mass struggles and deep revolutionary crises in one or several countries clearly testified to the objective possibilities of achieving new revolutionary victories. This mutual duty corresponds to a mutual common interest.

Each defeat of world revolution objectively weakens the Soviet Union

by strengthening world imperialism. Likewise, the restoration of capitalism in the Soviet Union (and other workers states) would tremendously strenghten world imperialism and thereby objectively weaken world revolution, the world proletariat and all anti-imperialist forces throughout

The break with that classical doctrine of proletarian internationalism as outlined by the Communist International in its first years of existence, i.e.

since the emergence of the first workers state, was a break with the interests of world revolution and therefore of the world proletariat. It did tremendous harm to the world proletariat, causing avoidable, unnecessary defeats for a whole series of revolutions, thereby simultaneously imposing avoidable, unnecessary sacrifices upon the Soviet workers for the defence of their state. Its gravest consequences revealed themselves much later, although Trotsky and the Soviet Left Opposition had foreseen them from

The theory of 'socialism in one country' implies the subordination of the interests of the workers of the world to the alleged interest of a 'socialist fortress' (in reality: the interests of the Soviet bureaucracy, quite distinct from those of the Soviet proletariat and the Soviet state as such). But such subordination implies in turn what Trotsky called a 'messianic function' for a specific country or at least the working class movement (the communist movement) and the proletariat of that country. Such messianic 'nationalcommunism' is however by no law of history tied to one country (the Soviet

Union) and one country only. On the contrary, once the theory of 'socialism in one country' is fully assimilated by all leaders and cadres of Communist

Parties under Stalinism, it can be reproduced at will in any country

Thus the Chinese CP, after the outbreak of the Sino-Soviet conflict, considered itself to have become 'the bastion of world revolution' instead of the Soviet Union, where capitalism had been allegedly restored. Thus, any forces throughout the world against the Soviet Union (with the Shah of

Iran, with the Pakistani military dictators, with US imperialism, with with the Chilean military butcher Pinochet, with Franz Josef

Strauss) is justified in the name of the 'defence of the socialist fortress' identified with the Chinese state. The final tragic outcome of the false doctrines of 'national communism' are open wars between 'socialist countries' for which only the governing privileged bureaucracies, and not socialism or communism or the working class in any way, are responsible.

b) The necessity of a democratic centralist International

The bitter fruits of 'national communism' are also increased nationalism suspicion among nations even after the overthrow of capitalism. They have also created for a whole period a distrust of any form of international organisation by important sectors of the workers' and revolutionary movement throughout the world. It saw the disastrous experience of Stalinism, in all its variants and ideological offshoots such as

Maoism, identify 'internationalism' with subordination of the interests of workers and revolutionaries of different countries to the manoeuvers of the bureaucratised state apparatus of a single country. In over -reacting against international Stalinist bureaucratic centralism (the Stalinist leader the world the start.

disgusting counter-revolutionary

Sadat, and national

The need for a revolutionary International where capitalism has been overthrown association with reactionary bourgeois

39

International Marxist Revieu of the French CP, Maurice Thorez, had actually coined the phrase, 'Proletarian internationalism today means solidarity with the Soviet Union in each and every situation'), many revolutionaries themselves ended up by throwing out the baby together with the dirty bath-water and rejected any form of international democratic centralism.

This, although historically comprehensible, was a tremendous step backward not only compared to objective needs of the class struggle but also compared to what revolutionary theory and practice had established even during the first decades of our century. Despite its superficial, and not infrequently demagogic, attractions it has to be rejected out of hand as any way forward. No more than revolutionaries can reject the dictatorship of the proletariat, or the very idea of class struggle, simply because they have been monstrously distorted and defiled by Stalinism neither can they reject proletarian internationalism or the need of building a revolutionary International, because of the use to which these terms have been put by sundry bureaucracies.

Confronted with increasingly internationalised forms of revolution and counter-revolution, with increasingly centralised imperialist counterrevolutionary strategy and actions, any seperation of the anti-imperialist and proletarian forces into purely 'national' or 'regional' sectors operating independently from each other, with no international organisation, can onLy greatly weaken the forces of revolution to the exclusive advantage of the class enemy. The centralisation of imperialism's counter-revolutionary role demands as an answer an international co-ordination of revolutionary activities, the absence of which greatly strengthens the enemy. The rejection of international organisation only makes sense from a theoretical and practical point of view if it is assumed that 'socialism in one country' is indeed possible — as is in fact the assumption not only of the Stalinists but of the Eurocommunists, the left reformists and various centrist formations. 6. The building of the Fourth International, the only existing world organisation of the working class which actually functions as such.

It is for these reasons that both the Communist International and Trotsky and his co-thinkers, from the first day they launched the idea that it was necessary to build a new Fourth International, staunchly stuck to the idea that the International had to function as a real organisation, based upon a freely accepted common discipline from its very inception, regardless of its relative weakness or strength.

We understand perfectly that the Fourth International is still very weak, although it is many times stronger than at the time it was founded in 1938 or on the first aftermath of World War II, at its second world congress of 1948. We are only the first nucleus of the future communist mass International which will be the final real general staff of the world revolution, actually coordinating all important revolutionary struggles throughout the world. Likewise, our national sections are not yet mass revolutionary parties actually leading day-to-day struggles of significant sectors of the masses of their respective countries.

These nuclei will have to go through many fusions with newly emerging revolutionary forces, many regroupments with oppositional tendencies

The need for a revolutionary International 41 breaking away from social-democratic mass parties and CPs in prerevolutionary and revolutionary periods, before they will attain the status of fully developed revolutionary mass parties capable of leading the proletariat and poor peasantry to victorious socialist revolutions.

But these nuclei bring to the building of the future revolutionary mass parties and the future revolutionary mass International a programme which summarises the lessons of 150 years of proletarian class struggles throughout the world - and also a crucial nucleus of cadres trained in that programme and experienced in its application to the most varied concrete tactical situations of the class struggle in all parts of the world. They bring to these mass parties and that mass International of tomorrow the invaluable training and capacity of education in embodied practical internationalism, applied on a daily basis.

Experience has shown again and again that it is absolutely impossible to attain even an elementary level of international co-ordination and action on a purely spontaneous basis. It would be total utopia to believe that the degree of internationalism in theory and practice needed by the present stage of the worldwide class struggle and revolutionary struggle can be in anyway attained, without the conscious and deliberate preparation of thousands and tens of thousands of cadres and militants in that orientation, years and years in advance.

That is why the fact that the Fourth International, weak as it still is, the only tendency of the international labour movement actually functioning as an international organisation in more than fifty countries throughout the world is not accidental at all. It is the product of the deliberate education and training in internationalism, as against the Stalinist 'nationalcommunism' concept, from the very inception of the Trotskyist movement, in the tradition of the Communist International and all the internationalists during World War I like Rosa Luxemburg and Karl Liebknecht.

The Fourth International is not a pure fetish or a simple signboard. It is a source of multiplication of strength in day-to-day action, and a constant pole of attraction for revolutionary forces throughout the world.

In tact, the presence of the Fourth International today in double the number of countries than it was present at the time of Trotsky's death or on the aftermath of World War II explains itself both by the fact that revolutionaries in more and more countries, through experience of their own revolutionary activities and struggles, reach programmatic conclusions identical to those of the F.I. and by the fact that they understand through that same experience the need of starting to build an international organisation, here and now. 7. The relation between the International and national sections

Here it is worth dispelling one more myth. This is that the existence of international organisation cuts across the development of correct tactics by national parties — a view propagated by centrists, Eurocommunists, and even Stalinists of the traditional type concerning the Communist International. It is simply false that the existence of the Communist International cut across the development of the correct tactics by national parties.

For example it was the experience of the Communist International which helped decisively to correct the disastrous ultra-left line of the early

German Communist Party as exemplified both by the Spartacists and the whole dynamic in the early United Communist Party of 1920-21 (March action of 1921). It was the Communist International which helped sort out the mess of opportunism, individualism, and rightism which the early French development', which helped develop the qualitatively superior tactics of the British CP compared to anything that had gone before in that country, on such questions as electoral policies, attitudes to the Labour Party and

Cannon in his First Ten Years of American Communism gives an excellent account of the innumerable ways in which the early Communist International helped to correct the tactics of the early American CP and allowed it to surmount problems in a way it could never have done by drawing on purely national political resources. The whole experience of such debates and decisions as the Third and Fourth Congresses of the Communist International on the United Front was a decisive aid to the national

As international organisation functioning in a democratic and not a bureaucratic way does not prevent the formulation of national tactics and the creation of national leaderships. The errors of the Third International made in the period of Zinoviev and Bukharin from its Fifth Congress onwards, and later its crimes committed in the period of Stalin, were not a result of international organisation but of the bureaucratisation of the

Soviet State, the Comintern, and the adoption of the organisational methods appropriate to this — overturning of national leaderships, preventing the holding of national congresses before congresses of the Comintern, imposition of national tactics by the International Centre, creation of a layer of servile functionaries by massive permanent international subsidies etc. The Fourth International has consciously integrated the lessons of

Each national revolutionary organisation has to learn through its own experience how to develop a cadre and leadership capable of encompassing, besides all the lessons of the international class struggle, the national specificities of its own country, of its working class, of its labour movement, and the working out of correct tactics there. The International as a whole, and other sections, can advise and urge but they have no right to decide anything on these fields. That is why the statutes of the Fourth International explicitly forbid international bodies to change national leader-

The Fourth International however also understands that the bourgeoisie refuses to confine its action to the national level and therefore the proletariat cannot do this either. It requires international struggle, internadiscipline. For example the precise way in which to carry out solidarity with the Nicaraguan and Salvadorian revolutions is a question of national tactics. But the need for an international solidarity campaign with the

Nicaraguan revolution is something which flows from international needs of the class struggle. On these key questions of international strategy and policy the International does, and must, have the right to take decisions and sections must accept that democratic discipline (i.e. after democratic

42

CP displayed. It the united front, policies in the trade unions etc.

parties in working out and determining their tactics.

these errors.

ships or to determine national tactics of sections.

tional organisation, and

International Marxist Review was the Communist International,

'British not therefore where appropriate international

The need for a revolutionary International 43 debate and majority vote). International decisions of this type are binding for all organisations which want genuinely to meet the needs of the class struggle and build a world party. The only alternative to that form of binding international organisation is precisely 'national-communism'. The final essence of this was clearly and tellingly summarised by Rosa Luxemburg after the collapse of the Second International at the outbreak of World War I in the bitter slogan 'Workers of all countries, unite in times of peace and kill each other in time of war'

In order to clarify the relationship between the International and national sections there is a second objection to be answered. Some people state that there exists no such thing as an 'international' revolution. Or else they use and distort the words of Lenin who said 'there is one, and only one, kind of real internationalism, and that is - working whole-heartedly for the development of the revolutionary struggle in one's own country, and supporting...this struggle, this, and only this, line in every country without exception'. Does that mean that Lenin championed national revolutions, as against world revolution because it is impossible to have a 'world' revolution? Not at all. Lenin had simply a very clear view of the relation between national revolutions and the world revolution, while expressing this view in a slightly paradoxical way.

If world revolution is understood as a simultaneous act in all countries, as a common overthrow at the same time of all the ruling classes, it is a mere utopia, and would only lead to passivity in the expectancy of the 'Great Day'. The Fourth International, which calls itself the world party socialist revolution, holds a completely opposite view of things. It sees the proletarian world revolution not as a simultaneous act but as a process of which the Russian revolution opened the first stage.

The relation between national revolution andinternational revolution is a dialectical one. It is a reflection of the contradiction between the national boundaries of the bourgeois state and the enormous development of the productive forces outside the national limits. This growth of the productive forces has made the class struggle international and for this reason there is not only an organic interdependency of all the 'national' economies but of all revolutionary class struggles as well. Imperialism is a chain. As all chains it breaks at its weakest link. It would be better if it broke at all its links at the same time, but that is from the domain of dreams and not from a reality which functions according to certain laws of development. But on the other hand there is no 'purely national' revolution. The revolution starts at the national level but it spreads and has immediate influence on the international level. That is what we mean by an international revolution: a permanent process of which the national link is not simply an aim in itself, not a final act, but the initial act.

Furthermore just as much as there is no strictly national revolution, no purely national economy, there is no bourgeoisie which confines its action to purely national terrain. We are living in the epoch of imperialism; the bourgeoisie organises itself internationally to try to defend its interests. In order to win a revolution at a national scale, we find that starting on a purely 'national' level is insufficient - in Vietnam it was not only the national ruling class which had to be overthrown, it was American imperialism, preceded by French imperialism and earlier Japanese im-

International Marxist Review perialism which had to be fought. This shows how utopian it would be to retreat into purely 'national' politics in order to start even the very first act of the revolution.

Therefore, it is necessary to avoid any mechanical interpretation of the relation between the national and international levels of revolution. Lenin argued against the 'empty assurances of devotion to internationalism', of so called 'internationalists' who utilise the same type of abstract internationalism in words of the Eurocommunists, Social Democrats, and Stalinists of our time. But to deduce from this type of quotation that all that matters is to prepare the first stage of the revolution i.e. to focus one's concerns solely on the national level, would be to totally misunderstand that the national specificity of each revolution is only relative and partial and not all absolute. As Rosa Luxemburg put it 'The class struggle against the ruling classes within the boundaries of the bourgeois states, and international solidarity of the workers of all countries, are the two rules of life, inherent in the working class in struggle and of world historic importance for its emancipation'

In fact, if we were to make an evaluation of the Fourth International today we would not say that it is too much occupied by international problems and experiences, or excessively centralised, but that insufficient common experiences still existed. The various national sections have not enough assimilated the experiences of other countries and the International as a whole. Precisely one of the most important tasks facing the International today and one that will aid national tactics, is to develop in the greatest possible way the common experience of the International. International discussion, international trips, the visits of comrades to different sections, a wider layer of cadres involved in international work and discussion, the strengthening of international journals, and above all, as discussed below, common international tasks directed at key revolutionary processes and issues are what is required both by the International and by its national parties. 8. International campaigns and actions

So far we dealt with the necessity of an International from the point of view of programmatic homogenity and the need of a rounded internationalist vision for national leaderships through the process of exchanging and drawing the lessons of international struggles - such need being rooted in the objective world character of the class struggle. The international centralisation of experiences helps reinforce the elaboration of the programme. But this programme is not an academic commentary on world reality, it is the basis for an attempt to change that reality. As such, it can only be tested in practice on a world scale. A caricature of internationalism would be to reduce it to an analysis of the world situation, leaving immediate practice solely to the national sections. There is indeed another aspect of this internationalism. This is the dialectic betueen the construction of the revolutionary International and the creation of national revolutionary parties themselves. Again it is not the case that building an International is counterposed to building national revolutionary parties, but on the contrary that it aids it. This is illustrated not only by theory but by concrete revolutionary experience.

For example, following the First World War it was inevitable there would be a tremendous ferment and creation of diverse revolutionary currents of different types. This occurred in every country. But what was not at all inevitable was that these would fuse and mature to create serious revolutionary parties. This did not and could not occur 'spontaneously'. It took the conscious drive to create a real revolutionary International. It was not 'German, French, British, American or Italian conditions' allowed the building of significantly larger and more advanced, and in key cases mass revolutionary communist parties in these countries. It took the conscious intervention, the 'voluntarism' if you like, of the Communist International to create them — although of course in reality it was not voluntarism but merely the subjective understanding of the needs of the objec-

This meant the International functioning not just as an ideological discussion and programmatic circle but as a real organisation. The International sent cadres, publications, advice, and money to these countries to create these parties. Furthermore, as we have seen, these methods, during the first four years of the Comintern did not cut across but aided the creation of national revolutionary parties. We repeat: it was not strong international organisation but Stalinist bureaucracy which destroyed both the

Communist International and national revolutionary parties.

Let us add that even after the conquest of power by one or several revolutionary parties, the danger of their bureaucratic degeneration or of an insufficiently coherent internationalist orientation on their behalf would be considerably hindered by the existence of a powerful International, independent from them because assembling revolutionary parties

But the International can in no sense be seen just as an accumulation of national parties. An International, and internationalism cannot be just a nice idea. It has to be concrete - it has to take the form of an organisation which does work internationally. A strong International will be a greater strength for the building of national revolutionary parties.

Take for example an international question such as today's imperialist war drive, or at an earlier period the war in Vietnam. Can these be considered simply 'national' questions? On the contrary: they require international campaigns against them. That requires organisation. Similarly it would be false to believe that the Nicaraguan and Salvadorian revolutions are an affair for the American comrades, or the Polish events for European ones. Neither from the point of view of the needs of international solidarity, nor from the point of view of influencing and winning currents to organise themselves in these countries, nor from the point of view of exploiting the international repercussions in the workers movements, do crucially depend on how much the weight of Fourth International as a whole, and as an international organisation, is brought to bear on these pro-

It is the same with key party building tasks of the Fourth International such as its drive today to implant itself in the industrial working class - the turn to industry. Initiatives for this may start in particular countries, but the forms, precise tactics and leadership must be decided nationally (as is

The need for a revolutionary International tive process.

from different countries.

these events create a 'division of lahour' blems.

45

, that

. Success in all these tasks will

specified by the statutes of the International) but the general turn and drive must be led forward by the International as whole and as an organisation. This is the only way to ensure the process goes forward and simultaneously, to ensure that costly errors can be avoided by national sections through mistaking particular local feaures for basic trends, illegitimately transposing the forms adopted in other sections to different

A whole series of other examples could be added to this list - anti- nuclear work, Iran, the international abortion campaign. These organised activities by the International do not cut across but aid the building of na-

Put more precisely we may say that the International in this aspect has to deal with and orient to the key developments, the 'weak links' chain of international reaction both for the objective needs of the class struggle and for party building purposes. This itself is a reflection of the nature of the process of permanent revolution - a process where the revolution develops unevenly with fierce outbreaks in particular weak links, with international ramifications and international tasks for solidarity party building resulting from them. In this sense again this poses crucial questions of international organisation - and the expression of this

Even now, before it has mass parties which have actually led revolutions, the Fourth International in no sense is an international organisation solely limited to fields of programme and political analysis, internationalist propaganda and education. With a correct understanding of its role, and with correct functioning, the Fourth International is already capable of organising internatinal actions — actions which mass parties could of course organise with much greater effieicency but which they refuse to do because they have long ceased to be revolutionary formations. To show that this is no theoretical speculation but a concrete reality we can take a few outstanding examples from the recent history of the Fourth International.

In the late fifties, the small French section of the Fourth International was the only current in the French labour movement to act consistently in active solidarity and support of the Algerian revolution (several groups of individuals outside the organised labour movement also acted in that way).

The Fourth International, much weaker at that time than now, actually succeeded in setting up the first factory producing light modern weapons for

- the forces of the Fourth International throughout the world, in the middle and late sixties, were very actively engaged, in many countries in leading positions, in organising and co-ordinating mass actions in solidarity with the

Vietnamese revolution. In particular, the role of our comrades in the USA in organising a massive anti-war movement made objectively an enormous contribution to the victory of the Vietnamese revolution by forcing upon US imperialism the withdrawal of US troops from Vietnam.

- in 1971, the Fourth International was the only organisation to launch a worldwide protest (including through its own Sri Lanka comrades) against the mass murder and oppression of the revolutionary youth of that island by the Bandaranaike government which was supported by Washington, Lon-

46 conditions etc.

tional parties.

in real international campaigns and initiatives.

the Algerian revolution in a period isolated from any international help.

International Marxist Review when that struggle was practically

don, Moscow, Peking, New Delhi, Islamabad, i.e. practically all established powers and states in the world. The life of the leader of the JVP, Rohane Wijeweera, was saved as a result of that international action.

- when the revolutionary peasant leader of Peru, Hugo Blanco, was first condemned to death by the authorities of his country, the Fourth International organised a world-wide defence campaign which saved his life. When he was later exiled from his country, a similar campaign was organised for

- when the decaying Franco dictatorship condemned six Basque nationalists to death at the infamous Burgos trial in December 1970 the Fourth throughout Europe to save their lives. As a result of these actions by the

Fourth International and others the death sentence was not carried out.

- when, after the overthrow of the infamous Shah dictatorship, the Khomeini forces, in summer 1979, started to repress the revolutionary left and the oppressed nationalities such as the Kurds in Iran, they singled out, among others, the young Trotskyist organisation for attack because of its solidarity with the Kurdish struggle. Fourteen comrades were arrested and condemned to death. The Fourth International succeeded in organising the largest international defence campaign in its history in favour of these comrades, receiving the support of many of the mass currents of the European labour movement and large part of the trade unions elsewhere in the world.

As a result of these actions the comrades were not executed and afterwards

- starting in 1979 the Fourth International has been organising or participating on a world scale in solidarity campaigns with the Nicaraguan and

Salvadorian revolutions. This had a significant scope, even with material gains for the revolution, in Canada, France, Spain, Mexico, Columbia, the

United States, Switzerland, Belgium and other countries.

-following the strikes and crisis in summer 1980 in Poland the Social

Democratic and mass working class organisations at first rejected, despite many words to the contrary, building practical solidarity with the new

Polish workers unions. The Fourth International was able in a series of countries to take the first initiatives to send delegations, material aid, establish links with the workers organisations to aid the Polish workers struggle and build a campaign against the threat of military intervention.

9. From a cadre organisation to mass parties and a mass International

Finally we may note a last ditch defence against the idea that it is necessary to build a revolutionary International today. The argument is sometimes advanced ' Well, of course, a revolutionary International is necessary; national parties alone are not enough; but it cannot be built now.

', and even cuts off working with other revolutionaries. We must wait for great events, and mass parties, which alone can create a mass revolutionary International current — that is the way the Third Interna-

As we have already seen this argument is not even historically correct — the Bolshevik leadership were already oriented to the construction of a new

International before the Russian revolution (indeed from the collapse of the old International onwards). More important than historical error however

The need for a revolutionary International his return. This met with success too.

International organised powerful mass actions all were free.

It is 'premature' tional was formed. '

47 and demonstrations

48 International Marxist Review this argument misunderstands the whole dynamic by which authentically mass revolutionary parties are built.

The argument advanced against building a revolutionary International today not actually an argument against building a revolutionary International, but against building any revolutionary organisation at all, even on a national scale. In the overwhelming majority of countries it is improbable that revolutionary organisations of a mass character will be built now or in a very near future. The fact this argument is not applied against building revolutionary organisations at a national level but is so used at an international one, shows only the weight of national boundaries and the nation state bears down.

Once there is agreement on basic politics then the more developed and stronger the form of 'organisation the better is the application of these politics. This is the basic principle of organisation on a national level. It applies precisely on an international level. The links between the different national sections, their common experiences, the simple fact of having far more minds and class struggle experiences to bring to bear on the problems does, and inevitably must, aid politics enormously. Anything else is to substitute idealism, belief in timeless programmes, 'inspired leaders' etc. for a basic materialist understanding on how politics is developed.

Indeed we might put it paradoxically by saying that in a certain sense, that of maintaining a correct a political orientation and understanding, it is particularly necessary to build an International when national revolutionary organisations are not of a mass character — because the pressures on small formations to fall into one-sided appreciations, subjectivism, etc, are truly enormous. They can only be neutralised to a certain point by integration in an international organisation. This is not an argument that an International would no longer be necessary when there are mass parties, because then there exist different types of tasks, pressures and needs which require an International. But it shows clearly why the whole argument of 'waiting' to build an international is thoroughly false.

It was for this reason that Trotsky was above all concerned to create the Fourth International before the outbreak of the Second World War - at the end of which he knew the opportunities for building revolutionary organisations would greatly increase, but also the scale of events and national pressures would be truly enormous. The result was as Trotsky had foreseen. The groups of the Fourth International survived the war and emerged strengthened from its great events and tests, even if their growth was much slower than Trotsky had thought. The national revolutionary organisations were shattered and dispersed amid a hurricane of subjectivism, confusion, national capitulation. The POUM in Spain, SAP in Germany, RSAP in Holland, PSOP in France, the Shachtmanites in the US etc. all disappeared. It was the preparation for these great events, including the task of consciously building an international organisation, that alone allowed the organisations of the Fourth International to come through the huge test of the war and its struggles and to emerge strengthened.

A similar experience has occurred in Europe and the United States in the period since the May/June 1968 events in France and their international effects. Out of these events, and the social processes which produced them, not merely the forces of the Fourth International but a whole series of other

organisations seeking a revolutionary road developed on a European scale

- the latter often initially growing much more rapidly than the Fourth In-

But the struggle in Europe is a very long and serious one and that in the

USA even more so. The ruling classes in the imperialist countries will not be overthrown on the basis of one or two great explosions but only on the basis of severe and protracted struggles requiring many different political turns and solutions. The organisations which had grown rapidly after 1968, but rejected a fully constituted revolutionary programme and International, were thrown into total crisis, and in the great majority of cases shattered and disappeared, by the first serious problem encountered - that of the bourgeois counter-offensive from the second half of the 1970s onwards.

(For example, the KPD in West Germany, PT in Spain, Lotta Continua in Italy, MES in Portugal). The organisations of the Fourth International and Trotskyism in contrast, while naturally not wholly escaping the objective situation and suffering some setbacks compared to the earlier gains, nevertheless essentially maintained themselves and their organisations intact and in a position to prepare for the next upswing in struggle. This included consolidating themselves organisationally and increasing their implantation in

These different results were not simply due to international organisation. They also depended on their political programme — although it is no accident that those with the basically correct positions demonstrated in practice to be most adequate for meeting the situation were also those who understood the need to engage in building a revolutionary International.

Nevertheless the 'organisational' fact of the building of this International simultaneously with the national organisation, and all the political conclusions that flowed from it, was a powerful element in providing a more coherent, rounded and basic political stability, an ability to orient on the basic features and not get lost in side issues, which was a major element in the different results between the Trotskyists and the other organisations.

This 'organisational' aspect of the building of revolutionary parties and a revolutionary International even when only existing as a small force, or more precisely the understanding that all questions of politics have organisational consequences, is one of the most basic aspects of Leninism.

The view that simply out of great struggles and events an adequate organisation will be 'spontaneously' created, a leadership spontaneously arise, a strategy be spontaneously developed, or that all this can be created in the short space of time in revolutionary crises, is idealism.

The masses, of course, only achieve revolutionary consciousness, only fully break with reformism, under conditions of mass revolutionary events

- events which by their very nature are very limited in time. But the organisation and leadership itself must be prepared in advance through years of hard struggles. This is one of the basic dialectics of revolution which

Lenin was the first among his contemporaries to fully understand and to

The Bolshevik party with a real revolutionary policy in 1917 was the result of years of work to build a cadre organisation with links with the masses, but not yet of mass dimensions, which was created before the revolutionary outbreaks of 1905 and 1917. The idea that we must 'wait' for ternational.

turn into a practical reality.

IMR Spring 82 - D

49

The need for a revolutionary International the working class, despite some other losses.

great events before struggling to build a revolutionary party, or a revolutionary International, is to fall into spontaneism and to abandon the terrain

We can show this by looking not only at the great achievements and strengths of revolutionaries such as Luxemburg, Liebknecht or Trotsky on some basic theoretical issues were superior to Lenin before 1917 - but also their errors - the reason why Trotsky was making no idle personal gesture when he said that on this basic question Lenin had been correct against all his opponents and on which had depended the outcome of the revolution itself. We will look first at the negative case. Prior to 1918 Luxemburg and

Liebknecht were not faced in Germany with the immediate perspective of the creation of a mass revolutionary party. It took the revolution of 1918 and the struggle afterwards to break sections of the proletariat from the

There was nothing Luxemburg and Liebknecht could have done to voluntaristically create a mass party before 1919. But what was possible in Germany, and which they failed to undertake, was to create a serious political cadre organisation, a fraction in the SPD prior to 1914, which grouped the most advanced workers, women, and youth, who were rejecting the policies of the reformist leaderships of the mass organisations. Under the conditions of authentically revolutionary crises of the 1918-19 type, this sort of organisation, which could have been thousands, could have fused with real currents of the masses to create, with a solid leadership, the revolutionary party of the masses, with hundreds of thousands of worker members, without which all talk of a victorious revolution in a major country is mere

What cannot be achieved however, even in the most revolutionary situation, is to go from nothing, or from small groups of a few hundred, to the creation of a mass revolutionary party capable of achieving victory.

The tragedy of the German revolution was that when war broke our Luxemburg and Liebknecht had an organised force of no more than a few hundred people, and even those not politically homogeneous. Therefore when

1918 came they were totally unable to influence the upsurge of the masses and Luxemburg was even defeated within her own organisation by the ultra-lefts who pursued the fatally wrong line of December 1918-March

It was the same type of disastrous mistake which was made by Trotsky prior to 1917 — when not merely did he not join the Bolsheviks, which was the biggest mistake of his entire life, but when he did not build up a serious

In consequence Trotsky entered the Russian Revolution with an excellent programme, and some brilliant cadres, but with an organisation (the

Mezhrayoutsi) so small that it could never have built even in the revolutionary conditions of Russia a party capable of taking power in 1917.

It was Lenin who prior to this period, including in the ultra-difficult phases of black reaction when he was working with tiny groups, who had built up the organisation actually capable in 1917 of fusing with the mass

In Russia the first groups of revolutionaries, first a few tens, then hundreds and then a few thousands, were consolidated from the 1880s on-

50 on which Lenin was superior to his contemporaries.

phrasemongering.

1919.

force in Russia of any major dimensions.

process and leading the revolution.

International Marxist Revieu' domination of the reformist and centrist organisations.

wards. However even by the time of the famous Second Congress of the

RSDLP in 1903, the organised Russian revolutionaries, contrary to some general impression, were still only a few thousands. The first fusion of the

Bolsheviks with the masses, as a faction of the RDLP, came only in 1905 - twenty years after the start of systematic organised Marxist work oriented towards Russia and 11 years after the start of Lenin's and attempts to create a party. But both prior to 1905, and then again after 1907, the Bolsheviks succeeded in building up a real cadre organisation in Russia — one again that survived the period of reaction which started immediately after 1914.

Periodically this organisation succeeded in authentically participating in mass struggles and fusing with sections of the masses - above all in 1905 and

But the actual dimensions of this cadre, although not insignificant, was still extremely limited compared to a mass party - for example in February

1917 the Bolsheviks had approximately 15-20,000 members. However this entire apparatus cadre meant that in periods of huge struggle, and when therefore the objective possibility of building a mass party existed, the

Bolsheviks could fuse with sections of the masses to build such parties. For example by October 1917 the Bolsheviks had grown to over 240,000 members from their original February number - an increase of over tenfold. But this did not result, as in Germany in 1919, in unlimited confusion, errors, lack of leadership ete but on the contrary the fusing of the existing simultaneously concretising and developing not only its organisational structure but also its political line. The key to this was precisely the cadre formation and nucleus built up by the Bolsheviks prior to 1917.

This example illustrates the dialectic of organisations and masses which

Lenin understood, with triumphant results. Tragically, Luxemburg or Trotsky prior to 1917 did not. We should honour the great revolutionaries but not follow their mistakes - when they themselves later realised they had

It is this fundamental lesson of practical politics that the Fourth International applies today. It does not believe that it is yet a mass International, nor that it can become so in a unilineal fashion without fusions with other revolutionary forces, currents coming from the mass parties etc. These will be products of authentic mass struggles and political developments which cannot be precipitated voluntaristically by the Fourth International. But to prepare such parties is vital. And this can only be done by constructing the strongest possible organisation now and not simply waiting and commenting on events. To do that is to revert into a pre-Leninist past and in the name of

'realism' fall into utopias. Furthermore the construction of the International, as we have seen, does not hinder but aids the construction of national revolutionary organisations and parties - and they in turn aid the construction of the International and national revolutionary parties in other countries on which, finally, the fate of the revolution in any particular coun-

Furthermore because they do not correspond to sectarian concerns and stunts, but to the real international logic of the class struggle, the activities

The need for a revolutionary International in 1912-14.

vanguard organisation made distastrous errors.

10. The Fourth International today try will depend.

51 with the decisive sections of the masses —

52 International Marxist Review and campaigns of the International do not cut across but aid the process of the construction of national revolutionary parties. Again we can show this through concrete examples. - the important role of the Jeunesse Communiste Revolutionnaire (JCR) in May 1968 in France and the creation of the Ligue Communiste out if it, an achievement supported by real political and material international aid, was a major step forward in party building in France. But that step forwards enormously aided the construction of the Fourth International and other national parties. A whole series of sections today — the Spanish, the Swedish, the British, the Antilles, to take only the most direct examples - owe either their very existence or a major part of their strength to that success in France. - the campaign to save the life of Hugo Blanco was objectively required by the needs of international solidarity, independently of any considerations of recruitment or party building. But because it did correspond to objective needs it was also a significant step forward for building the party. Hugo Blanco is today the best known figure on the Peruvian left. This, together with the assistance given by the International, aids the building of a significant national section in Peru, building sections in other parts of Latin America, and building the Fourth International as a whole. - the campaign against the Vietnam war was dictated by objective considerations and should have been launched even if not one single member would have been gained. It was crucial not only for the outcome of the antiwar movement but also enormously important for building the Fourth International in many countries, that there was in the United States, in the chief imperialist power waging the war, an organisation, the Socialist Workers Party, in political solidarity with the Fourth International. The existence of this organisation helped build not only the anti-war movement but also the Fourth International - with particularly direct implications in countries such as Australia, New Zealand, and Britain but also a general effect in the whole International. - the international campaign against the Burgos trials undertaken by the Fourth International was dictated by the needs of solidarity. But its result, against showing its correct character, was not only to aid saving the militants but to help win over a whole section of Basque nationalist revolutionaries to the Spanish section of the Fourth International.

In short it is not only theory, or the experience of the mass parties of the Communist International, but the concrete tests of the class struggle in this period which shows that the building of national revolutionary parties and a revolutionary International are not counterposed but interdependent parts of the class struggle.

← Soviet Influence and Neo-Colonialism in Black Africa · The Sectarian Mythology of the 'International Committee' →

Something wrong on this page?